dellet
Gold $$ Contributor
You’re absolutely correct, the government can’t force a manufacturer to sell anything. They can only control the price or profit.The US federal or state government can only stipulate "If you want to sell product X it must meet these standards" or "a percentage of them must meet...". A corporation can always opt not to sell the product at all, rather than go broke trying to meet the standard and still succeeding in the market. I'll say again: government cannot force a company to sell anything.
In other countries, governments have had to nationalize (assume control of) private companies to meet their economic goals. For example the UK has nationalized many industrial companies such as British Steel, Rolls-Royce, British Leyland, British Aerospace, and British Telecom to name just a few.
In the US, peacetime and post-WW II nationalizations have been rare, temporary and mostly involved financial institutions or transportation systems in distress, and "too big to fail" measures in the financial crisis of 2009.
-
The problem is, that same government can keep me from buying, importing or building a product unless it meets their mandate, if I want to use it. No matter how you slice it, the government is controlling the market.
This is an argument over semantics. This is like one of the old federal laws concerning automatic knives. Never illegal to own, just illegal to buy, sell, or transport.












