mac86951 said:I'll go ahead and toss in my experience, my lr-308 loves H4350 and I don't have an adjustable gas block, and I use federal 210M (6.5 creedmoor). My 308 load development for a different -10 platform was very different. Your mileage may vary, and expect to try multiple variations and allow your data to point you in the correct direction. Gas guns show different signs than bolt guns, so more information on what to expect is a good thing.
-Mac
Here is the deal.... Armalite rifles (ALL AR-10 & 15s) are designed to function with moderate burning rate powders. Varget, RL-15 IMR 4064/4895 Maybe 3031, but it could be a tad "fast". There are other excellent powders as well, VV and Accurate 4064/2230, plus Hodgdons.
Bolt rifles are not Dwell-time sensitive. The pressure impulse of the load means nothing in a bolt gun since it is not used to cycle the bolt carrier and extract, eject and load the next round. Faster powders give less dwell time, slower powders increase it. Faster powder likely "safe" in your rifle; just not going to function as smoothly.
Slower powders are dangerous. Pressure continuing to build for greater duration than optimum. Maybe if you are shooting XMR4350, which is the fastest of the three 4350s; MAYBE you are okay using it; but for what purpose? The risk is battering your bolt carrier, buffer setup, bolt lugs and barrel extension. Nothing "Good" is gonna come out of that. Just because the 4350 load "performs" don't mean your AR "likes it"...
Armalite does not warrant their rifles when used with handloads. Here is why... Lack Of Awareness and Understanding.
Sierra used to include a lot of articles by men like David Tubb and Gary Anderson. Legendary shooters who have forgotten more about handloading and marksmanship than any gun magazine writer will ever realize existed. There were articles on Gas Gun Loading and Service Rifle applications. What worked in 1985 for the M14/M1a .308win rifle is still valid for the AR-10. Talking the 168 BTHP match bullet with IMR4064 or 4895. No Varget or RL powders available back then. Need to look at updated info, but those powders are still excellent for that bullet, just some like Varget are maybe less temperature sensitive.
To safely shoot your gas-operated semi-auto rifle you MUST Understand the variables and Cyclic Functions.
There is no "pressure sign" loading for these weapons unless you have no regard for your safety or that of others, or the longevity of your gear.