• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

Got brass troubles. Cause ? Video posted

You’re sizing the case shoulder junction way too much, a couple thousand is all you need. The base should be measured above the web, your number should be smaller than your bolt face simply because you have a tapered case. Try that number again and report back.
I have been using the rcbs die. Is it sizing the diameter of the shoulder way to much or it’s getting bumped back toward the body too much ???? How far up from the case head should I measure. I have never thought of measuring the diameter of a shoulder at the shoulder body junction. I haven’t really heard of anyone doing it either. Just pushing the shoulder back. I’m learning don’t cuss me too bad.
 
Last edited:
Are you talking about the initial firing with new brass ? Or the sizing of the shoulder diameter ?
Yes, Initial firing. Like most all new brass, new, unfired cases are just too short but that's out of our control as reloaders.. My factory 30-06 chamber is 7-8 thou on first firing and I still get over a dozen stout loadings out of Win brass. Your numbers are not at all bad and I think you have a good representation of what 99% of us deal with in normal everyday tolerances.
 
View attachment 1424217You’re currently sizing the shoulder diameter
Redding .008
Hornday .009
RCBS .0045
And nobody thinks that’s a problem ?
That’s why I posed it. For help. I can see it would cause a problem. How to fix ? As far as my shoulder push back goes if I back my die out any I will have a little pressure when closing my bolt. I can try it again later hopefully to test or does my die not fit the chamber worth a shit
 
If it were actually sizing that much than yes but without an optical comparator or a CMM machine. I wouldn't use any of these numbers...
I have been using the rcbs die. I knew just off of feel alone it was working my brass the least. I never heard of measuring the shoulder diameter only shoulder set back.
 
Post #137: "Whatsupdoc" had the same failure point on Starline brass with a chamber that he said he knows is a tight chamber and tried two different dies. He managed 7-8 loading's, which is much better in my opinion than the OP's 4 but still not great.. Do a google search and see if you can hit on any more complaints in other shooting forums/ pages.
 
Hard to close bolt- fix by pushing back shoulder
Bolt click on bolt open Or hard to open - case just ahead of web expanded too big for chamber.
 
That’s where I measure it.
Two out of your three dies are grossly over sizing. Heres an example of a quality 308 die that sizes beautifully and rounds chamber freely before and after ignition with indefinite case life.
I do use the rcbs die. After the first 100 rounds 1 round per each piece of brass I used the hornady dies. The other firings I used the rcbs dies they felt like they was working the brass the least. I used the hornady and small base reddings just to compare measurements I do not use them for sizing in this rifle. What would you do since I have learned it’s squeezing the shoulder too much ? In your pictures it looks like your shoulder is getting squeezed .003 is that corrrect ?
 
Hard to close bolt- fix by pushing back shoulder
Bolt click on bolt open Or hard to open - case just ahead of web expanded too big for chamber.
I do not have a hard to open bolt or a click from bolt popping case out of chamber. I Never have on this rifle. I have had a snug bolt close before getting dies adjusted.
 
I do use the rcbs die. After the first 100 rounds 1 round per each piece of brass I used the hornady dies. The other firings I used the rcbs dies they felt like they was working the brass the least. I used the hornady and small base reddings just to compare measurements I do not use them for sizing in this rifle. What would you do since I have learned it’s squeezing the shoulder too much ? In your pictures it looks like your shoulder is getting squeezed .003 is that corrrect ?
That's why we anneal... I make sure to cover the body/ shoulder junction along with the neck when I anneal. Your case neck is being worked back and forth way more than 3 thou, I can promise you that and it doesn't separate. Separation is due to thinning of the material, which is from the lateral force of stretching not from an open and close force. Measure a fired case mouth and then measure it after sizing without the expander ball in the die. You might be surprised how much brass can withstand.
 
Or screw the old barrel back on.
Nothing was wrong with it. I paid for a barrel and it shoots fairly well. I’m going to attempt to use it. If I play around and let the case shoulder stay blowed out but back my die off to just touch the shoulder and maybe squeeze it down .002 I probably will have a snug bolt close is there any down sides to that route if I go that way ? I have always heard and read .001-.002 is where ya want to be
 
View attachment 1423069View attachment 1423070

I had a case separate today which was a first. It’s starline brass bumped back 2-3 thou depending on what day it is, and this was the 4th firing. Many out of the 100 I started with shows a faint line outside on the body where it snapped. Anyways I anneal after every firing. 223 cases. I have seen ( not through personal experiences) the case head separate from over sizing and I have had split necks and I have had primers get blown out but not so much this. Helps. +++EDIT+++ I’ll also add I can not feel anything inside the cases where the line is forming with a paper clip. 94 out of the 100 has the obvious line around the outside of the case. 6 doesn’tView attachment 1423205
Look at the video link I posted on case head separation. Based on the video by an expert he states that the case shoulder gets pushed against the chamber shoulder by the primer, then the body expands tight against the chamber. The entire excess clearance is now between the bolt face and the case head. If you have excessive headspace the case 60,000 PSI wants to blow back towards the bolt. It has nowhere else to go. The location of the case that separates is not in the chamber. The entire case head in front of the .200” line is locked in place.

In any case no matter where the case separates it’s caused by the brass being stretched. It can only stretch if the is a larger than normal gap somewhere. It cannot stretch without a space to get pushed into. I cannot figure out why the case fails at the same mid length location. But the fact is it fails by localized stretching.
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
167,614
Messages
2,236,973
Members
80,628
Latest member
RSH89506
Back
Top