I have handloaded for over 40 years; that is my preference. $$$$ savings & accuracy point to that as the right way to go.Pierced AR primers seem off thread; but search here; I did a write up on my DPMS and that included firing pin/primer issues and my resolution to them.
As to the OP post, Forum Boss has it right, try different ammo first. Fed GMM 168 and fed GMM 175 are benchmarks for almost all ARs. Take pics of your brass (case heads) and post them here, we can help you verify your gas system is in tune if you're not sure what to look for. Post some groups too, I'd recommend 5-round groups and 1 of them single feed, the rest feed from the mag.
Alternates to try if Fed GMMs aren't available, nosler Cust. Comp. or Hornady Match.
I'm skipping a ton of info, so keep is posted on how the ammo change goes.
-Mac