• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

Beaten by the buck I bagged

Prose

Silver $$ Contributor
This story is entirely true despite the rumors.

First year deer hunting with a new rifle built by hand on a modern Mauser style action. Only one expense was spared, that being the $22 scope rings instead of those made in the USA costing about $90. Load testing throughout the summer shows consistent accuracy below ½ MOA for a three shot group. Groups at 300 actually measured about 1/2 inch so whatever that works out to be. My frugality was solidly holding.

The evening hunt (11/4, Northern MN) was bitterly windy, with a heavy mix of sleet and snow. The water beads formed perfectly on the hand-rubbed stock. I had been thinking that it was perfect weather for having a cheap plastic stock on a throwaway rifle, but was proud to have built an accurate and attractive one.

My posting for the evening hunt was unusual to account for the weather. End of legal shooting was set to be 6:29pm. Immediately behind me was a deep ditch with a two lane road on the other side. To my left and right were 40 acre blocks of trees, and straight in front of me was a stream that intersected the ditch along the road. Along this stream were two narrow clearings. The thought was that I may see deer as they cross the stream or come to cross the road. This stream intersected the ditch about 10 yards to my right.

About 6:25, I saw a mature buck and doe slip into the stream and could occasionally see them peek out at me. I low crawled to the edge of the stream and waited behind the accumulating snow and some grass. Checking the time repeatedly, the buck showed up in my scope at 6:28pm. He dropped violently from the 130 grain nosler that was placed in his neck just below the chin. The doe ran back into to woods to my right. I followed her for about 30 seconds until the likelihood of a good shot had disappeared. I went back to look at the buck laying in the stream, but he wasn’t there. He was 20 yards away, across the ditch and stream intersection and struggling to stand-up right in the center of the road. The faintest shimmer of headlights danced against his white tail and I audibly swore no doubt. My father in laws last words before this hunt, “Don’t let em cross that road.”

I ran toward him, not willing to shoot at him on the roadway. I made it to exactly the middle of the ditch before losing my footing, falling into the water, and flinging my rifle into the air. Undeterred, I continued toward the buck rifle-less. My mission was to make sure he didn’t get run over by the vehicle or catch a second wind, or worse, found by other hunters that had more guns than me. About this moment he had fallen immediately onto the far shoulder of the road. I lept on top of him and held him down. The deer was very interested in me not holding him down, and if not for the gunshot wound to his neck, and most of his blood pouring out, I probably would not have succeeded. The truck passed and I grabbed an antler and dragged him back to my side of the road. He kicked and gasped while I looked for my rifle. Once the rifle was found the struggle was ended.

Two or so minutes later, my brother in law pulled up to me on the shoulder, looked me over, and asked, “Is that your blood?”

Over the next few days. I would miss three shots on two more deer (Lucky for me my wife doesn’t drop her guns, and let me borrow hers to close out the season). Post hunting evaluation shows the scope rings did not handle the roughly six aerial feet traversed by rifle. Shift in point of impact was about 20” at 100 yards. Scope is fine. New rings, the ones I should have bought the first time, have been ordered.

Eight or so months ago, when talking with my friend Rueben, he cautiously scoffed at the notion of saving money on a build. I think we both understood it as a dumb decision, but it was that one thing that made me able to tell my wife, “Look how much I saved!”
 
Last edited:
But just one picture to cement the mental image would be nice. Like maybe a shot of the road or remains of the wrestling match.

Even the best books often have a sketch or picture on the cover.
 
Hmm...me thinks the sight in of a dropped rifle should be checked before hunting with it again no matter the quality of the scope rings involved. Your quarry deserves your best shot at a clean kill.
It simply did not cross my mind. On the second dear I figured I must have hit a branch or something and it was an unsupported shot. The third dear was a wide open shot, no excuses for the miss... that's when it popped into my head.
 
I thought it was a great story. Made me smile and think if similar circumstances. Granted.. resighting the rifle should have been done, but we all make mistakes at time. Neverless it was a good story! Thanks for sharing.
 
This story is entirely true despite the rumors.

First year deer hunting with a new rifle built by hand on a modern Mauser style action. Only one expense was spared, that being the $22 scope rings instead of those made in the USA costing about $90. Load testing throughout the summer shows consistent accuracy below ½ MOA for a three shot group. Groups at 300 actually measured about 1/2 inch so whatever that works out to be. My frugality was solidly holding.

The evening hunt (11/4, Northern MN) was bitterly windy, with a heavy mix of sleet and snow. The water beads formed perfectly on the hand-rubbed stock. I had been thinking that it was perfect weather for having a cheap plastic stock on a throwaway rifle, but was proud to have built an accurate and attractive one.

