Wayne: I must be fortunate, compared to your experience with one 4-12x "Rifleman". I've had one since they first became available, and was so impressed with it, then bought a new 4-12x VX-1. Cost of each was around $250 give or take a few bucks, the main difference being the old style 1 moa hash marks on the elev. & wind adjustments with the "Rifleman", and the VX-1 with the 1/4 moa clicks. The "Rifleman" sits on a Remington 700 222, and while I can't speak for the abilities of the guy who can't hit a g'hog, I've sent many to that clover field in the sky with that little 222 & the Leupold. One of my favorite "go to" rifles when I want something compact & lightweight for carry. The VX-1 has been mounted on one of my AR-15 flatops for many years/ many rounds fired, and there has never been a problem.
For me, both have been well worth their cost, and the "made in the USA", compared to the "made somewhere off-shore" on the others is enough for me. Just curious: why do you believe someone other than Leupold is making the lower-end Leupold scope's? If that's true,
then are you saying that the new Redfield's that cost even less than the low-end Leupold's are also being made by someone other than Leupold? I must be lucky. Of all the new and used Leupold's I've bought over the years I've never had a bad one yet, regardless of their cost.