• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

Fake news in gun mags now?

I have a related story about group size from one of our top gunsmiths in the UK. Years ago, this guy comes into his shop and starts asking about putting a stainless match barrel on a run of the mill Parker-Hale 308 deer rifle. The gunsmith listens a while and thinks 'timewaster' and declines the job on the basis that the rifle owner won't get value from an expensive rebarrel of a P-H 1100 or 1200, whatever it was. The owner gets visibly perturbed and says: "I'll have you know this is a half-MOA shooter!" to which the 'smith's reply is twofold - "B*ll*cks and even if it did do that, which I don't believe, why would you want to have it rebarrelled?" Exit disgruntled individual and the 'smith thinks, last I'll see of him, and no great loss either.

Some weeks later, the guy DOES reappear waving something like a PL50 50 metre pistol target and demands to speak to the boss. He plunks the target down on the counter with a flourish "See there!", and waits for approbation from all present. The 'smith looks at it and he said to me there had to be maybe 30 or 40 shots spread all over it - not a group of any sort never mind half-MOA. So he asks what this proves as he's frankly out of his depth here. The proud owner points to four or five shots out of the 30 that happen to have formed a random half-inch pattern or thereabouts and says "See! A half-MOA group!"

I could probably shoot Tony Boyer size groups too if I could choose any 5 out of 50 on the paper. Second thoughts ............ No, Tony Boyer would still beat me. :)
 
One of the best examples that I remember was the Remington R51. I read a GLOWING article about Remington's new handgun. Being a revival of an old design, it was cooler than any other new gun, it was fantastic, accurate, blah blah blah. Soon after the article was published, I was at my LGS and spied one under the glass. I asked to look at it and they all spoke up with comments like "junk", "you don't want it", don't waste your money, etc. I insisted on looking it over so they let me. I pulled the slide once and handed it back. It felt like it was packed with sand. Nice job on the article, American Rifleman! Of course it's no wonder why Remington is in trouble, either.
 
Artical basicly states 1" ammo. Is that really a selling point? Now factory ammo that shoots .5" would be something to write about.
 
I'd bet that you guys are having a heart attack about nothing. Watch for a correction in the next issue of the magazine and I'll bet that they will say that they were trying to say that the group data was the best 4 of a certain number of five-shot groups...

Most people can't spell any more (I see it all the time on this forum) so it wouldn't be very surprising to me to find out that the author just couldn't write a sentence worth a d@mn.
 
Gun mags, including American Rifleman, kind of left me in the dust.

I'm not very interested in any of the new stuff, don't own an AR, and know nothing and don't care about hot rod pistols.

I think that if someone came out with a magazine that interested me, no one else would buy it.:rolleyes: jd
 
in the last years yeah but when i first started getting it , it was much better . best gun mags i ever read were handloader and rifle when dave wolfe had them.

I am in total agreement with this statement, Rifle in particular had some good writers and not the amount of BS that the newer version has.

drover
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
166,585
Messages
2,221,507
Members
79,726
Latest member
radiowaves88
Back
Top