Dimner
I do believe in Captain Crunch.
Oh I totally agree.I did a great deal of CMP shooting years ago, (lost my love for organized shooting since then) but I could not disagree more about the AR15. I've carried the M2 Carbine in M1A1 configuration, the M16, M14 as well as Remington and Winchester bolt rifles. Along with the standard 1911 pistol.
I understand you like older rifles, so do I, however, the AR15 platform (WITHIN ITS LIMITS) in a well-made configuration is as fine a rifle a family man could want. Those limits are well within the needs of family and defense.
It can be downright reasonably priced, (of course the sky's the limit) it's chambered in reasonable cartridges, 223, 5.45 x 45, 22 ARC, 6MM ARC, 6.5 Grendel, 6.8 SPC to mention a few. It's durable, easy to maintain, mine in 5.56 x 45 and 6MM ARC are varmint grade accurate. I have ZERO PROBLEM trusting my life to either of my AR 15's.
I have always been an old rifle lover. When I, begrudgingly, started the CMP format with the AR15, that's when I learned how dang ergonomic and practical the AR15 format is. After I found that out, I built two more

But they do not get alot of use. Old lever guns, mausers, 1903's, and garands is where my heart is at.