Dusty, I had the same issue with my BHP. It was fixed with a quick online visit to Brownells for the Cylinder & Slide extended safety, then installed by my local smith. Problem solved for a total cost of about $125 for the safety, shipping and my smiths work.
The subject HP, don't have a pic (yet) of the new C&S safety.
I'm also a lifetime owner, user, carrier of the venerable 1911, and it is the most represented handgun in my safe. But if you love the 1911, then it's cousin the BHP deserves the same love, right?