• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

Want .19 - Which One?

Posted at Long Range Hunter.com & varminter.com

I am posting to this forum because I believe that long range hunting is using the equipment that you have to ITS maximum potential. A 150 yd shot with a .22LR is really pushing the envelope but is truly a pleasure to achieve or watch. So long as the animal is killed quickly.

I have wanted to build a .19 for a long time but I don't know which one to choose...Badger, Calhoon or .19/223...

Which is the better cartridge for ease of reloading? Fireforming?

What effective--not extreme maximum--ranges would I expect from each?

Is one bolt action rifle easier to convert then another into these calibers? Anshutz, CZ etc. Gunsmith costs and base rifle price? I don't want to go the full custom route at this time as I have a .22 PPC, a 6mm PPC and a 6.5 X 284 ordered and a .33 going to be ordered and maybe a .25, so the money is tight.

I am leaning, sorta, kinda like to the Badger. Don't know why? Do you? Should I be?

I have some .17s and some .20s including a .204 Ruger so I don't want anything in those calibers.

I expect to be shooting within 200 to 300 yds. I'll be using it against coyotes, foxes, prairie pooches, foxes, squirrels, foxes, rabbits, foxes snowshoe hares, oh, and did I mention foxes.

When we went out rabbiting last weekend, we're getting between 70 and 100 bushytails every morning between 3 or 4 of us. It's their cycle, so we've been told, and as such the predators are also in abundance. I saw 12 different foxes in the space of 20 minutes, all greys or reds, and bloody huge. We're only taking the rabbit's rear legs and the skins and leaving the rest in huge piles...then come back in the afternoon and shoot predators over the piles. Monday, we got 3 foxes, greys, and a feisty badger...within about 45 minutes of calling. In three days of hunting we shot 2 coyotes, 7 red foxes, 6 grey foxes and 1 badger. It is illegal to shoot crows or ravens in Canada but we could have had easily 100 or more.

We used amongst ourselves besides .22LR and .17 HMR, .17 Rem, .204 Ruger, .218 Mashburn Bee, .218 Bee, .219 Zipper, .219 Donaldson Wasp, .222 Rem, .225 Win, .22 Hornet, .220 Swift and a .221 Fireball. Most on Martini or Winchester Lo Wall single shots and some older bolt actions. We are trying to keep alive the old calibers.

The other gun that I want to pick up, but much later, is a .15 for a neat little close-in shooter...and then maybe a .14, just because it's available and I believe it's man's given right to have as many rifles and calibers as possible--whether we shoot them or not!

Thanks in advance for any input in solving this stay awake at night ponderer!
 
another thought, the 19 has problably the best s.d. of the small bullets out there. So push it as fast as you can! plus, in a pinch you can use 17 cal cleaning stuff. the army liked the 19 cal so it can't be all bad, better s.d. than the 223 bullet.
 
I own both the 19 Calhoon and a 19-223 but I've just not fooled with them enough to give you an experienced based opinion. Hopefully that'll change very soon, but for the animals and ranges you mention, I'd think that the Badger would be the ticket. Brass forming for the Calhoon and 19-223 couldn't be any easier as no special dies are needed. Just run your cases through the FL die and shoot. I understand that forming for the Badger is a bit of a pain due to brass hardness. James offers preformed brass for the Badger at a very reasonable prices and that's the way everyone goes as far as I know.

Have you talked with the folks at James Calhoon Mfg? You'll not find nicer people anywhere and they'll not BS you or let you spend money that you don't need to. Hurry though, he generally shuts down for a few weeks around this time of year for elk hunting.

Check the archives over at www.saubier.com/forum.html for past discussions on the merits of the Badger. You'll also find a fellow over there that's having very good success shooting drawn down plastic tipped 20 cal bullets out of his Badger. Not that there's anything wrong with James' bullets but they are lacking a bit in the BC dept.

As for actions, I don't know. If you don't have a project rifle laying around, I'd just buy a rifle off of James and be done with it. The prices are very reasonable if you like CZ's. I assume that you've already visited their website but if not it's www.jamescalhoon.com
 
Big Ears, thanks for the info...I have an older Anshutz 1416 that I was thinking of changing over but I've gone the Calhoon route and just buying one of his CZ’s in .19 Badger...a whole bunch of pre-formed brass and bullets and a die set and have done with it...

I really couldn't decide so opted for my gut feeling...I just might buy the other two calibers later on, the kids can use them with me...

I’m still wanting a .14 and .15 rifles and those will be my next ventures in futility…and then maybe another .17 like a HeBee or Ackley Bee or Hornet…
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
165,925
Messages
2,206,299
Members
79,217
Latest member
NF1E
Back
Top