• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

Hammer style bullet puller - Accidental discharge.

In a nutshell, this is not the tool to use if you are salvaging rounds due to others in the batch are suspect to have loose primer pockets. Use a pair of pliers and bend the bullet out of the brass by hand with no impact, salvage the powder and toss the rest of the mess.
And since we have opened Pandora's Box... for the benefit of the less experienced....

We are not going to single out Mike for volunteering the story, but since his bolt face and hammer posts bring up a few important safety lessons... let's use the lessons learned to avoid issues. By telling his story, he may be keeping the next rookie from putting primers in blown pockets.

The point of this is discussion is to point out the deficiency in general advice to folks leaning on their own.

There really should not be an instance of needing to disassemble a round where the primer was put into a blown pocket. Cases are getting hard to come by without a doubt, but they are not worth risking gas leaks or collateral damage.

The first opportunity to scrap the brass, comes when the spent primer is removed from the case. In non-crimped cases, pockets that give up the spent primer with abnormally low force are a red flag. In crimped brass, the use of a gage is what keeps you out of trouble.

But, if by chance the rookie is handed used brass where the primers were already removed, what then?
It is still the loader's responsibility to inspect the brass, including the pockets. The primer installation force is a warning all by itself.

Let's say we are loading on different types of presses or using different priming tools with respect to keeping things safe.

On a progressive machine where we are potentially auto-loading or where there is a chance that there is not enough sensitivity to "feel" the problem, we introduce the concept of gages and inspection. When primer pockets are blown, they fail the gages and we do not proceed to load them.

On traditional single stage presses, the user has the responsibility to either gage pockets or learn to know when the "feel" is wrong, preferably both.

It is possible that Mike didn't realize he was getting into trouble when putting primers in blown brass. Not enough emphasis has been placed on the importance of the primer pocket to primer relationship.

With any hand priming tool, the user has more than enough warning if the primer just drops into the pocket such that it would just back off when the case is being tapped on a table, etc..

In general, when you take on loading, you also must take responsibility for the priming.

Being trained and taught by a mentor, means the mentor needs to warn the student of these risks. Best when they arrange a demonstration of a loose pocket versus one that meets the bare minimum dimensions.

Suppose someone like our OP has no mentor and is learning this on their own. As a community we have failed to put much importance on this point, but that is just my opinion.

My opinion is based on belonging to several clubs where the rookies have struggled with ammo and component shortages, and we are seeing a rash of blown primer pockets and I think there is a connection.

Being on their own, and the reluctance to scrap brass, combines with little warning in their training from the internet or YouTube and we get mistakes.

There is a question about what text books say about importance of investment in gages for primer pockets.

None of us were with Mike when he was leaning, and we don't know if there was much warning when he put primers in what would be called failed pockets. Only Mike can say if he should have even put another primer in the cases or not.

Once that line is crossed and a primer is put into a blown pocket, all bets are off on the impact hammer, as well as loading into any semi-auto context.

Glad the story about the hammer and his bolt face has a happy ending. Play it safe folks.
 
Last edited:
I'm old and a little slow and having problems trying to figure out how a primer would ignite and not set off the powder charge. I also use to use the hammer style puller but its to much work and noisy so I went to the RCBS collets. Much easier, safer and a whole bunch quieter.
 
I have the same puller and this past weekend had to pull 20 rounds I had loaded and started wondering what type of puller would I get instead of the inertia style.
So what other puller do you guys have or use
 
I've still have a primer embedded in the 5/8" sheetrock ceiling of reloading room. Buddy was knocking bullets out of several 6 BR rounds that he loaded with CCI 400 and it was blanking primers. I have a 4x4" block on floor and he was hitting kinetic puller on it. Went right by his face. Didn't ignite the powder thank goodness. To be clear this was new Lapua brass, tight primer pockets.

primer.jpg
 
Last edited:
I had about 15 180gr lead bullets to pull from .40S&W. Just taper crimped. Would not budge and I whacked it pretty hard on concrete. Then tried the Hornady cam loc puller - slipped right off the lead. Great, now what? Got an extended shellholder and raised the bullet above the top of the press and grabbed the bullet with this. Put a good bite in it and lowered the ram. No fuss, no mess. The bullets went to someone who casts.
1674618939210.jpeg
 
I went to the grip n pull easier than a collet & faster with no damage to the bullet.

 
Im glad we get to hear the story. Next time something isnt right maybe itll cause somebody to stop and think, and will also share their experiences without getting pounced on.

I agree wholeheartedly. I used to work as an Arborist and I think one of the biggest improvements in safety over the years industry wide has been open communication about accidents. Tearing people down just results in people hiding what they did and nobody ends up learning anything from it.
 
In the one I posted above, the case was in a normal chuck that comes with the RCBS impact puller, nothing contacting primer. Looks like they had the same discussion several years ago. I might not have believed it happened this way either if I hadn't been sitting 5' away.

https://forum.accurateshooter.com/threads/inertia-bullet-puller-mishap.3847327/

Local gunsmith (retired now) but had handled 100's of thousands of rounds of ammo. Opened a box of 9mm and dropped one on his concrete shop floor and the primer detonated. Case ricochet off his wall. He theorized that it had hit something laying on floor but the primer didn't have a dent.
 
Last edited:
Always made me nervous, beating a loaded round in a hammer on the floor. I have collet pullers and only use the kinetic puller if I seat a bullet too deep when working up loads. Just a few light taps will move the bullet several thousands. "one moment of stupidity can cause a lifetime of suffering"
 
Not fair to infer that the OP's problem was 'stupidity'. Lots of reloaders over the years have done the exact same thing (or probably even worse) without issues. Th OP just had the bad luck, but also the courage to let everyone know it happened.
We've all had primers that seated a bit too easily for comfort. Pulling the load is one way to deal with it. Personally, I normally don't use my press to prime cases (except for handgun loads). I use a hand-primer and pay very close attention to the feel of the primer seating. If there is even a slight reduction in the effort from case to case I mark the case head and then discard it after that firing. Obviously if it is a sloppy fit that seats with little to no resistance I discard the case without completing the loading process.
 
In the one I posted above, the case was in a normal chuck that comes with the RCBS impact puller, nothing contacting primer. Looks like they had the same discussion several years ago. I might not have believed it happened this way either if I hadn't been sitting 5' away.

https://forum.accurateshooter.com/threads/inertia-bullet-puller-mishap.3847327/

Local gunsmith (retired now) but had handled 100's of thousands of rounds of ammo. Opened a box of 9mm and dropped one on his concrete shop floor and the primer detonated. Case ricochet off his wall. He theorized that it had hit something laying on floor but the primer didn't have a dent.
I rolled my bridgeport over a primer on the floor and it detonated. It was very contained under the steel wheels but it made a scary bang
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
166,265
Messages
2,214,890
Members
79,496
Latest member
Bie
Back
Top