I prefer the bolt lifted.
I also thought about this and when I tested, this design allows the firing pin to release. In other words, the design will fire if the trigger is depressed unless the bolt is opened so far that it isn't "started" into the lugs at all. The feed is not "smooth" and bolt manipulation is clunky and loud.
I should also mention up front, most of the folks who will be using these rifles are very inexperienced at being silent, or running a rifle much at all.
Several times ive been out with someone i have heard them switch safty off. Every time i have had this happen the coyotes stop in their tracks and look straight at that persons direction. Has made easy shots for me though!!.
Same here, which is why I think the design is way too loud.
We typically hunt in pairs, one with shotgun and one with rifle. I have seen them stop in their tracks when my partners slips off their safety even at distances beyond 75 yards out. The shots in my context are usually way closer than this due to cover and obstructions, so typically less than 50 yards and they will hear this click for sure.
On the other rifles, I have detailed the safety switches to silence or greatly reduce the noise, and remind folks to try and be stealthy on the shift.
We would normally be discussing an AR15 safety or a Rem 700 Clone with a Jewel trigger, but my friends have gone out and purchased these Ruger American Predators to dedicate to certain farm trucks and irrigated orchards using no-lead bullets (Barnes 50gr VG) per CA regulations and to avoid pass-throughs.
With the Ruger American safety being on the tang, it will be a challenge unless there are some tweaks to the design, so I was just wondering out loud if anyone has already solved this cause I know it is going to be a problem.