I'm saddened by some of the problems other clubs have with knuckleheads. I belong to a private club where we have none of these problems. Target stands do get shot, but it's poor shooting or incorrect zeros not vandalism. We consider them replaceable items; the cost of doing business. Now and then a new member, or at times an old hand goofs up regarding club rules. They get corrected by others and typically all is good. We've had only a couple instances where it didn't resolve and the member left. Sometimes voluntarily, other times involuntarily. We're a fairly small club (<500 members) so most everyone knows everyone else. We police ourselves and at the same time have each other's six. It's like a family, really. We have no need for Range Officers during casual shooting. We are open to the public for scheduled matches, where of course, there's a match director running the show. I think the keys to our success are:
* Limited headcount. It means a lengthy waiting list which screens out yahoos. Newbies really want to join.
* As noted above, we coach newbies on the rules and expect newbies to call us on it if we mess up.
* Routine, frequent work parties and presence of the leadership team mean there's a constant visibility if things start going astray.
* We have a high end camera and audio system which has been very useful in identifying errant shots or protecting us against a few outside accusations.
* We have baffles. No blue sky. I wasn't keen on them before we put them in. But I'll tell you, it's much more relaxing running a match when you know a round can't leave. A baffle hit is considered a serious infraction with a fine. If unreported, it's a fine and suspension.
All this results in a club that's safe, enjoyable and like a family. The leadership team and the members focus intently on keeping it that way. It works.