I bought one last year and have been more than happy with it. My eyes aren’t the greatest either, but I really have no complaints, especially for the money. Parallax is definitely touchy. Yes, it does get darker at a higher magnification, find me one that doesn’t. But I haven’t found it to be too dark. At mid range magnification, my eyes find it to be clear and bright. One con, is my rear ring obscures my windage turret. I rarely, if ever dial for windage so no big deal. I like it better than the Sightron’s I’ve looked through. I like it better than the GE. I like it better than the Nightforce Competition, based mainly on the price tag. I can’t compare it to other high-end scopes since I haven’t looked through the March’s, Majestic’s, Kahle’s etc. And I wouldn’t, that’s a silly comparison.
Subsequently, I find the whole debate between scopes rather humorous. As Sandstorm said, everyone’s eyes are different, thus our experiences are different. Based on what discipline and distance you shoot, your vision, and what you’re trying to accomplish, let that dictate your approach to choosing your glass.
Personally, I swear, I think it’s just another equipment race. I’ve seen guys that seemed to get more enjoyment by showing their rig off than an actual shooting well.