Oh, I know it happens. I've seen it in classes I've been in and with people I've coached. I've also noticed that the vast majority of shooters making the egregious errors are new shooters.Mean,
In late October I took a friend out cause his rifle was shooting bad with new ammo. He was all over. I put a little rail level on that I use to mount scopes and he was amazed how much can’t he shot with. His groups were still bad vertically, but the horiz was remedied. This was a level range, flat ground at 400yds. He ordered 2 scope levels since.
Oh, I know it happens. I've seen it in classes I've been in and with people I've coached. I've also noticed that the vast majority of shooters making the egregious errors are new shooters.
It is a training issue that should be fixed with more practice and brain calibration rather than with one more gadget. Common sense has to ask, "How did targets ever get shot without bubble levels?" They have only been commonly available for a few years now. My peers and I have been hitting targets way out there (1200+ yds) for a very long time without them. They can be handy, especially if you are trying to stack rounds in an x-ring. In a field environment they are just a crutch that can waste time, or worse, lead you astray if they get bumped.
This would be an interesting experiment. Put tape on the side of the bubble level that faces you. Film the level from the other side. From various positions, cant the rifle to 45 degrees or so then bring it back to level by sight and feel. When it is level by your judgment, say "level" out loud. Go back and look at the video to see how good or bad you did.
Charlie, that is like saying a carpenter built a house without a level and it was almost as good as a level. But it isn’t. It’s either level or it isn’t. Math says any cant degrades accuracy, period.
Look, it is not a huge deal. If you love them, then you love them. There is no shame in that. Some of us like to maintain proficiency with as few helps as possible. I occasionally take my plain old Ruger 30-06 deer rifle, with the duplex 3-9x leupold on it, out to 600 yds on a 3/4 chest plate, just to remind myself that I can. Hell, I still shoot iron sights sometimes!Uninformed conclusion? It is simple math. Gravity + cant = horizontal dispersion. I will watch the video.
Watched the video long range 56. He was prone in the same place. Now try that test while in different shooting locations and see how plumb he is. Do what you want, but saying “scope levels don’t work” or saying “you can be as level with or without” are simply false.
As for vestibular senses, talk to any pilot about how they can and do fail you.
Look, it is not a huge deal. If you love them, then you love them. There is no shame in that. Some of us like to maintain proficiency with as few helps as possible. I occasionally take my plain old Ruger 30-06 deer rifle, with the duplex 3-9x leupold on it, out to 600 yds on a 3/4 chest plate, just to remind myself that I can. Hell, I still shoot iron sights sometimes!
But do this, take a large bullseye target and intentionally cant your rifle 2 degrees and see how crooked that looks. If it doesn't look that crooked to you, then you really do need a bubble level.
Just so we know what kind of drastic changes we are talking about here, using a 6.5 Creed with a .600 BC bullet @ 2750 fps, a 5 degree cant = an additional .2" of drop and an additional 3.4" of windage at 1000 yards. According to JBMballistics.
I've already stated a couple of times that the bubble could easily make the difference between an "X" and a "10". I also stated that I shoot iron sights.In F-Class that would take a dead center "X" shot and make it a 10, you just explained how it does make quite a difference at 1,000 yards. If you want a true test of your skill set why don't you just use open sights or a longbow?
I've already stated a couple of times that the bubble could easily make the difference between an "X" and a "10". I also stated that it took an absurd 5 degree cant to do that. I also stated that I shoot iron sights.
I realize that my opinion involves a broader view of shooting disciplines.... beyond what the OP refers to as "bench target shooting". So sue me.
You are correct, I had to go back and find out what I did wrong in JBM. Originally, I left the zero at 100 yds and looked at the difference in windage at 1000 yds. When I changed the zero to 1000 yds then the error increased to a little over 5" per degree. So I was wrong about the amount of cant needed to be significant.I am not sure about the part about it taking an absurd 5 degree cant to move from an X to a 10. This article http://www.accurateshooter.com/optics/canting-effect-on-point-of-impact/ implies that an 8 degree cant takes you all the way off the paper at 1000 yards.
Well here's something to comtinplate. As I said if the scope is set up right does it matter if the rifle is canted? The answer is yes and no. I'll explain. Your rifle is zero'd at X range and now you want to shoot a target and the rifle is canted 20 degrees. Where the crosshairs intersect does not change.. Theoretically, you should be able to rotate the scope 360 degrees with no POI change. The degree of cant doesn't matter. ( that's the no answer ). Now the yes answer: However, if your shooting with the same 20 degree cant and make a windage change (or elevation) on the scope your going to get both verticle AND horizontal change. That's the simple answer.
You are only correct to a degree. Yes, a shooter may set up his rifle with a small amount of cant to suit his body position and level the crosshairs and adjust his zero to compensate. However, you are wrong in the assertion that POI would not change.Well here's something to comtinplate. As I said if the scope is set up right does it matter if the rifle is canted? The answer is yes and no. I'll explain. Your rifle is zero'd at X range and now you want to shoot a target and the rifle is canted 20 degrees. Where the crosshairs intersect does not change.. Theoretically, you should be able to rotate the scope 360 degrees with no POI change. The degree of cant doesn't matter. ( that's the no answer ). Now the yes answer: However, if your shooting with the same 20 degree cant and make a windage change (or elevation) on the scope your going to get both verticle AND horizontal change. That's the simple answer.