• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

Need a new torque screw driver

I don't trust digital torque wrenches. I've been eyeballing the Capri Tools CP21075 for my next, I like the 1 lbs increments. Wheeler Fat Wrench has worked well for me. Always bottomed out after use. Treated well - never dropped. There is always a better way though.
 
Did manage to get it to adjust again but did a test of trying to torque a screw in an front rifle rest that weighed in at 20 lbs with the fat wrench set at 15lbs and the rest spun around on the table repeatedly without the Fat wrench clicking as if the rest weighed nothing so I no loner trust the inch-pound settings and are not willing to find out if they are good or not by damaging a scope.
That is not a valid test of torque wrench. Also. Just because an item weighs 20 lbs doesn't mean it will take 20 lbs of torque to rotate it...
 
Just went to torque down the mounting screws for a MRD on my S&W M&P 4" Performance Center Comp Carry and found my Wheeler Fat Wrench wouldn't adjust up from it's recommended not in use minimal (<5 in/lbs) settings. Did manage to get it to adjust again but did a test of trying to torque a screw in an front rifle rest that weighed in at 20 lbs with the fat wrench set at 15lbs and the rest spun around on the table repeatedly without the Fat wrench clicking as if the rest weighed nothing so I no loner trust the inch-pound settings and are not willing to find out if they are good or not by damaging a scope.

I bought the Wheeler Fat Wrench at least 20 years ago and have been 100% satisfied with it but I know a lot of companies now make in-pound torque screw drivers specifically advertised for firearm use and was wondering if one or two are well regarded as more accurate than most others. In all my years of mounting optics, scope bases and rings I have never needed for than 32 inch-ponds of torque.

So what's out there currently in the under $100 range for a consistently reliably accurate gunsmith inch-pound torque screw driver.
 
Did manage to get it to adjust again but did a test of trying to torque a screw in an front rifle rest that weighed in at 20 lbs with the fat wrench set at 15lbs and the rest spun around on the table repeatedly without the Fat wrench clicking as if the rest weighed nothing so I no loner trust the inch-pound settings and are not willing to find out if they are good or not by damaging a scope.
That’s not the way a torque wrench works therefore your test is not appropriate for torque wrenchs .
I like beam torque wrenches. But they must be like a Sturtevant type handle with an ‘axle’ type pivot in middle of the handle. This is where it is held to insure the distance is exact. Sort of a balancing act but it is imperative to ensure an accurate reading. Although I’ve never read it, I don’t think a beam type ever gets or needs recalibration.
Probably the most misunderstood item is torque reduction. There are many charts that give the percentage of reduction needed based on whatever you’ve put on the threads of the fastener you are using. I’ve seen many fasteners with a stated torque amount but they don’t say what that rating is based on. Totally dry and clean?
Some lubricants actually require as much as a 50% reduction. Even spit is different than totally dry. The only true fastener measurement is ‘stretch’ of the bolt. However it is a measurement that is impractical to use in most applications.
 
I use the Wheeler T handle that has the preset torque modules. I don't need anything more precise for any of my stuff but I do still have my yellow Fat Wrench as the OP described and it still works fine after a lot of years of use.

Just saw that set last weekend (someone else's.) Looked pretty handy. Not sure what the quality of the bits are, but they're largely consumable anyway.

I do like my Fix-it Stick set though. I got the variable up-to-65 in-lb indicator. Not terribly accurate, but does what I need.
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
166,812
Messages
2,223,701
Members
79,899
Latest member
Orville. Johnson
Back
Top