Yes, I'd agree 100% with that. I have two Barnard 'P' action based F-Class rifles both originally with 0.473" bolt-faces. One has very happily translated from 308 Win to the straight 284 and I've never regretted the choice.
The other went from 6XC to 284 Shehane - it shot very well, won me a few medals, but didn't provide much more MV than the other 284 in its 'straight' form and I decided 2,830 fps or so with 175/180s was all I needed anyway. So when its barrel was finished I went through all these iterations about possible 30s with a 0.473" case-head and came to the conclusion none were worth pursuing. (30 Cal was important as I own vast numbers of quality mid weight bullets in the calibre, mostly VLDs, that I wanted to use up and frankly there are few buyers these days for 185/190gn examples of this bullet type.) Eventually, a new magnum face bolt body came from New Zealand and the rifle is just finishing its first season as a 300 RSAUM. With hindsight, this was the correct decision on the bolt. I only wonder if the WSM might have been a bit better cartridge choice on the basis of posts in this thread, but the 284 remains my main long-range F rifle and I keep the loads MVs down a bit on the SAUM.