• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

.223 AR Velocities - Longer Barrel, lower Velocity?

A buddy got a Garmin Chrono and we took it out yesterday. We were trying a .223 load with 69 gr RMR bullets using N135, Wolf SRMs, and the same lot of Win Brass.

We tried two ARs, a 14.5 Minnies Machine Govt contract overrun, and a Colt 6920 16.0. Both carbine Gas systems. The Colt has maybe 200 rounds, and the SOCOM has at least 1000-1500 rounds.

I patched both to feel for obvious anomalies, and nothing felt odd. Both have jumps from 2.250 of about .135 as best I can tell with that crappy hornady tool.

Velocities were as follows:

14.5 BCM SOCOM 2677 fps

16.0 Colt 6920 2638 fps (39 fps slower!)

If they shot close to the same I'd be surprised, but the shorter one shot faster? Any ideas?
 
GCRSINK.jpg

The evil weapons in question.
 
You might check the water capacity of a fired case from each of the rifles. One grain of water difference can make a noticeable difference in the pressure realized.
 
I'm guessing that there's a slight bore diameter difference here. No doubt that each barrel is its own animal and some shoot faster, but I've never had a shorter barrel shoot faster.
 
A buddy got a Garmin Chrono and we took it out yesterday. We were trying a .223 load with 69 gr RMR bullets using N135, Wolf SRMs, and the same lot of Win Brass.

We tried two ARs, a 14.5 Minnies Machine Govt contract overrun, and a Colt 6920 16.0. Both carbine Gas systems. The Colt has maybe 200 rounds, and the SOCOM has at least 1000-1500 rounds.

I patched both to feel for obvious anomalies, and nothing felt odd. Both have jumps from 2.250 of about .135 as best I can tell with that crappy hornady tool.

Velocities were as follows:

14.5 BCM SOCOM 2677 fps

16.0 Colt 6920 2638 fps (39 fps slower!)

If they shot close to the same I'd be surprised, but the shorter one shot faster? Any ideas?
Are they both chambered for the same cartridge, 223, 223 Wylde or 5.56 x 45?
 
Are they both chambered for the same cartridge, 223, 223 Wylde or 5.56 x 45?
They're both 5.56 despite the 223 designation on the Euro 6920. Apparently they can't have a military caliber in civilian hands in Europe. So, as I understand it, Colt marks these 223.

And wouldn't the shorter leade on a 223 chamber yield higher pressure and thus more velocity?

I'm assuming the 6920 is also Chrome lined. I'll have to check later today.
 
They're both 5.56 despite the 223 designation on the Euro 6920. Apparently they can't have a military caliber in civilian hands in Europe. So, as I understand it, Colt marks these 223.

And wouldn't the shorter leade on a 223 chamber yield higher pressure and thus more velocity?

I'm assuming the 6920 is also Chrome lined. I'll have to check later today.
Barrel length is just one of a multitude of factors in velocity. You may even find that a different lot of ammunition provides different results.

One would think that the shorter lead of a 223 chamber (if it was truly cut that way) would provide more pressure but the barrel may have properties that negate that.

The only things that matter is that you know how the rifle reacts. It's producing a bit slower velocities, so what? Is it accurate and dependable? Those mean a hell of a lot more than a few feet per second.
 
The only things that matter is that you know how the rifle reacts. It's producing a bit slower velocities, so what? Is it accurate and dependable? Those mean a hell of a lot more than a few feet per second.

I agree. I'd just never seen anything like this. We normally chrono EVERY .223 round on the same 20" bolt gun for comparability. But with the Garmin, we have the freedom to capture everything all the time if we want.
 
What were the ES and SD values for each of the two velocity sets for the different rifles?

I wouldn't be too concerned with the velocity of the shorter barrel being slightly higher than the longer one. I'd guess it could be some subtle difference the bore/groove configuration of the two barrels, or possibly between the gas systems. However, there are so many posible variables that could go into the difference in velocity that trying to chase down what might cause the difference is likely to be an exercise in futility.
 
I agree. I'd just never seen anything like this. We normally chrono EVERY .223 round on the same 20" bolt gun for comparability. But with the Garmin, we have the freedom to capture everything all the time if we want.
Give it time you'll see plenty of stuff that makes no sense.
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
165,851
Messages
2,204,884
Members
79,174
Latest member
kit10n
Back
Top