• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

Picking a Powder

I'm planning to retire in a couple of years. In the meantime I want to learn what I can about reloading to reduce the learning curve for when I have time to start doing it.

I'm putting experimental loads on paper to see what I come up with, but so far I have found remarkably little describing the characteristics of the numerous powders available. I shouldn't have to find every manufacturer, and their website, and download the data for every powder very one of them has. I would expect to see a listing of a powder's speed relative to others, its burn temperature relative to others, and its energy density. Certainly SOMEBODY must have come up with a listing like this showing all ,or most, of the powders available. Where is it?
 
I have shot with a GREAT MANY powders over the years with an equal amount of cartridges to shoot them in. Here is an observation: "I have not yet seen a "burn rate chart" that actually puts the powders in the correct "spot" on the list". They use the chemical "explosion / heat" numbers listed by the manufacturer to place the powder on the list, INSTEAD of actually testing the powders in several cartridges. Even QuickLoad has to have the "burn rate adjusted" after you get a baseline velocity and measurements of a loaded round. That means that QuickLoad uses the manufacturers numbers just like those that create a chart. Actual experience /usage of a given powder, has "told me" where to start, even with new wildcats that I am flying by the seat of my pants with! It has always been said that experience is the best teacher>>>and it is true!
 
Last edited:
Shooters World Powder's has a Printable Burn Rate of Most Powders on the Mart ?
The Shortage of Powder is a Problem at this Time.

I would recommend trying to find a copy of a old Speer #8 reloading Manual ! The Section on Trouble Shooting is very Helpful.

Best of Luck Traveling the Rabbit Hole

Don
 
I'm planning to retire in a couple of years. In the meantime I want to learn what I can about reloading to reduce the learning curve for when I have time to start doing it.

I'm putting experimental loads on paper to see what I come up with, but so far I have found remarkably little describing the characteristics of the numerous powders available. I shouldn't have to find every manufacturer, and their website, and download the data for every powder very one of them has. I would expect to see a listing of a powder's speed relative to others, its burn temperature relative to others, and its energy density. Certainly SOMEBODY must have come up with a listing like this showing all ,or most, of the powders available. Where is it?
I've been reloading for over 50 years for field shooting. The core considerations are case capacity, expansion ratio, (chamber volume + bore volume ÷ chamber volume) read this as (case capacity and length of barrel per caliber) ergo the longer barrel the larger the expansion ratio for the same caliber as a general guide and then the projectile weight.

Desired projectile weight, barrel length to achieve goal, (ease of carry, end velocity, general use of rifle), then consult a powder burn rate chart.

The general rule is per caliber the heavier the projectile weight the slower the powder, also the longer the barrel to required to burn the slower burning powder.

Compare load data for cartridges of similar (or best) the same case capacity.

A simple example is a 300 Savage and a 308 Winchester, same caliber, very similar case capacity, very similar viable projectile weights per barrel length. Consult 308 load data and a burn rate chart, powders for the 308 will be a good starting point for the 300 Savage using equal bullet weights, be conservative use low start loads.

A more difficult example; I had to develop 500 grain loads for a custom 450 Magnum Marlin bolt gun as at the time no such load existed.

The book Cartridges of the World showed the wildcat 458 x 2, the 45 70 Government and the 450 Marlin to be nearly identical case capacity with the 458 x 2 and Marlin the same. First try produced my desired velocity with a 5 shot ragged hole group at 50 yards with 45 magnum caliber, iron sighted dangerous game rifle.

READ, there's plenty of books, BEWARE of the internet, in all these years I've almost never seen blown up guns or melted brass until the last decade.

Also this can be as simple as reloading for the field, requiring responsible loading, producing 1" groups at 300 yards or state of the art precision loading, producing record groups at a mile as well as producing the responsibility and costs that go along with that.

Enjoy!
 
The answer to how to pick a powder is experience. You start by reading about other shooters experiences. Then take a few of the best experiences and try them yourself. No magic bullet answer to your question.
 
I would recommend any new hand loader to get a copy of Ken Water's "Pet Loads". Not only is it a good read, but the basic "culture" of load development and wildcatting is a great start.

BTW - if you type handloader as one word in here, wants to change to bandleader. Woke spell check?
 
Grab the book metallic cartridge reloading, a lyman manual the lyman casting manual. This will give you a very broad understanding of the processes including casting and the tools required. How you want to shoot and how perfect you want your loads will change the results. You could basically load any cartridge with 2 powders. Unique and h4895 will do almost everything unless your shooting major outliers like the 50bmg. If you are trying to establish a small stash of powder to learn with and have a good fall back supply a couple of 8lb jugs will keep you in the game.
 
I believe you're making this more complicated than is necessary.

If you are shooting traditional calibers there is a vast amount of information available on known combo's of powders / bullets that work very well for those calibers.

A good place to start in with a Lyman, Sierra, or Nosler loading manual that publishes "most accurate" load tested. It's not absolute but a good place to begin especially in this time of shortages that may last for quite awhile.

The Lyman Reloading Handbook is one of the best for describing the reloading process."

Whatever you decide, my advice is to adhere to published data by reliable sources. Beware of Rambo's "pet loads" for which there is no published data.
 
The easiest method of choosing a powder per CARTRIDGE is to peruse several manuals and look at the top 3 or 4 powders listed that produce the fastest velocities.
Usually there will be 1or 2 powders at the top across all those manuals, these powders will be the one’s with optimal burning and pressure.
This is how you choose powder.
Burn rate charts are meaningless, as what one powder company lists as RQ100 will be different to another companies RQ100 number, this number is what all other powders in that companies list is compared to. There is NO STANDARD to measure off.

Cheers.
 
You don't say what cartridges you will be loading for. Some of the more popular cartridges have been worked over by lots of folks and there are known good loads to chose from. Given the current availability of components, you may not be able to obtain your preferred choices and will be forced to use less than ideal powders, primers, brass, and bullets. Several good loading manuals are a must.
 
I'm planning to retire in a couple of years. In the meantime I want to learn what I can about reloading to reduce the learning curve for when I have time to start doing it.

I'm putting experimental loads on paper to see what I come up with, but so far I have found remarkably little describing the characteristics of the numerous powders available. I shouldn't have to find every manufacturer, and their website, and download the data for every powder very one of them has. I would expect to see a listing of a powder's speed relative to others, its burn temperature relative to others, and its energy density. Certainly SOMEBODY must have come up with a listing like this showing all ,or most, of the powders available. Where is it?
Your making it more complicated than necessary. I don't buy Vit or Norma powder because it's expensive. For starters I would go to Accurate Shooter on this website, click on your caliber and see what the best shooters use. In the reloading manuals I look at which 2-3 powders give the highest safe fps. Forget burn rate The powders with the highest fps are the most efficient for speed, doesn't mean they are the best for accuracy,. I have 6BR and a 6BRX no other caliber. Never had more that 5 powder types and after chrono'ing them I rejected several. My rifles are Varmint rifles that always shoot around .350" if I am doing a good job. I don't think you can relate burn temp and energy density to accuracy.
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
166,294
Messages
2,215,838
Members
79,519
Latest member
DW79
Back
Top