Interesting how different folks have different opinions (and I am not saying yours is wrong). When I got serious about prairie dog hunting I quickly found I needed something with more reference (I hold over, don't dial). The 4 plex once I got into the bold portion for wind holds, I had no reference for repeatability.
So I went down the Leupold VX-3 with VH reticle route. Think I had 5 or 6, but found they just didn't work for me. So I made others happy owners of my scopes.
For my 17 HMR/Mach 2, I really like the Sightron S-Tac 4-20 MOA-2 reticle. For my centerfires everything got standardized on Vortex on the Viper HS LR 6-24 FFP. When I bought my first one, I didn't even realize it was FFP or know what that meant for me. The beauty of being able to change power as the conditions (mirage) changes, and my holds remain the same is a real benefit. My normal shot is 200 yards, 10mph cross wind. I shoot that all day long once the wind starts. I know I need to hold 3MOA into the wind for the 6 inch drift that will occur. Shoot with the same hit percentage as I do before the wind starts.
Which will work better for you is the question.
Leupold VH retice
View attachment 1428645
Or a Christmas tree style reticle?
View attachment 1428646