I have shot my 6 dasher for hunting the last 2 years. Last year I shot the Berger 108 BT and killed a whitetail doe at just over 300 yards...deer ran about 30 yards after being hit well and left a blood highway to easily track her. I considered that a success but was concerned that my limited results were more of an anomaly.
I shifted this year to the Berger 105 HVLD. The season started off well. I shot a very nice CA blacktail 4x4 buck at 406 yards on my first shot. He was bedded down and the bullet hit where I had placed my crosshair. He got up, took a couple of steps and piled up. That bullet performed nearly perfectly in my opinion, both in anchoring the animal and leaving a great blood trail. A few weeks later on my trip to Wyoming to shoot antelope doe I had mediocre results. I hit a nice doe on my first shot at 460 yards and she ran about 30-40 yards and just froze standing up. I walked up to within about 250 yards of her and shot her right in the neck to finish her off. That shot slammed her straight to the ground and I was satisfied that the bullet had performed well and the animal was dead and not suffering. When I got within about 50 yards of her I realized she had her head back up looking around as if nothing had happened. The bullet had essentially behaved like a full metal jacket and punched right through...leaving only a pin sized red mark on her neck. I shot her in the head and that finished her off. When we were skinning her we found the first bullet on the other side of her hide...it looked like a deformed bullet with a very thick jacket (almost like a deformed fmj). I have some pictures of it that I will attach to this thread. The lot of 105HVLDs that I shot my CA blacktail with were different than the ones that I shot in Wyoming (ran out of the first ones).
I decided after the Wyoming results, and some experiences a friend had encountered with 105HVLDs in his 6x47 Lapua and 6br a few years back when hunting out of state to move to another bullet next year. My friend said it best in my opinion - "When the Berger performs well it is awesome but unfortunately the performance is inconsistent"...at least in the smaller to mid range 6mm cases. I plan to shoot the 90gr Scirocco or newly announced Barnes 95gr LRX in the Dasher and also add a 284 winchester to my arsenal. I'll begin my load development for that rifle with the Hornady 162gr eldx and 150gr Scirocco. I love having my rifles shoot small groups which is why I chose Berger (rifle typically shot 3/8 inch 5 shot groups with both the 108 and 105s) but this upcoming year I am going to focus on finding a bullet designed first and foremost for hunting.
JP
Just wondering how the 108 Berger performs on deer sized game compared to a 105 hvld. Not much info out there. Thanks