My posting for the evening hunt was unusual to account for the weather. End of legal shooting was set to be 6:29pm. Immediately behind me was a deep ditch with a two lane road on the other side. To my left and right were 40 acre blocks of trees, and straight in front of me was a stream that intersected the ditch along the road. Along this stream were two narrow clearings. The thought was that I may see deer as they cross the stream or come to cross the road. This stream intersected the ditch about 10 yards to my right.

About 6:25, I saw a mature buck and doe slip into the stream and could occasionally see them peek out at me. I low crawled to the edge of the stream and waited behind the accumulating snow and some grass. Checking the time repeatedly, the buck showed up in my scope at 6:28pm. He dropped violently from the 130 grain nosler that was placed in his neck just below the chin. The doe ran back into to woods to my right. I followed her for about 30 seconds until the likelihood of a good shot had disappeared. I went back to look at the buck laying in the stream, but he wasn’t there. He was 20 yards away, across the ditch and stream intersection and struggling to stand-up right in the center of the road. The faintest shimmer of headlights danced against his white tail and I audibly swore no doubt. My father in laws last words before this hunt, “Don’t let em cross that road.”

I ran toward him, not willing to shoot at him on the roadway. I made it to exactly the middle of the ditch before losing my footing, falling into the water, and flinging my rifle into the air. Undeterred, I continued toward the buck rifle-less. My mission was to make sure he didn’t get run over by the vehicle or catch a second wind, or worse, found by other hunters that had more guns than me. About this moment he had fallen immediately onto the far shoulder of the road. I lept on top of him and held him down. The deer was very interested in me not holding him down, and if not for the gunshot wound to his neck, and most of his blood pouring out, I probably would not have succeeded. The truck passed and I grabbed an antler and dragged him back to my side of the road. He kicked and gasped while I looked for my rifle. Once the rifle was found the struggle was ended.

Two or so minutes later, my brother in law pulled up to me on the shoulder, looked me over, and asked, “Is that your blood?”

Over the next few days. I would miss three shots on two more deer (Lucky for me my wife doesn’t drop her guns, and let me borrow hers to close out the season). Post hunting evaluation shows the scope rings did not handle the roughly six aerial feet traversed by rifle. Shift in point of impact was about 20” at 100 yards. Scope is fine. New rings, the ones I should have bought the first time, have been ordered.

Eight or so months ago, when talking with my friend Rueben, he cautiously scoffed at the notion of saving money on a build. I think we both understood it as a dumb decision, but it was that one thing that made me able to tell my wife, “Look how much I saved!”
I never tell my wife that I'm building a new rifle. They just magically appear. I'm always working on something so she has no idea if it's mine or someone else's. She asked me once how many rifles I had, my answer was and still is. "A lot". I tell her that I save a bunch because I buy my stuff wholesale.
 
Great story. My hunting buddy and I had a similar experience once. We were hunting one evening from tree stands set up in a hedge row of trees about 50 yards wide between two crop fields in east NC. One field had soy beans and the other had cotton in it. These fields were huge. Out in the middle of the cotton field was a little foot ball shaped island of trees and swampy ground. My hunting buddy that lived in the area had seen a nice buck moving around in this patch of trees a few days before I arrived for my 3 weeks of hunting with him. We placed stands in the hedge row which ran over a mile long about a half mile from each other. He in one and me in the other so we could cover the whole area between us. We had nice shooting rest built on the stands so we could get steady to shoot long range. About an hour before dark we see all kinds of deer movement in that foot ball patch of woods. A buck is chasing does. He comes out to the edge of the cotton field but is about 800 yards from me and walking away in the direction of my hunting buddy. The buck is strutting as he walks and all I can see is from his neck up with his head bobbing up and down from the angle of the land and over the cotton. When he gets to where he is right at 500 yards from my buddy as I watch through my field glasses I see the buck drop like a rock and hear POP the BOOM. My buddy shot him. Then I see about 5 or 6 doe come running out of that patch of woods toward my end of the field. Since I need meat when one stops right at 400 yards from me broad side I shoot it and down it goes. By the time my buddy got to my stand and we walked to his truck that was hidden about 100 yards from my stand in the hedgerow it was close to getting dark. We hurried to get the little pull cart we hauled deer in out of the truck and because it was a bit warmer than I thought it would be I took off the army camo field jacket I had on and put on a long sleeve shirt that was my buddies that was laying in the truck. We also left our rifles in the truck because we though there would be no need of them and did not want to have to pack them a half mile across that cotton field. When we got to were my deer was laying I started to load her up on the cart while my buddy walked down to where his deer was but it was not there. Now my this time you could only see a thin line of light in the western sky. When I was in such a hurry I forgot that I had left my flashlight in the pocket of the jacket I left in the truck. My buddy had his light and started looking for a blood trail when all of a sudden I hear something trashing in the cotton field and when I look I can see in that thin line of light in the west a antler rise up and down. I call to my hunting buddy, "your deer is over here and he AIN"T DEAD". With my buddy in front of me we walk over to where the buck is and because the bullet had went high because my buddy though the deer was about 600 in stead of 500 yards away it had cut the spine and immobilized the back end but the front legs and head were very active. The buck up on his front legs with head swinging tried to get my buddy. He jumped back almost knocking me down. The deer fell but was trying to get up again. We backed off and let him settle down some. My buddy said give me your knife. I always carry a folding hunting knife but guess where it was. Yep, in the truck with my flash light. We compare our regular pocket knives which only have about 2 1/2 to 3 inch blades. My buddies is sharper than mine so we make our plans. Now I was only in my early 40s and in good shape but my buddy was in his early 60s. I tell him that we would come from behind the deer and he was to pin his left antler to the ground and I would jump down and straddle the deer and pin his front legs with my right leg and grab his right antler with my left hand and bulldog his head around and cut his throat. So we proceeded to do this. When I cut the deer throat it coughed and blood flew all over me from my belly to the top of my head but we got the job done. It was a 10 point buck that was around 200 lbs. When we got to my buddies house and I got out of the truck and his wife came out and saw me she thought I had been shot because of the blood on me. It scared her to death.
 
