Medic505
Gold $$ Contributor
Why? And, I'm not being a smartass. What information do you gather by doing this that is different from what you'd get with a comparator?Every freshly reamed barrel of mine gets a casting.
Why? And, I'm not being a smartass. What information do you gather by doing this that is different from what you'd get with a comparator?Every freshly reamed barrel of mine gets a casting.
It's a hard copy of what your reamer actually did. You'll also see how longWhy? And, I'm not being a smartass. What information do you gather by doing this that is different from what you'd get with a comparator?
I guess all that would depend on what temperature your casting is and how well you could accurately measure. So many variables.It's a hard copy of what your reamer actually did. You'll also see how long
the neck actually is and it's actual width for turning purposes. Besides the
the throat and lead, I like to see how tight the throat is.
Unless you have access to (and the operation knowledge of) laser scanning devices, chamber castings are going to be as accurate as it gets. The shrink ratio of the casting won’t be enough to matter for the purpose of measuring freebore or neck turning diameter.I guess all that would depend on what temperature your casting is and how well you could accurately measure. So many variables.
It's a decent tool however you can easily take 5 measurements using exactly the same bullet procedure etc., and achieve 5 different sizes. So I pick the 2 that are the closest and go from there. It's a good idea but it has its limitations. I don't remember getting the exact measurement twice ever. Design and user are two huge factors. For me it's 'close' enough.
Yes Sir !! I use Roto Metals 158/190 F. chamber cast. There reallyUnless you have access to (and the operation knowledge of) laser scanning devices, chamber castings are going to be as accurate as it gets. The shrink ratio of the casting won’t be enough to matter for the purpose of measuring freebore or neck turning diameter.
I do agree on the importance of the operator’s ability to use a measuring tool, though.
1. You need to make sure the modified case is securely tightened all the way down.It's a decent tool however you can easily take 5 measurements using exactly the same bullet procedure etc., and achieve 5 different sizes. So I pick the 2 that are the closest and go from there. It's a good idea but it has its limitations. I don't remember getting the exact measurement twice ever. Design and user are two huge factors. For me it's 'close' enough.
An excellent master rifle smith told me essentially the same thing a few years ago.The issue with the above is how hard the rod is pushed up against the base of the bullet can vary the reading. I put the bullet in the case and keep the rod backed off and locked. Turn the barrel to muzzle down and let the bullet fall in to the lead angle. Unlock the rod lock and let it fall on to the bullet base, Lock the rod, remove it, remove the bullet and check. I can do this ten times and get a measurement within a couple thousandths.
Edit: I use the Wheeler method on a new barrel with the bullets I plan on using, then use the Hornady for comparison.
Unless you have access to (and the operation knowledge of) laser scanning devices, chamber castings are going to be as accurate as it gets.
Yes, but they are typically for larger cavities. The typical scanner should be able to accurately measure depth of a relatively shallow hole. I am not an expert on their use, but I believe the depth of a chamber should be within the scope from my limited experience. I would run a dowel into the barrel to where it would contact a loaded round. It should plot a pretty darn accurate chamber profile mesh.Are there laser scanning devices for internal surfaces?
Looks to be a good product.Safer than metal casts you might try http://www.reprorubber.com. This will produce a detailed and exact replica. For the best accurate measurements they are usually done with an optical comparator or CMM. With care adequate measurements can be made with hand tools bearing in mind that this cast is flexible.
I would assume when you are opening the action using that method, you might want to give the bullet some help with a cleaning rod down the bore while extracting? If not, I would think you might stick the bullet in the lands, or pull it out of the neck a little?
That is A method…….
