Not
@Forum Boss, but I've been doing a bit of that this year. See:
https://forum.accurateshooter.com/threads/h4350-alternatives-including-new-viht-n555.4017410/
In fact, I'm not long home from my final range session in the exercise earlier today having eventually 'done' 16 powders including the two now banned in the UK benchmarks (H4350 and H414). N555 was also run a second time since my earlier post in the other thread, now in reformed and neck-turned 308 Win Lapua Palma brass to see how it reacts to small primer ignition.
I'll update the thread above in the next few days with broad findings then write it up for Target Shooter online e-zine early in the new year.
Overall, the three ball grades tried disappointed (H414, Ramshot Big Game and Hunter) - not terrible by any means, but uniformly behind the best of the extrudeds.
Also, overall the 'velocity kings' the aggressive high-nitroglycerin numbers disappointed (Norma URP, Alliant Re16 and 17). Great MV averages, but not so hot in their groups and spreads.
The two Czech manufactured Lovex (Shooters World in the US) extrudeds (SO-65 / SW 'Long Rifle' and SO-70 / SW4350) performed very well and consistently as I expected having long liked this producer's tubular powders. Their 'legs' were short though, especially SO-70 / SW4350 whose MVs were way, way down on what QuickLOAD predicted and ended up 100 fps down on H4350 despite + 1gn charge weight and a full-case in the 7mm-08. (May be useful in something roomier like my 284 Win and 300 SAUM F-Class rifles.) SO-65 / SW 'Long Rifle' could be an excellent grade though for those not needing max speed and willing to trade price saving and availability against a not vast MV reduction against H4350.
N555 is an excellent performer in the 7mm-08 in LP brass. Overall, I was very impressed. However ........!! The SP reformed 308 Palma results were poorer. Not disastrously, but it was no longer a star. Groups and ES values grew noticeably, although interestingly MVs remained as per LP results with the top loads
Star #2 was good old-fashioned, been with us forever (1984 it arrived in the UK) Viht N160. As good if not better groups and ES values as N555 and only a few fps less MV in the 7mm-08. (In 260 Rem and Creedmoor though the higher case capacity to bore ratio values and the Creedmoor's smaller case will almost certainly see N555 outperform N160.) I was so impressed, I'll likely switch from my current 7-08 match load of a compressed charge of N160 in SP brass to a lower charge / MV combination in Lapua LP cases. (Even my club shoots have so many 284s, WSMs, SAUMs now that the little 7-08 has been pushed into a disadvantageous position in mid-range matches and I can happily give up the extra speed I get with SP for 300 yard comps.)
Star #3 was a Europe only Nitrochemie powder, the newish to us tubular single-based Reload Swiss RS62 which outperformed H4350 in speed, precision and consistency. This didn't surprise me at all as I've yet to find an application where RS62 doesn't at least match H4350. As its supply position here is mostly good (no shortage of stock, but not many LGSs stocking it) we're better off now with it than when we could still get H4350, but only fitfully and usually ratione. RS62's only downside that I can see so far is its rather long-grained formulation which pushes up fill-ratios and doesn't suit mechanical powder measures.
IMR-4451 was a steady performer and shows considerable promise. (As I also found in the 6.5 Creedmoor a few years ago when the powder was new in the UK long after its US introduction.) MVs are up by a useful 20-30 odd fps over H4350, or they are at least when keeping within Hodgdon and Sierra Manual ed VI maximum loads. I'm sure that H4350 can be (and is) 'pushed' a lot further and higher by many such is its flexibility and good manners
Norma 204 looked like it can be 'pushed' to much higher levels than I used and to considerably higher MVs than H4350, but the jury is out on its consistency and groups.