• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

Chronograph? Why do I need one?

In the interest of honesty and clarity, I've been using an optical chrono until this purchase.
As we all know, there are two kinds of people, those that shot their chrono and those who will. I did both!!!
My goal is long range shooting. I've had great success out to 600+ yards numerous occasions but not consistently. I do not have a highfalutin scale but the one I have is accurate and I know this because where I work I use precision instrumentation that requires calibration checks and my friend in the calibration department checked my scale and she said it is indeed accurate. With that being said, I do not allow
any variation in my charges. If I'm looking for, say 42 grains of Accurate 2460, I get 42 grains which means I will make adjustments until I get 42 grains...exactly. Despite being so OCD, I still occasionally see ES' shoot to the high side for no apparent reason.
My groups are typically sub-MOA (1/4"-1/2"). One of my goals is to put 5 shots through one hole. I've come close many times but not consistently.
As to whether or not I already know the answers? Hardly, I typically shoot 150-250 rounds per week because I'm in search of the "demon tweak" that will give me my goal. I'm close but I spend a lot of time and money dancing around the "perfect round".
Your shooting 200 rounds a week. Sounds like you would need a new barrel every 10 weeks. Some guns just won't shoot. Beating them to death won't make them better. Both of my varmint hunting rifles shoot under .5" with just about any load and a bad es. Kreiger barrels. Shooting competitive groups cost a lot of money for the best equipment.
 
Simple answer to your question......you don't. Good accurate information from Bart. I will say using the Lab Radar totally changed my outlook on primers but I do not use it to develope a load.I would not miss a beat without it. I would feel handicapped without tuners.
 
The crony will let you know your average FPS, which is nice to know, just to know what your load is doing.
And it is a necessary tool to help you take that FPS and other factors of your load and scope settings and work out a data sheet, for scope adjustment for dialing your shots to a ranged distance.
Those two factors alone, are my main reason for have one.
 
STD DEV's in the high 30's to low 40's'. ES' in the 40's-50's
And then I had some fantastic chrono numbers but the groups were horrible. STD DEV in the single to low double digits and ES' in the 5-7 range!
What's up with that?
That doesn't jive. ES are much higher given those large SD which seem unbelievable.
Agreed. I have also never encountered a case where standard deviation is greater than extreme spread.
 
It really depends on your goal. If your goal is shooting at 100 yards at moa, a chrono is not really necessary. If you are hunting deer out to 200 yards, probably not necessary. But if you shoot farther, how are you going to be able to hit anything without knowing the trajectory? Trajectory is very dependent on velocity. No chronograph no velocity data.

If you want to shrink your groups to 1/2 moa 90% of the time, a chronograph is a very useful tool. You could do it without one, but i suspect it would take you far more time, bullets, powder and primers.

The 2 best things a chronograph can tell you is why a load is not performing well and velocity so you can see when you are close to min or max pressure. The latter is important because most cartridges are designed to perform the best on the closer end of max pressure.

The groups you are seeing at 100 yards that are sub moa and st dev in the 30s-40s I would consider false positives. Especially with a barrel mounted chronograph.
Hmmm...
My barrel is a 22" bull barrel.
I did an experiment with this chrono before deciding to keep it or return it.
I shot 2 groups of 5 shots each.
First 10 was without the chrono attached.
Second 10 were with chrono attached.
I saw no difference, either visually or by measurement.

Ah yes, you made an excellent point!
I did indeed notice, through the chronograph, the target and primer, that I had some issues with 3 different loads I had made. If I didn't have the chrono I probably would have kept shooting them but I stopped mainly because the velocity was showing over 200 fps more than all the others I had already shot which were around 2650-2750 fps. So thank you for your help, I now see a helpful use of a chrono I hadn't considered.
Also, I have segregated my brass by brand but not by lot # nor the number of times the brass has been reloaded though I do have them designated to just the one rifle. I don't have a die set that allows me to set neck tension.
I think this next reload session I will measure the volumes of each case and separate them into their respective groups and see how that works.
Thanks again!
 
