• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

NF Comp 15-55x52 or March. HM 10-60/Majesta 8-80x56

JBT47

Silver $$ Contributor
I’ve owned March and NF FFP MRAD scopes. But typically I have chosen other brand FFP premium scopes due to better glass/image quality and the past few years I’ve bought Schmidt, ZCO, & Tangent specifically for glass preferences in those branded FFP MRAD scopes.

I am an unknown distance shooter and typically buy FFP optics w/ 0.1 MiL adj turrets. High mag to me is max power of about 27x.
The last couple of years I have competed in some F-TR and have done very well while using my FFP 5-25 or 27 Mag scope with coarse MRAD adj’s. My scopes are are obviously sub optimal for known distance F-Class shooting to say the least. Reticles are too large/coarse and turrets far to coarse adjustments with the tenth MIL clicks vs .125moa click adjustments.

I have enjoyed the F-TR comps a lot so I am ready to spend money on more appropriate high mag 1/8 moa adj SFP scopes. It would be nice to dial 40x or more on a 600 yd target and maintain a fine aim point. My rifle set up is fine but heavy FFP scopes are the wrong tool for square range high accuracy shooting. I need high mag SFP with fine 1/8 moa adjustment clicks.

I trust the NF brand (as well as March) re: durability, reliability, robustness, and overall mechanical quality. So why choose March when could buy two NF Comp’s for about same price?

Plus, NF is lighter weight slightly and I like to have as much weight as possible in my barrels rather than in a scope. Is the glass in either March HM and/or Majesta really better and brighter than NF Comp.? Most top shooters it seems choose the NF Comp.
I understand we all see things slightly differently and the above questions are subjective in nature to some extent. However, I believe glass quality (clarity, brightness, resolution, contrast, low light performance) opinions of experienced users can get closer to objective opinions.

Just want to see consensus among those who have owned and tested each. Are your choices based on economics, overall optical quality, mirage considerations, or some other driver?

I may buy used and try both over the next year to answer such questions if responses to this thread go both ways. Buying used optics is a win in that I don’t lose as much if decide to resale after trying it out.

Thanks
 
Last edited:
NF Comp glass is really hard to beat and thats what i have on my 600yd rifles, I have the Majesta on 1K HG and the extra magnification helps when the conditions are right, Majesta glass is significantly darker when you shoot at max 80 power, I shoot benchrest 600/1K and scope weight doesn't make much of a difference if you make the class weight
 
At our range, I rarely see a March, almost every shooter is using a NF comp. I have been using one for a few years and just love it.
 
I own a Majesta, NF comp. and a March HM 10-60x56
Wanted to see if their is a real difference worth that money
In my opinion, go with the NF comp 15-55x52
It's just a clear and slightly brighter, with the March your only gaining
the extra magnification.
Depending on what reticle you like or are comfortable with,
the DDR-2 has a floating dot but no hold offs.
The FCR-1 has fine lines and some hold offs but no floating dot.
 
I have both and with all due respect to the other posters above, there is simply not comparison between the NF comp and the Majesty. The Majesty glass is at another level. The Majesta at 80X handles a bad mirage much, much better than the NF at 55X.
Dont get me wrong, I love my NF Comp, and I shoot it all the time on my BR at 600yds. But let's be real people. No comparison to March Majesta....If you have bad eyes like I do, you will love the Majesta. If your eyesight is excellent, then the NF should be sufficient...
 
I have both and with all due respect to the other posters above, there is simply not comparison between the NF comp and the Majesty. The Majesty glass is at another level. The Majesta at 80X handles a bad mirage much, much better than the NF at 55X.
Dont get me wrong, I love my NF Comp, and I shoot it all the time on my BR at 600yds. But let's be real people. No comparison to March Majesta....If you have bad eyes like I do, you will love the Majesta. If your eyesight is excellent, then the NF should be sufficient...
I agree.
I looked through a 18x80x56 about a month ago at my local club. One our BOD members had it on a 300 Weatherby Mag.
I had my 30BR on another Bench with the 15x55 x52 NF Comp.

I’m not saying the big March is worth over twice the price, but I could REALLY see the difference at 200 yards on a bright sunny day.

Other things being equal, a 56mm lens simply gathers more light than a 52mm.
 
If one can afford it the March is it, no knock on Nightforce at all as they are good and builded like tanks. I liked my NSX 8-32x56 very much, but looking though them side by side told the story or to my eyes. Do everyone is different,!
 
I have both and with all due respect to the other posters above, there is simply not comparison between the NF comp and the Majesty. The Majesty glass is at another level. The Majesta at 80X handles a bad mirage much, much better than the NF at 55X.
Dont get me wrong, I love my NF Comp, and I shoot it all the time on my BR at 600yds. But let's be real people. No comparison to March Majesta....If you have bad eyes like I do, you will love the Majesta. If your eyesight is excellent, then the NF should be sufficient...
wonder if this glass quality thing is really as personal as shooters eyes , I have NF comp and just got Majesta 8-80X and my eyes are not perfect but today at the 1000 yards with first time out Majesta NF comp was clear winner , at 40-50X with mid day mirage NF comp image was brighter and my eyes could see details/impacts better , maybe its shooters eyes ?
 
wonder if this glass quality thing is really as personal as shooters eyes , I have NF comp and just got Majesta 8-80X and my eyes are not perfect but today at the 1000 yards with first time out Majesta NF comp was clear winner , at 40-50X with mid day mirage NF comp image was brighter and my eyes could see details/impacts better , maybe its shooters eyes ?
I've got a comp..I'll trade for the Majesta. That would make my 3rd.
 
wonder if this glass quality thing is really as personal as shooters eyes , I have NF comp and just got Majesta 8-80X and my eyes are not perfect but today at the 1000 yards with first time out Majesta NF comp was clear winner , at 40-50X with mid day mirage NF comp image was brighter and my eyes could see details/impacts better , maybe its shooters eyes ?
I’ve experienced the same when switching between a Vortex GE and a NF Comp. Used the GE for 3 years, then upgraded another rifle this year to the NF Comp. At first, I could “see” better thru the GE. After using both for about 3 weeks set to 40X, the opposite is now the case. The scopes didn’t change, thinking it has to be something in our vision. My ophthalmologist could not explain why…
 
The reason I found your comment so funny is that it is so timely.
Earlier today I wrote this on another thread.

 
My question on March is why so many for sale. Lots of shooters I know have went from several to 1 or none.
That's a new one on me. I visited the Marketplace here for optics, and I had to get to page 12 or something to find any mention of March for sale. It was actually sold inside of 3 hours and it was not a Majesta. I did see some people LOOKING for a March and another selling a March, one of the older models, and it was immediately picked up.
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
165,296
Messages
2,193,250
Members
78,819
Latest member
DJT
Back
Top