• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

Money back from Savage??

I think Ron is on the right track.

As a centerfire shooter when "I" see split brass on the first firing I never blame the chamber. Its the brass. YMMV JMO disclaimer disclaimer ;D

No doubt chamber size plays a role but ALL brass should be able to handle one firing without cracking even in a sloppy chamber. Does'nt always happen though.
Years back unloaded Winchester brass in 204R would come with some splits right out of the bag. Hornady 204R was known for getting a certain percentage of splits on the second firing.

One thing I've noticed in the pics, both yours and another shooters provided in the link. The roll crimp on split brass is readily visible. That could easily be explained by loss of pressure due to leaking gases. But why do the necks measure the same as unsplit brass?
I would look through some fired unsplit brass and see if you can find some more roll crimps still visible. Thats a clue to brass hardness.
And not to let Savage off the hook. You should comparitivly measure the shoulders of your brass against Kona's.
Yes rimfire headspaces off the rim but if your chamber is cut deeper than need be that could cause undue stretching.

How many other lots of ammo have you tried?
 
So I called Savage today. I am sending the gun away and they are looking at it. Not sure yet if I can get my money back or a credit for a different gun. I'm looking at the Savage 12 bench rest in 6 norma br. The girl there said that she would do her best to help me out. :)
Thanks for all the help!
I will keep you all posted on what happens.

Siiri
 
The waitting game is on.... Sent my rifle away today. See how long it takes this time!
Last time it was about 2 and 1/2 months. :(
 
Thought I would tell my story. I had purchased a Savage LRPV.204, used, at a gun shop. Was told that the original purchaser did not like the .204 and traded it in for a LRPV .223. Well I got it and went to work up some loads and it shot all over, I figured the guy traded it in because it did not shot. Called Savage and they said send it back which I did, they even picked it up. Replaced the barrel, test fired and sent it back no charge. Test target .4 inch with factory ammunition. :) Savage worked for me, great company.
 
jeffnet said:
Thought I would tell my story. I had purchased a Savage LRPV.204, used, at a gun shop. Was told that the original purchaser did not like the .204 and traded it in for a LRPV .223. Well I got it and went to work up some loads and it shot all over, I figured the guy traded it in because it did not shot. Called Savage and they said send it back which I did, they even picked it up. Replaced the barrel, test fired and sent it back no charge. Test target .4 inch with factory ammunition. :) Savage worked for me, great company.
To bad with Savage your dealing with 2 different companys for rimfire and centerfire.
 
i had some remington 17hmr ammo that after firing the necks were split, then i tried federal and havent had a problem!
 
ajax said:
i had some remington 17hmr ammo that after firing the necks were split, then i tried federal and havent had a problem!
Siiri tryed a few different kinds of ammo and 2 different guns. All combinations ment cracked necks.
 
ajax said:
i had some remington 17hmr ammo that after firing the necks were split, then i tried federal and havent had a problem!
Ok fellas as I mentioned in Siiri's first thread all or most all 17hmr is made @ cci/speer Remington, hornady,and all the other brass are made on the same machine with the same brass wire, just the head stamp is different. Ron your correct on the procedures used. I buy factory second 17hmr which is the stuff thats not good enough for you the public and I have shot 1000s of rounds of it through my Savage 17hmr with not a single split case to my knowledge. The quality control @ CCI is second to none. bad ammo can slip through the cracks of any manufacturer but I can't imagine one person in Canada is getting it all, its more than likely the rifle.
Siiri I wish you two kids the best of luck with it ;) By the way I have a f class Savage in 6.5*284 and 6br and they are tac drivers.
Wayne.
 
Just an update...
I have talked to Savage and they looked at my gun and told me that nothing was wrong with the chamber and that it was the ammo, but when I told them that my bf uses the same ammo and never had a case crack. Savage quickly said that they would send me a new gun. As I do not want a new gun I asked for my money back or for a credit for a different gun, since I am looking at the Savage 12 bench rest in 6br. He said that a credit might be possible but he has to talk to the marketing guy.

I will keep you all posted on what happens next!
Thanks!
Siiri
 
So it is official I am getting a Savage 12 bench rest in 6mm Norma br. I was able to get a credit for my 17 HMR. :D In about 2 weeks I`ll have my new baby! Lol :P I am sooo excited! So much to learn!! You will defiantly be hearing more from me now.

Thank you everyone!
Siiri
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
166,314
Messages
2,215,963
Members
79,519
Latest member
DW79
Back
Top