The ivy is/was the standard of excellence and I agree with the maker smooth stainless steel is the way to go. I got Dewey's way before I saw an Ivy but I think I spend more time cleaning my rod than the gun when clean them. I saw a guy at the benches at Manatee break a carbon rod off trying to get a stuck case out of his rifle. It was such a shit show that he wound up with carbon in his hand. I fully understand that something was wrong with his crazy wildcat and the fit in the chamber and his smith made sizing die. But even if you have your act mostly together some times you need to bump a case out and this rod was not up to the task. If I was looking to improve rods a closer fit to the bore size would be it for me, the step between a 22 centerfire rod and the next step up is too big. There are some that need more than a 22 CF rod but the 30 caliber is too much of a step. Just my 2 cents I am sure some like carbon rods just not me.