• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

17 hmr- will it outshoot 22lr at 50m?

good guess, but no, not motorcycle .. once a year local range Youth Day, I bring a black Chipmunk 22 w/ Millet red dot sight, a pink Crikett 22 w/ Millet red dot sight, and a Savage Rascal Target model 22 in Boyds laminate coyote pattern stock w/ bipod & rear bag and Nitro 6-24X scope, plus 500 rounds of generic 22 ammo, set up for the young kids to shoot, all FREE, 50 yards off bench, closely supervised, and only with parental consent (some of whom have never shot a rifle before) .. I also make up some "awards" to hand out to the kids, heat sublimation printed tags and such .. aka (you guessed it) Rimfire Ninja tags ... the kids do surprisingly well, and its great fun
yeah, that is really great get kids to associate with the image of feudal assassin's real positive influence. what happen to plain bullseye shooting!
oh, wait a minute you trying to make think they are snipers, no wonder the far left wants all of our guns!

Lee
 
yeah, that is really great get kids to associate with the image of feudal assassin's real positive influence. what happen to plain bullseye shooting!
oh, wait a minute you trying to make think they are snipers, no wonder the far left wants all of our guns!

Lee
omygawd, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles have destroyed America's soul whilst I was napping .. and I always thunk it was going to be the Zombie Apocalypse Invasion that would do us in , go figger
 

Attachments

  • Mall ninja.png
    Mall ninja.png
    86.9 KB · Views: 14
My 17HMR is a marlin. It shoots 1 inch groups at 100 yards. No better, no worse. Always right under an inch. I donno what a better barrel would do. Ive never known if thats good or not for a 17. I guess its ok. Id like better, but it could be worse. I did bed it and do alittle stock work.
 
You think hmrs are not allowed because the two two mafia is trying to keep them down? I know any two two match ive been in they will let you shoot that hmr all you want. Itll score right down there with the 10/22 crowd. With the current offering of hmr/hm2 ammo the two two aint coming unseated anytime soon.
 
omygawd, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles have destroyed America's soul whilst I was napping .. and I always thunk it was going to be the Zombie Apocalypse Invasion that would do us in , go figger
This might be too deep in thinking for you, but next time ask those kids what it is they are thinking when shooting those targets.
I pretty sure if you ask JR shooters who shoot bullseye targets what they will say. sometimes we are our worst enemy!

Lee
 
You can pull the the bullets and reload the 17 hmr a bit easier than a 22lr. it has more of a conventional neck bullet design with bullet diameter same as centerfire. I dont think all the potential has been extracted from the 17 cal rimfires.
 
You can pull the the bullets and reload the 17 hmr a bit easier than a 22lr. it has more of a conventional neck bullet design with bullet diameter same as centerfire. I dont think all the potential has been extracted from the 17 cal rimfires.

Approx a couple of years ago a guy was posting his impressive long range results achieved via reloading. I seem to remember dies were available??? Too bad nothing has shown up recently as the potential appeared interesting.
 
I imagine it could be an interesting and changing world in rimfire if, in theory, there were manufacturers interested in manufacturing match grade ammo. Maybe someday.
 
My 17HMR is a marlin. It shoots 1 inch groups at 100 yards. No better, no worse. Always right under an inch. I donno what a better barrel would do. Ive never known if thats good or not for a 17. I guess its ok. Id like better, but it could be worse. I did bed it and do alittle stock work.
yeah pretty typical for the usual off the shelf Marlin or Savage any 17 hmr ammo at 100 yards, not match winners, but sub moa .. give it a whirl at 50 yards like the vastly superior two-two-only match shooters do, expect 3/8" groups.. my Savage 93R17 BTVSS and Savage B17 FVSR do same/same .. (my other 5 hmrs shoot tighter) ... try some A17 ammo, may or may not shoot a tad better .. shoot well, be well, stay safe
 
Last edited:
no offense, but you likely won't win any matches with them - simply because they are so rarely allowed to compete - seems more than a tad odd that so many world class elite champion two-two shooters have such a low opinion of the deplorable 17 hmr that they simply will not allow the unworthy 17 hmr in competition, quite specifically because .. well ... uhhh ... because they don't want to win by such huge margins, bless their heart .. but best of
omygawd, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles have destroyed America's soul whilst I was napping .. and I always thunk it was going to be the Zombie Apocalypse Invasion that would do us in ,

yeah pretty typical for the usual off the shelf Marlin or Savage any 17 hmr ammo at 100 yards, not match winners, but sub moa .. give it a whirl at 50 yards like the vastly superior two-two-only match shooters do, expect 3/8" groups.. my Savage 93R17 BTVSS and Savage B17 FVSR do same/same .. (my other 5 hmrs shooter tighter) ... try some A17 ammo, may or may not shoot a tad better .. shoot well, be well, stay safe
I hate to tell you but 3/8 @50 yds won't cut it in any sanctioned matches and you think it can hang with the two two lmao ? Come on man it will never reach the potential of the two two in regards to accuracy. Maybe just maybe if they started making match ammo and get match grade barrels it might compete. I bet in the wind that little round will move all over the place, hell it moves a lot with a 22 round couldn't imagine. 17 in 10mph wind. I'm good on shooting pellets out of a rimfire
 
