Hi-NV Shooter
Gold $$ Contributor
Lee,
Yes, Mike Ross, Jeff Madison, and I spent considerable time investigating the potential benefits from indexing barrels. The majority of our testing showed a slight improvement in precision when the bore curves were clocked to 6 or 12, but it wasn't statistically significant. I often wrestle with myself as to whether it's another one of those crumbs worth pursuing or if it's better to concentrate on those variables that are already proven to enhance performance.
As regards coned chambers being less stable than traditional, I'm not sure I can answer that. Maybe "Hoop Stress" calculations in conjunction with an FEA would provide some clarity, but considering the relatively low pressures we deal with in RF, I don't personally feel coned chambers would be less stable and there are a lot of great shooting rifles that utilize them for one reason or another and not just for indexing. That being said, some cones are designed poorly and do cause problems.
If you do decided to investigate indexing farther, I have one suggestion. Based on the assumption that 6 or 12 is the ideal clock position, design your testing around using only 2 positions such as 12 and 3, 12 and 9, 6 and 3, etc. It'll save you hundreds if not thousands of rds in any attempt at finding something close to statistical significance vs trying to shoot all the way around the clock.
Landy
Landy Thanks for the suggestion on where to start. now if I try this that's another story.
Lee