• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

Annealing Machines in Late 2018

Phil3

I need to have some brass annealed, and after having looked through a multitude of older threads on annealing machines, it does seem that induction annealing is the way to go...for a price. I am not prepared to shell out $1000+ for an annealing machine unless it is demonstrably much superior in results vs any other method (torch). I am ok with some inconvenience in use.

Perhaps technology, knowledge, and prices have changed for annealing in 2018, but what in your opinion are good values for the money? I am probably OK spending up to perhaps $500, but if twice that provides much superior brass, well, maybe I will consider the big buck machine.

I will shoot perhaps a couple thousand rounds a year I would guess, in 223, 6mmBR, and 6.5 x 47.

Thanks.

Phil
 
I bought a Benchsource. I really like it. It takes a few minutes to get it set up for each case type, but once done I just sit there and plunk in cases. With a little background music, it takes little effort to do hundreds of cases at a sitting. At 2-4 seconds per case, you can do the math. I put the money “saved” into Lapua brass.;) I’m not the kind of guy that needs to have “the newest, greatest, most expensive”. I thought about buying the parts and building one. Instead, I treated myself to the Benchsource.
 
Last edited:
jimmymac said:
Maybe someone with hands on experience will chime in on this unit.
Click to expand...

That is the machine I use. I annealed with my home made rig for several years before buying a machine. I considered the Annealeez, but decided to spend a little more and buy the MRB unit. I know there are plenty of folks happy with their Annealeez, but I was hesitant to buy a machine with some known short comings.

I'm sure some of the AMP machines will chime in and tell you if you aren't using an AMP, you aren't annealing. I have a different opinion however.
 
Last edited:
I was tired of hand feeding my Benchsource so I sold it. Was going to either build the Gina-Erik induction, or buy something.

I initially considered the EZ-Anneal machine. It had induction and a casefeeder. Could run almost non-stop and was pretty much everything I was looking for. Then he raised the price substantially.

After using my buddies MRB while doing research and trying to make a decision, I decided to scrap the induction plans and got my own MRB. I dont have to hand feed each case and it works just fine. I'm happy with the build quality, although sometimes when loaded full of .308 brass they do jam up a little. Other than that, it works great.
 
Phil,

I have, and use the Annealeeze, Bench-Source, and Annealing Made Perfect (AMP). All three do an excellent job in annealing brass from 223 up to and including 375 Cheytac. I have the first version of the Annealeeze and totally replaced the gas nozzle holder as it was just inadequate; a new design has since been implemented and I can't speak to that. Once set up (maybe 5-10 minutes depending if you need to change out wheels for different size cases-very simple) the Annealeeze can just be filled up and let it run. Of course, never walk away from any open flame source. In short the Annealeeze is a relatively cheap, fast, convenient, single torch system that is self-contained and just works. The customer support is fantastic as the owner helped me solve a gear issue with an ultimately simple fix with a wrench by spending time with me on the phone in the middle of his dinner. That's helping the customer!

The Bench-Source is a two torch system that also requires a little bit of time to set up with some minor fiddling with the torch head holders but easily doable. Unlike the Annealeeze it does require constant attention to feed the rotating wheel with cases. As noted above, this is not a big deal once you get into a rhythm. Of course, one should never leave any machine with an open flame unattended including the Annealeeze. Again, this system can handle any case size up to and including 50 BMG. I use tempilaq for both the Annealeeze and Bench-Source. Two torches makes the annealing process go a little faster but not that much faster.
Of course, it is significantly more expensive than the Annealeeze. The two propane bottles will require some type of ingenuity on your part to conveniently store them both while using or not using the machine and unlike the Annealeeze it is not a self-contained unit that is easily movable. Customer service is very good and the owner is reachable and helpful.

The AMP machine is obviously an induction system that requires no propane bottles, open flames, or replacement propane bottles. It does require different case interfaces for the machine for each case size/caliber. Also, it requires that you hand feed each case just like the Bench-Source unless you buy a relatively expensive case feeder. Of course, the price for the AMP MK II is considerable compared to the other two machines. Again, customer service is second to none and you can use the machine in something called AZTEC mode to determine the "perfect" anneal time for your particular case and lot number. Also, you can send your cases in for testing on their machine to determine if it is perfectly annealed and can therefore calibrate your machine to perfectly anneal your particular cases. Kind of a pain to send things to New Zealand but, that is an option.