You think hmrs are not allowed because the two two mafia is trying to keep them down? I know any two two match ive been in they will let you shoot that hmr all you want. Itll score right down there with the 10/22 crowd. With the current offering of hmr/hm2 ammo the two two aint coming unseated anytime soon.
"any two two match ive been in they will let you shoot that hmr" .. kindly come down to south Georgia and tell our range officers that, LOL .. and don't forget to petition ARA and IR5050 to do the same, though we will never get them down here at out local range anyway, 20 lanes of e-targets only, 50yd/100yd range, they refuse to allow paper targets for the few infrequent matches we have (but we keep workin' on em, never say die) .. we have had some IR5050 shooters show up at our last two matches, with custom builds, Vudoo and similar, Sinclair rests etc.. Unlimted class IR5050 bench guns .. I shoot sporter class Annie 22s off bipod and rear bag against 'em, because our range does not distinguish between such category nuances, and for myself "playing is winning", rimfire target shooting, recreational, fun and educational ... I will shoot 22LR and/or 17 hmr versus anybody any time, any caliber, rimfire or centerfire, 50 yds or 100 yds .. if it ever stops being fun I would just stay home and watch Netflix --- PS - there is no "two-two mafia," but there are many decades of vested interest built into 22LR rimfire ONLY, and most of the players and all of the sponsors want to keep it that way, the match grade ammo companies like Eley especially so .. there is a LOT of money in this sport, a lot of heavily vested financial interests, and it is in their interests to defend the staus quo.. as typical of a wide array of other unrelated business interests in all established markets ; competition is always feared whether or not it is believed to be worthy competition
 
This might be too deep in thinking for you, but next time ask those kids what it is they are thinking when shooting those targets.
I pretty sure if you ask JR shooters who shoot bullseye targets what they will say. sometimes we are our worst enemy!

Lee
strive a little harder to pay attention and look at picture posted .. the range is 50 yd/100 yd 20 lanes of pricey Kongsberg KTS e-targets .. std NRA A23 targets at 50 yards and std NRA A25 targets at 100 yards with bench monitor displays of shot plots .. the kids, mostly age 10 or younger, most have never fired a rifle before, and they are shooting at A23 targets at 50 yards, not cutesy lego teenage mutant ninja turtles and cartoon characters .. if you don't know what these standard A23 and A25 targets are, write NRA a letter and ask them .. down here in south georgia they are known as bullseyes .. but if you are are truly desperate to boycott LEGO movies and Roadrunner cartoons, , by all means, go boycott, save America, ban cartoons and burn LEGOs .. by the way, they think whatever they think, but what they shout out is, "look daddy, I got a TEN" .. or "look mommy, I got an X"
 
strive a little harder to pay attention and look at picture posted .. the range is 50 yd/100 yd 20 lanes of pricey Kongsberg KTS e-targets .. std NRA A23 targets at 50 yards and std NRA A25 targets at 100 yards with bench monitor displays of shot plots .. the kids, mostly age 10 or younger, most have never fired a rifle before, and they are shooting at A23 targets at 50 yards, not cutesy lego teenage mutant ninja turtles and cartoon characters .. if you don't know what these standard A23 and A25 targets are, write NRA a letter and ask them .. down here in south georgia they are known as bullseyes .. but if you are are truly desperate to boycott LEGO movies and Roadrunner cartoons, , by all means, go boycott, save America, ban cartoons and burn LEGOs .. by the way, they think whatever they think, but what they shout out is, "look daddy, I got a TEN" .. or "look mommy, I got an X"
Wow man you must be really really old or really off your rocker. I'm leaning towards the second choice. Down in Georgia there is one the best indoor ranges in the country chickenfoot go look it up. Go talk to William Casey about your hummer and see what he says about you shooting it ina real sanctioned ara match. If it's doing 3/8 @50 you might as well stay home. 3/8 will get you dead last ina sanctioned match
 
