• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

Ready for new rifle. 223 - Savage vs Howa

Bought a cheap Howa last year and after struggling to achieve decent groups I scoped the chamber and discovered an eccentric bore-chamber relationship. Sent rifle in for warranty service and Howa sent a new unit after admitting the chamber has "issues". Received new Howa and it also has chamber eccentricity "issues". I've never seen this type of thing with the several Savages I've owned. I will never purchase another Howa.
 
Instead of buying the Savage BVSS, I would suggest as others have, to purchase just a Savage Action and go from there....the stock on the BVSS, especially the grip area was so fat for me, I couldn't get a consistent "hold" on it...plus the blind magazine...those were my two "cons" regarding the BVSS....
 
Bought a cheap Howa last year and after struggling to achieve decent groups I scoped the chamber and discovered an eccentric bore-chamber relationship. Sent rifle in for warranty service and Howa sent a new unit after admitting the chamber has "issues". Received new Howa and it also has chamber eccentricity "issues". I've never seen this type of thing with the several Savages I've owned. I will never purchase another Howa.

Just out of my curiosity, how fo you find the eccentricity issue?
 
eccentricity issue??? lf chamber and rifling were misaligned l'm surprised a round would even seat in the chamber or the bolt would close!!!
 
Easily determined by looking at lands as they fade in the leade. If some lands extend beyond others in a sine pattern then the bore-chamber relationship is not true.

Well, if that is true, and I have no way to doubt it, then that explains the TC 223 barrel I had. I looked at it with borescope after trying to get it to shoot under 4 inches! I chalked that up to factory crap and shipped it off.
 
True but there are still some around. As I said I know a gentleman who has a NIB 223 that he would be willing to part with. Mine is the most accurate mass produced factory rifle I've ever had the pleasure to shoot.

The XR-100 probably won't be any harder to find than the Howa in 223. There are a few on Gunbroker at the moment: https://www.gunbroker.com/item/771755828

His price is high for a used rifle but they do have a reputation for accuracy.

I bought an XR-100 in .204 when they first came out. Didn't like the 12" twist and didn't like the then available brass, so I built a 20 Tac with a very heavy 26" Krieger with a 10" twist, and used Lapua brass - I could shoot it in benchrest matches, it is that good. The XR-100 action is an excellent choice to build on.
 
I’ve been doing a lot of searching on the net and forums for a new rifle. The main purpose will be for ground squirrels and prairie dogs at distances beyond what my 17 HMR and 22 Mag cannot reach. I haven’t seen recent reviews, (2017 or 2018) of the two rifles side by side. I have decided on the .223 Remington since I have dies and lots of cases already.

This is what I’m looking at:

1. .223 cal. 1-12 twist

2. Ground squirrels & prairie dogs.

3. Scope will be either a Vortex PST FFP 6-24x50 or Sightron 10-50x60. I have both scopes now.

4. Will be shooting 40 to 50 grain bullets.

5. Howa 1500 Varminter Supreme HWR95112 or Savage 12 BVSS

6. Will add replacement trigger for either rifle. Not a fan at all of the accu trigger.

Both rifles get good reviews on the accuracy. Some favor the Howa action over the Savage. I’ve never owned either one, but was able to handle a Savage in the store the other day. While it was not a 223 or the model I wanted, the action did not feel smooth at all and it didn’t lock up smoothly either. I know with the Savage, I can change barrels if so inclined, but I’m not interested in changing calibers.

Any input would be appreciated.

a6baaa7b1a8aac14093337bffdb40bb3.jpg

6587a02abcda5c5be2122a74986b2310.jpg
I have a Howa, that started life as a 308, its now a 6.5x47 lapua, I just had my gun smith rebarrel it. He is a very high end custom gun builder. And in his words he was way impressed with the Howa action and Stock that is pillar bedded. He put on a 26"35 brux 4R barrel with a muzzle break. I have not got to shoot the Brux barrel yet can't wait. It lived one year with a Pac Nor 6.5x47 barrel and was very impressive. So can wait to see what this does. Hard to Beat a Howa.
 
Can you get a 223 with a 12" twist? Don't get me wrong, I prefer a 12" twist since I like to shoot 50 and 55 grain bullets but it seems all the manufacturer's are producing 8" and 9" twists in the 223 Rem these days.

+1 for the Tikka's - great rifles - accurate - smooth bolt - good triggers - but they have an 8" twist.
 
I have a Savage FV12 223 9twist that shoots 55g Noslers Varmageddons (both tipped & HP) half moa all day long. Even in the tupperware stock.
 
Can you get a 223 with a 12" twist? Don't get me wrong, I prefer a 12" twist since I like to shoot 50 and 55 grain bullets but it seems all the manufacturer's are producing 8" and 9" twists in the 223 Rem these days.

+1 for the Tikka's - great rifles - accurate - smooth bolt - good triggers - but they have an 8" twist.
1-8 Twist is preferred in a 223 caliber
Tikka
Ruger
I believe Mossberg all run 1-8
55-77 gr projectiles are mainstream are they not ?
 
Do watcha gotta do....

Last factory rig here,ADL 12T 223 Remington. Shooting cast @2600+ fps... throw a little EA40 epoxy at the stock,along with a 510 Timney set at 2 1/2#... and a 3200 elite scope(off this site)...

Good luck.... cause,I'll take pretty much any bet,just sayin.
 
Skip both and get a Tikka. Swap out the factory trigger spring for an aftermarket “varmint” replacement ($6). You’ll be happy that you went Finn.
 
Skip both and get a Tikka. Swap out the factory trigger spring for an aftermarket “varmint” replacement ($6). You’ll be happy that you went Finn.
The subject of this thread is...
Ready for new rifle. 223 - Savage vs Howa
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
165,834
Messages
2,203,945
Members
79,144
Latest member
BCB1
Back
Top