Bottom line, how much money do you want to spend and how into the newest and "greatest" are you? I think the most cost effective and efficient sweet spot is with the Annealeeze. But, as noted in the above posts, there are many options to choose from and that is a good thing. None of the machines are "cheap" regarding cost and you can decide how much you want to spend and what type of machine do you want and if you want torches or induction processes.

The above is only based on my experiences with the noted three machines and I don't have experience with any others. I hope you find this helpful.

Regards
Dan
 
You should start with why you “need” to anneal. If it’s just to soften up the necks then any machine will do. If you want to hit a tight tolerance of hardness, the amp seems to have nailed it and has the data to back it up. The rest are basically mechanisms to automate feeding cases through a flame.

If all you want is softer necks to extend life, the AMP is not a sensible solution due to its cost. If you want more, I can’t comment intelligently, as I have no idea how much it matters.
 
I've done thousands on a Bench source. Mostly 6br, but also 223 and 308. I have no experience with other brands but am totally happy with the bench source. I have heard it is possible to rig a Dillon style case feeder up to them, which would eliminate the hand feeding, but I've no tried it.
 
Phil3 said:
I need to have some brass annealed, and after having looked through a multitude of older threads on annealing machines, it does seem that induction annealing is the way to go...for a price. I am not prepared to shell out $1000+ for an annealing machine unless it is demonstrably much superior in results vs any other method (torch). I am ok with some inconvenience in use.

Perhaps technology, knowledge, and prices have changed for annealing in 2018, but what in your opinion are good values for the money? I am probably OK spending up to perhaps $500, but if twice that provides much superior brass, well, maybe I will consider the big buck machine.

I will shoot perhaps a couple thousand rounds a year I would guess, in 223, 6mmBR, and 6.5 x 47.

Thanks.

Phil
Click to expand...
I decided on the more expensive AMP annealing for a couple of reasons. First, I don't have to worry about open flames/fire accidents. Second, with a torch, you have to watch the temperature of the flame because it will vary as the propane level in the tank drops. I saw a thread of a way to help with that by using a large barbecue size tank and rigging up some in-line regulators. But I didn't want to do that. The exact correct amount of annealing for any brand/size case takes all guesswork and uncertainty out of the process. I have found that since I started using the AMP to get consistent annealing that the extreme spread had dropped by almost 50% on most of my handloads. I attribute that to consistent neck tension in the annealed brass. Like a lot of people say - cry once.
 
I will chime in with a vote for the AMP. I have one and consider it money well spent.

I think that Pag put it best when he said that if there was a need to own two, then he would own two, and so would I.
 
I decided to start annealing my cases for long range bench rest before the AMP was introduced.

As I have been an analog design engineer for 50 years with a significant part of that in Switched Mode power supplies, I decided to design an induction annealer.
Well, after playing with a bunch of circuits and blowing a hand full of MOS power devices, I decided experimenting wasn't fun anymore.

About that time, Fluxeon came out with their ANNIE annealer. So, I bought one. They had their share of hiccups with the difficult move into production and I had many problems. I stuck with them and they took care of me and after 3 problems, I ended up with the unit they supply now and absolute trouble free for many years.

Why the Annie doesn't get more press here is
beyond me. My ANNIE will anneal 100 cases in 15-20 minutes and after initially setting the correct anneal time with the use of Tempilac
I get very good, stable anneals. And last time I checked their price is still around $450.

I made a custom plastic base for mine with a glass rod sticking up through the water cooled coil (look up above in the ANNIE stickie) and I have glass rods cut for each case I anneal to get the anneal at the right part of the neck and shoulder area. That plus a tag taped on the platform with time vs case size and brand and I am good to go.

And, that is my recommendation!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

AMP Annealing Ltd Customer Service
Replies
5
Views
928
LarryDScott
Hand vs machine annealing
2 3
Replies
50
Views
2,298
justinp61
Advice for gas flame annealing - what is your process?
2
Replies
32
Views
1,384
Truckbed

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Classified Ads

Forum statistics

Threads
166,274
Messages
2,215,639
Members
79,518
Latest member
DixieDog

Share This Page

Back
Top