I hate to tell you but 3/8 @50 yds won't cut it in any sanctioned matches and you think it can hang with the two two lmao ? Come on man it will never reach the potential of the two two in regards to accuracy. Maybe just maybe if they started making match ammo and get match grade barrels it might compete. I bet in the wind that little round will move all over the place, hell it moves a lot with a 22 round couldn't imagine. 17 in 10mph wind. I'm good on shooting pellets out of a rimfire
I hate to tell you but strive to pay closer attention.. I never said 3/8" c-c was a match winner, I never said that was the limit, I said pretty typical generic random hmr ammo, for any off the shelf relatively inexpensive generic hmr rifle .. and I know what ARA and IR5050 bulls are and how scored .. but I don't expect to hear much wisdom from anyone who repeat internet nonsense like "I bet in the wind that little round will move all over the place" ... wind drift has nothing whatsoever to do with bullet weight .. it's about aerodynamic drag profile and time in transit to target .. smaller proife and faster is better .. bullet weight matters not, although inertia can matter (better resistance to wind gusts) and inertia is directly proportional to momentum, (mass x velocity) .. likewise bullet weight has absolutely nothing to do with bullet drop, gravity is a constant .. did they not teach you that in high school ?? .. save your money, don't bet, just look it up, many trustworthy sources, including ammunition manufacturers; it is not an opinion, it is a demonstated and proven reality .. google can help you find whatever sources your special expertise considers worthy .. (or you could ask someone with a degree in Aerospace Engineering, but you just did) .. but do feel free to offer your bet on which centerfire has less wind drift, 22-250 or 45-70
 
There is no love for me and the 22lr in the accuracy game. Absolutely love plinking with them. Olympic medals and college scholarships are awarded based on the 22lr performance. Many companies have spent alot of time trying to make better ammo. I still do not believe its at the level of the athletes shooting them especially prone.
Now if I were to walk into a sporting goods store and want to leave with the most accurate rimfire rifle and ammo under $500 I think the 17 HMR or 22 WMR may have an edge.
 
I hate to tell you but strive to pay closer attention.. I never said 3/8" c-c was a match winner, I never said that was the limit, I said pretty typical generic random hmr ammo, for any off the shelf relatively inexpensive generic hmr rifle .. and I know what ARA and IR5050 bulls are and how scored .. but I don't expect to hear much wisdom from anyone who repeat internet nonsense like "I bet in the wind that little round will move all over the place" ... wind drift has nothing whatsoever to do with bullet weight .. it's about aerodynamic drag profile and time in transit to target .. smaller proife and faster is better .. bullet weight matters not, although inertia can matter (better resistance to wind gusts) and inertia is directly proportional to momentum, (mass x velocity) .. likewise bullet weight has absolutely nothing to do with bullet drop, gravity is a constant .. did they not teach you that in high school ?? .. save your money, don't bet, just look it up, many trustworthy sources, including ammunition manufacturers; it is not an opinion, it is a demonstated and proven reality .. google can help you find whatever sources your special expertise considers worthy .. (or you could ask someone with a degree in Aerospace Engineering, but you just did) .. but do feel free to offer your bet on which centerfire has less wind drift, 22-250 or 45-70
Lmao wow I sure got a lesson from someone that has not shot any sanctioned matches in what 30 years? I have 10+ years of shooting sanctioned matches and never ever ever ever heard of anyone even mention a 17hmr for br matches. Here's a thought old timer go make your own 17hmr br league I'm sure it will catch on. Make your own custom action get a company to make match grade ammo have a target made and then hunt for killer barrels. It will go the exact same way as .22br a equipment race. This is the nature of any top level competition period. Go shoot a match with it and report back.
 
I hate to tell you but strive to pay closer attention.. I never said 3/8" c-c was a match winner, I never said that was the limit, I said pretty typical generic random hmr ammo, for any off the shelf relatively inexpensive generic hmr rifle .. and I know what ARA and IR5050 bulls are and how scored .. but I don't expect to hear much wisdom from anyone who repeat internet nonsense like "I bet in the wind that little round will move all over the place" ... wind drift has nothing whatsoever to do with bullet weight .. it's about aerodynamic drag profile and time in transit to target .. smaller proife and faster is better .. bullet weight matters not, although inertia can matter (better resistance to wind gusts) and inertia is directly proportional to momentum, (mass x velocity) .. likewise bullet weight has absolutely nothing to do with bullet drop, gravity is a constant .. did they not teach you that in high school ?? .. save your money, don't bet, just look it up, many trustworthy sources, including ammunition manufacturers; it is not an opinion, it is a demonstated and proven reality .. google can help you find whatever sources your special expertise considers worthy .. (or you could ask someone with a degree in Aerospace Engineering, but you just did) .. but do feel free to offer your bet on which centerfire has less wind drift, 22-250 or 45-70B
Being a bit picky, the time of flight does not determine wind drift. What is called lag time does, the difference between the time of flight if it was in vacuum and the actual time of flight.
 
I never said 3/8" c-c was a match winner, I never said that was the limit, I said pretty typical generic random hmr ammo, for any off the shelf relatively inexpensive generic hmr rifle ..
So if I understand you correctly you're claiming that pretty typical generic random 17 hmr ammo in "any off the shelf relatively inexpensive generic hmr rifle" will shoot 3/8's groups?

And if your answer is yes, about how often could one expect this to occur, on the regular, 1 in 10, 1 in 100, 1 in 1K, 1 in 10K, 1 in 100K, 1 in a million???
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
165,377
Messages
2,194,360
Members
78,863
Latest member
patrickchavez
Back
Top