I bought one from MidwayUSA that said for new brass and full length resized
I have to use the small base die for my criterion barrel, not the shell holderFor the 308 cartridge case designs, Wilson makes two holders, one for new cases and one for sized cases, i.e., it's a set.
Unless I am missing something which is always a possibility with "senior" brain, both pictures posted show the "new case" holder being used. Do not use the "new case" holder for F/L sized case, use the other case holder.
I have trimmed hundreds of 308 and 243 cases using the excellent Wilson trimmer and never had to use "small" base die. The F/L sized case should fit in the appropriate case holder with plenty of neck exposure to trim the case. Also, you should not be excessively reducing the radial dimension of the case to fit a case holder!