This looks to be an all around scope
Buddy has had real good luck with accuracy of Nikons Moa hash marksI like simple plex reticles with a 5ish MOA subtension at optics highest power (coupled with a low-profile target elevation turret). Nikon is great for establishing even subtensions with their plex reticles. The plex reticle is definitely the simplest ballistic and rangefinding reticle ever made.
Familiarity with a reticle makes use easier. If all you use is Mil-dots then a fast shot can be made. The Horus H-59 may take a bit longer to adapt to as it were second nature.It depends on what you are hunting. Two leggers or four leggers. In a mountain terrain, heavy woods I would avoid clutter reticles. If I was hunting two leggers in the open or at a distance I would avoid simplicity. They shoot back. Just my first cup of coffee thoughts. Time change creates jet lag and I never left the ground.
Honestly, I'm in the same boat, a german #4 or a duplex works great for our areas. lolI hunt Whitetails mostly in the swamps and the thick stuff associated with the swamps here in NE NY . I prefer a standard duplex (Leupold). I also like the German reticles ,easy to find in low light.