Agreed. I have also never encountered a case where standard deviation is greater than extreme spread.
The statement I made is not the way it came across to you. Sorry for the way I posted it.
I had high STD DEV's on some rounds with corresponding ES' which in some cases resulted in stellar groups!
And just the opposite, excellent STD's and ES' with lousy groups.

With that stated, in a reply to another commentary, I realized and stated that there is more that I can do during case prep that I should apply.

What the real issue is (was) that after spending close to $500 for this chrono, was I getting my money's worth out of it. With you and others I have decided that in the end I think it was money well spent.
 
I've seen a couple guys at the range using devices which hold the Magnetospeed off the barrel, seems like an elegant solution to the Magnetospeed-as-a-Tuner problem :).

When I used a Magnetospeed on my barrel the darned thing shot smaller groups, that pissed me off :mad:.
I've seen that as well but after conducting my test as I had stated in another reply, it appears to not be necessary for me to do that so I won't.
 
The statement I made is not the way it came across to you. Sorry for the way I posted it.
I had high STD DEV's on some rounds with corresponding ES' which in some cases resulted in stellar groups!
And just the opposite, excellent STD's and ES' with lousy groups.

With that stated, in a reply to another commentary, I realized and stated that there is more that I can do during case prep that I should apply.

What the real issue is (was) that after spending close to $500 for this chrono, was I getting my money's worth out of it. With you and others I have decided that in the end I think it was money well spent.
Search "positive compensation" to find out why target precision vs velocity variability is not a direct correlation.
 
The crony will let you know your average FPS, which is nice to know, just to know what your load is doing.
And it is a necessary tool to help you take that FPS and other factors of your load and scope settings and work out a data sheet, for scope adjustment for dialing your shots to a ranged distance.
Those two factors alone, are my main reason for have one.
I have yet to use a ballistic trajectory app to determine what to set my scope to, I just hold over and walk my rounds into the target (anything over 400 yards).
Sometimes I can get on target in as little as 3 shots (helps to have a spotter), or it's taken me as many as 30 shots to get on target (no spotter)
Perhaps I should start using a ballistics app and start using the turrets as they are intended...perhaps.
 
Your shooting 200 rounds a week. Sounds like you would need a new barrel every 10 weeks. Some guns just won't shoot. Beating them to death won't make them better. Both of my varmint hunting rifles shoot under .5" with just about any load and a bad es. Kreiger barrels. Shooting competitive groups cost a lot of money for the best equipment.
Nah, if a barrel can wear out a in 2000 rounds then either that's a cheap barrel or max loads are being shot through it and not enough time is given to let it cool off. And/or cleaning methods and frequency are insufficient.
 
There's a lot of drop at 1000 yards fire two bullets 9fps apart and fire two 50fps apart.which two will group tighter.this is main reason for using it and getting your loads up to snuff besides muzzle velocity for your dope
 
So I bought a chronograph, MagnetoSpeed V3. Now what do I use the data for?
I reload for .308 and .223/5.56.
Today I shot approx. 150 rounds of .308.
I had some phenomenal groups well under 1 MOA at 100 yrds and the chrono numbers were not good at all.
STD DEV's in the high 30's to low 40's'. ES' in the 40's-50's
And then I had some fantastic chrono numbers but the groups were horrible. STD DEV in the single to low double digits and ES' in the 5-7 range!
What's up with that?
Also tried some premium factory ammo and the numbers were all over the place and the groups were not nearly as good as most of my reloads.
Again, what's up with that.
How/why do I use a chrono to help me do.....what???
Check out one of Erik Cortina's videos on tuning. He states that ES is related to proper ignition, firing pin mechanism, primers, powder). Speedy Gonzales says that when he gets a new premium action he still gives it a thorough going over. He doesn't say how he inspects it.
 
There's a lot of drop at 1000 yards fire two bullets 9fps apart and fire two 50fps apart.which two will group tighter.this is main reason for using it and getting your loads up to snuff besides muzzle velocity for your dope
Actually won't both potentially group tight...if you have your scope dialed in properly?
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
165,991
Messages
2,207,448
Members
79,255
Latest member
Mark74
Back
Top