• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

Reasonable ACCURACY lifespan for an AR15 barrel

Did you catch how they determined the cleaning intervals?
And, what would you think of cleaning your service rifle barrel after 400 rounds? Seems like a carbon ring could easily build up before cleaning. And, I'm thinking it's going to be a significant cleaning session.

On the 300 rapids - I get how rapid fire wears the barrel faster, but not why the groups would open up at 300 but still group well at 600.
 
My understanding is as rate of fire becomes more rapid than 1 round for every 10 seconds barrel life suffers at an exponential rate.
 
Did you catch how they determined the cleaning intervals?
And, what would you think of cleaning your service rifle barrel after 400 rounds? Seems like a carbon ring could easily build up before cleaning. And, I'm thinking it's going to be a significant cleaning session.

On the 300 rapids - I get how rapid fire wears the barrel faster, but not why the groups would open up at 300 but still group well at 600.
They made a few mentions that they cleaned when their "standard ammo" went out of bounds, but like I mentioned they stayed vague on specifics.

I always cleaned my SR rig at the end of a day, even if I was going to shoot more the next day. It was just too easy to stay out of trouble with the bbl, but also with the BCG and trigger. When I used to compete in silhouette, I would test to the limits, then clean with margin to that limit. I never hit the limit with my SR rigs cause I am usually too tired after practicing to want that problem.

A SR Club match was at least 88 rounds so going two cycles would be no less than 176 rounds. With rapids and environment, I never bothered to push the rig to failure just because it was too easy to clean and lube at the end of a day and not worry. I don't even check the barrel till it goes over 2500 rounds.

My theory on the reason performance drops on the 300 rapids before the 600, are two fold.

One is I am far better at sling-prone than I am at 200 sitting rapid, and so I would see the problem with more confidence than 200. I can just hold sling-prone tighter, so my detection level is lower. I might not find that problem at 200 just cause I can't hold that tight sitting.

The second dimension to the issue is the heat build up. It will usually be the second string that shows the problem because the bbl is already hot, and then we hit it with more rapids. The cadence is based on 60 to 70 seconds, versus I usually take 13 to 14 minutes on the 600 yard line, so the bbl temp stays much lower. The gun gets hot enough during the second 300 rapid string that the group can open up but when kept cooler will still go several hundred more rounds while holding inside the X when shot slowly.
 
They made a few mentions that they cleaned when their "standard ammo" went out of bounds, but like I mentioned they stayed vague on specifics.

I always cleaned my SR rig at the end of a day, even if I was going to shoot more the next day. It was just too easy to stay out of trouble with the bbl, but also with the BCG and trigger. When I used to compete in silhouette, I would test to the limits, then clean with margin to that limit. I never hit the limit with my SR rigs cause I am usually too tired after practicing to want that problem.

A SR Club match was at least 88 rounds so going two cycles would be no less than 176 rounds. With rapids and environment, I never bothered to push the rig to failure just because it was too easy to clean and lube at the end of a day and not worry. I don't even check the barrel till it goes over 2500 rounds.

My theory on the reason performance drops on the 300 rapids before the 600, are two fold.

One is I am far better at sling-prone than I am at 200 sitting rapid, and so I would see the problem with more confidence than 200. I can just hold sling-prone tighter, so my detection level is lower. I might not find that problem at 200 just cause I can't hold that tight sitting.

The second dimension to the issue is the heat build up. It will usually be the second string that shows the problem because the bbl is already hot, and then we hit it with more rapids. The cadence is based on 60 to 70 seconds, versus I usually take 13 to 14 minutes on the 600 yard line, so the bbl temp stays much lower. The gun gets hot enough during the second 300 rapid string that the group can open up but when kept cooler will still go several hundred more rounds while holding inside the X when shot slowly.
For reference, I hold a high master card in high power - using a match rifle.

Except for matches, I've been cleaning my barrel after at least 60-70 rounds but not more than 150 [just depends on the number of rounds on it after a range session] for two reasons.
Preemptively catch carbon rings early​
Ensure I stay away from having accuracy degrade due to fouling​
My 'strategy' has been to clean to a 'known' condition - i.e., the amount of black in the grooves in the first 5 inches which I check via a borescope. The condition I've been using is: The lands are free of any black; grooves only have black in the corners; the carbon ring at the very beginning of the throat [i.e., not in the chamber - I've never seen one of those] is not all the way around the throat and where it has formed it's not solid.

I mention all this to get your comments. Thanks
 
I agree with your post. I don't like to over or under clean an XTC rig.

I like to keep away from trouble. If I drop points, it should be because of my aim, not a malfunction or dirty barrel.

I also think the Hornady podcast was decent but would like to see the study/math behind those spreadsheet values. If it is as simple as an average and +/- 2sigma, then they could have said so without a lot of trouble.

They don't shoot rapids in a testing lab while doing load development data or QC checks on bullets. That cadence helps extend the bbl life of those test rigs.
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
164,684
Messages
2,182,663
Members
78,476
Latest member
375hhfan
Back
Top