• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

Shilen barrel options

mule

Silver $$ Contributor
Shilen barrel options for grade
Select match vs match

What is the big difference other than what I've read between the select match and the match barrels and stainless steel has any of you guys had any experience?
 
Shilen barrel options for grade
Select match vs match

What is the big difference other than what I've read between the select match and the match barrels and stainless steel has any of you guys had any experience?
I've kind wondered the same, but reading their info on it I'm mot sure anyone would be able to tell the difference between the two. Hell it's all a crap shoot if ya get a good one or not anyway. Saying that, barrels are cheap compared to buying 8k$ worth of ammo a year. I've only had experience with match select barrels so I wouldn't be able to say if accuracy is better or not. Kinda interesting anyway
 
EVERYTHING MAKES A DIFFERENCE
Well tell us John what that difference is. Have you shot any of the match barrels vs select match side by side ?. My guess is you're more likely to get a good one in select match grade than the just match. I've had a bad select match grade barrel too so maybe not.
 
I guess "bad" is relative. I've never had a "bad" Shilen barrel and I have had Match, Select Match and Ratchet in various profiles. All were superlative.
 
I guess "bad" is relative. I've never had a "bad" Shilen barrel and I have had Match, Select Match and Ratchet in various profiles. All were superlative.
Good for you , but I'm sure I'm not the only one that has had a bad shilen select match or other wise. This barrel never shot groups very well and never scored well so I would call it a bad barrel. You have no idea how many barrels some guys go through to get that one killer. They aren't all killer barrels
 
As mentioned, it's 'relative' to the need/expectation.

For example, for what I do, 1/2 MOA is great. For others, that's unacceptable.
 
Good for you , but I'm sure I'm not the only one that has had a bad shilen select match or other wise. This barrel never shot groups very well and never scored well so I would call it a bad barrel. You have no idea how many barrels some guys go through to get that one killer. They aren't all killer barrels
Well Sir you are correct in that I have no idea how many barrels "some guys" go through to get that "killer" barrel. I also have no idea if the barrel you are referring to was yours or someone elses that you heard about or how well it needs to do to score "well." If your talking about the barrel on the world championship rimfire rifle that shot better than every other barrel on every other gun used by every other shooter or "The Highlander Barrel" .... there can be only one. Are all the rest are "Bad Barrels?"

Shilen has damn sure made, and continues to make, their share - and more - of championship barrels.

Of course this is only my testimony based on my personal experiences.
 
Well Sir you are correct in that I have no idea how many barrels "some guys" go through to get that "killer" barrel. I also have no idea if the barrel you are referring to was yours or someone elses that you heard about or how well it needs to do to score "well." If your talking about the barrel on the world championship rimfire rifle that shot better than every other barrel on every other gun used by every other shooter or "The Highlander Barrel" .... there can be only one. Are all the rest are "Bad Barrels?"

Shilen has damn sure made, and continues to make, their share - and more - of championship barrels.

Of course this is only my testimony based on my personal experiences.
I'm pretty sure if you would have reading it properly you would have seen where I stated my barrel. So it was on my gun I shoot 22 rf br ara. I tested over 40 lots of ammo with about the same results from all of them, wich shouldn't be the case. It wouldn't never group under about 3/8 @50 yds and in ara or ir5050 that's not good enough. Got another shilen match select had it installed and it is a absolute hammer and I've shot my best scores ever with this barrel. So I do know they make good ones and some not so good ones it's part of the business.
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
166,268
Messages
2,215,184
Members
79,506
Latest member
Hunt99elk
Back
Top