• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

unshootable mirage

Mirage is caused by differences in air density, typically due to thermal effects. Light passes through air currents of varying density,which cause it to refract differently. The mathematics of light incidence and refraction due to mediums of differing density are described by Snell's Law. It's no different than the old example where a pen standing in a half-full glass of water looks as if it's bent. Mirage can affect your shot in at least two ways. The first and most obvious effect is that many use spotting scopes to visualize the air currents (i.e. mirage), which can be used to estimate wind speed and direction. An incorrect estimate of wind speed based on mirage will put a shot out just the same as an incorrect estimate based on wind flags will.

The second effect of mirage is far more sinister. In very strong mirage, the point you think you're aiming at on the target may not actually be where you're aiming. In the example of the pen in the glass of water, our brain tells us that the pen isn't really bent as it appears, largely based on the top segment of the pen that is observed through air only. From that segment, which functions somewhat like a "3-dimensional anchor", or point of reference, our brain can make a very good estimate where the submerged part of the pen is really located. When looking through a rifle scope in bad mirage at a target at 1000 yd, there may not be such an anchor, no common point of reference, etc. It can be very difficult to know that you are actually aiming the rifle at what you're seeing in the scope. One approach that can help with this is to pick your point of aim during your sighting shots and see how/where the mirage is actually displacing your shots, The difficulty in doing that is that you have to be able to distinguish between the visual effect of the mirage (i.e displacement), and what the wind was doing to the shot.
 
Last edited:
So Denys, what causes 'real' mirage? Is it not a change in the refractive index of the medium (air) through which the light (image) is passing caused by differential temperature of the layers? Edumucate me:).
What I was saying is that in French, the word mirage means "something that is not there even though you think you see it. What we call mirage, the heat shimmer, is definitely there but it's messing up our view of the target.

Savvy?
:D
 
Last week we shot in what is normal Mirage for Arizona Summer. I know some people say don't bother dialing back. I dialed back to around 15X. That seemed to help. Of course my scope is only a 8.5X25 . I am sure the mirage was still there, but at least the target settled down.
 
I shot with four others at 500yds yesterday and they were saying how bad it was. I am using the new Vortex Strike Eagle 5-26-52 and had no problem, I saw the X plain as day, but when I broke out the back up rifle with the Viper HST the mirage was horrible.
 
Shooting F class at Laurel MS one weekend and it was horrible. There was no way you could say you held the same spot twice. I came to the decision that if I ever had to shoot in mirage that bad again I was going to back off to 25 or less and dial.

It happened at Connaught last yr. I was shooting the Canadian Nats and the mirage was just abysmal. Dialed the whole match and held center. Shot the highest score I shot all weekend.
Laurel can be one of the worst mirage ranges I’ve ever seen. Had a match last year at 1k I just quit trying to use the scope and just trust the rifle to track
 
Laurel can be one of the worst mirage ranges I’ve ever seen. Had a match last year at 1k I just quit trying to use the scope and just trust the rifle to track
Yes, being that the firing line is only slightly above the grass and the e-target line much closer to ground level than a pulled target, Laurel's 1000yd range has the worst mirage I have ever seen. Sometimes it seems like the shimmering black meat ball is moving 2-3 MOA and forget about seeing any scoring rings.
 
That depends. Some people (like me) do not reduce magnification due to the phenomenon we incorrectly refer to as "mirage". (More on that below.) The MD disk supplied with some March scopes can be used at any magnification to expand the depth of field.



The term "mirage" is used incorrectly here, but since everybody calls it mirage, why fight it. The correct term would be "heat haze" or "heat shimmer," but for some reason we like our French terms in shooting: Mirage, Ogive. ;)

A real mirage (the optical illusion kind) is when, for example, you're driving on a long straight road and in the distance, there appears to be water, even a lake, on the road ahead. That is a mirage and you do not need a riflescope to see it.

What we experience in our riflescopes is heat shimmer, which is a gradient in the refractive index of the air caused by the variation in temperature between the air at the ground and the cooler air above. This heat shimmer effect is enhanced by telescopic sights to where you can actually see it, which is why when you reduce the magnification the effect diminishes to where you do not even see it without an optics of some kind.

Also, it's a lot more fun saying "I'm watching the mirage" instead of "I'm watching the heat shimmer." It has more of a touch of erudition to it, don't you think?
We girls could use the term shimmering!!
 
Last edited:
Last week we shot in what is normal Mirage for Arizona Summer. I know some people say don't bother dialing back. I dialed back to around 15X. That seemed to help. Of course my scope is only a 8.5X25 . I am sure the mirage was still there, but at least the target settled down.

I agree . . . I shot at Colorado Rifle Club last Saturday, 100yd BR. 12-15mph cross wind in near 90 degree heat. Mirage was boiling sideways. I have a 8-32x Sightron Siii. Dialed back to 24x, 12x looked even better since the mirage became so much more clearer! I used a foreground object to help assure I was aligned. Correction was nearly 6moa left! My target that put me into the Shootoff was a modest 24" 10-shot with a score of 88. If mirage is challenging for me it is challenging for everyone else in my relay.

my two cents,

BB
 
The only real way to solve this problem is the same way it is solved with ground based telescopes, active optics. However, a similar problem (only at the user end) is solved quite well in high end camera lenses like the Canon L series and similar lenses from other makers. Electronic image stabilization. It is designed to address camera shake where in this sport, the shake is in the object itself. Not real shake mind you but the appearance of shake do to atmospheric disturbances. The lenses have motors that micro adjust the lens to keep the image stable. Would not necessarily increase the resolution of the image (that would be the realm of active/adaptive optics) but it could stop that X ring from hopping around like a jack rabbit. I'm surprised that scope makers have not already incorporated the technology into competition rifle scopes.
 
In camera lenses with image stabilization (IS for Canon) or vibration reduction (VR for Nikon), there are tiny gyroscopes built into the lenses that detect camera movement and adjust the lenses accordingly. This usually buys you 2 to 4 stops and it's quite useful when handholding a long lens and using a rather slow shutter speed. The IS or VR does NOTHING for a moving subject. Also, astute photographers disable IS or VR when the camera is mounted on a tripod (somewhat akin to a riflescope on top of a rifle in a 72 pound rest or sophisticated bipod.)

I should also think that the repeated violent recoil experienced by riflescopes when the round is fired, would cause havoc on the tiny, fragile gyros.

Also, the last thing a target shooter wants is for the riflescope to move around independently of the rifle. That's not really conducive to repeatability.

And of course, IS or VR requires power and will further increase the cost.
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
167,301
Messages
2,229,530
Members
80,313
Latest member
KeithIgoe
Back
Top