I got a rifled barrel for my Winchester 1200. This was back in the last century....LOL. Bought a box or two of a dozen or so different slugs to try, looking for that magic combination that shot knots at 100 yards. I drilled and tapped the receiver, and mounted a scope to help squeeze out whatever I could from that set-up. What I found was that almost everything shot inside of about 3 inches at 50 yards, and with eerily similar points of impact, so similar sight settings. Going to 100 was where things changed. For me and my setup, the Active slugs shot about 4" groups, and were readily available back then, so that's what I hunted with. The sabot slugs were new back then. I did shoot BRI sabots and they did well, but were at least double the price when you could find them. The BRI sabots would hit sideways from my Mossberg 500 smoothbore at anything past 60 yards, which is why I got the rifled barrel for the 1200.
I also observed that buckshot would print donut shaped patterns from the rifled barrel, so while that was an option from smoothbore slug barrels, it didn't work in the rifled barrel for me either. Didn't matter if it was double-O, Triple-O, or #4 buck, 2¾" or 3", it spread out to those donut patterns much faster from the rifled barrel. I wouldn't even use that for home defense, it was too erratic.
I've been shooting the Hornady SST slugs through that same barrel lately, using a 2½x scope, with really good results. They're expensive, but they shoot flatter at 100, and will hold under 3 MOA for me on the range.
For home defense, with shots being inside 25 yards, I'd think a smoothbore would work just fine. A buddy had an 870 smoothbore slug gun that was back-bored and magna-ported (pro-ported??) by JD Jones. That thing shot the Winchester foster slugs at 50 yards where all the holes touched. I know because I shot it myself. Those are $3/box slugs too. Buckshot would stay inside a piece of notebook paper at 10 yards.