OK, I've got to tell what my brother did. He had just gotten out of the Marines and bought a Remington 700 in 30-06. He had also broken his leg and had a full cast on it, but it was deer season and he was damned if he wasn't going to go, what with a brand new rifle and having given up hunting for Uncle Sam for those years.
Anyway, he left the house before sunrise and was on a back road about 50 miles from the house when he noticed some cows crossing the road in front of him. He stopped at the first farm that he came to and told the farmer about the cows on the road.
After the farmer had gotten his cows back into a new fenced-in pasture, he asked my brother where he was going to hunt. My brother told him that he was heading for a public hunting ground nearby. The farmer told him that he was more than welcome to hunt his property and even told him where he could park and set up.
Well, my brother parked his car, loaded his rifle and crutched his way about 100 yards down a valley with a sharp ridge running along one side. The farmer had told him that he had always seen deer in the valley or running the ridge.
My brother got situated and some minutes later, the sun came up. A few minutes of watching the woods come alive and he saw a nice buck and a doe running the ridge above him. He lined up on the buck, shot and the buck went down. But not for long. It got back up and started kinda running along the ridge in the direction it had been going. He lined up on the buck again, bang, and the buck went down again. Up it came again, but this time, there was something very wrong. It was trying to run on its front kneees. About the time my brother started swinging on the deer again, it lost its ballance and came rolling down the ridge.
My brother started crutching like mad toward where the deer was rolling to, and as luck would have it, it stopped rolling almost at his feet. He didn't want to shoot it again, soooo, you guessed it, he takes his K-Bar out, jumps on the deer (yes, I did say he had a full leg cast on), wrestles it down and slits its throat.
My brother jumps off the deer to catch his breath. About this time the farmer shows up to see what the shooting was about. Since he looked at my brother first, he was quite concerned that my brother had somehow shot himself because he was covered with blood. Once that got squared away, they went over to check out the buck. It was a big deer (200+ dressed) and was a big basket 8-pointer.
Well, they went to check where the deer had been hit. They found that one of the hind legs had been broken just above the major joint (first shot). They then found that the front legs were both broken. The downhill leg had been broken about the knee and the uphill side was hit between the knee and the shoulder.
Well, the farmer helped my brother gut the deer and got his bobcat to help load it in his car. He was home just an hour from the time shooting was legal. I had heard him drive up and met him coming in the house. I asked him if he had figured out that he couldn't hunt with a full leg cast on. When he said that he had already got his deer, I said some words that I can't type here, but to the effect that he was full of something. He had to show me the deer in the trunk of the car before I believed him.
Now let me pause here and remind everybody that my brother had just gotten out of the Marines, where "Every Marine is, first and foremost, a rifleman". He had qualified as expert! He took two shots and never hit the body of the deer!! And a wall-mounter to boot! Life is NOT fair!!! (Or am I just a jealous little brother yet?!) :rolleyes:
PS - that was not the last deer that he jumped on and wrestled down either...he did it once more, this time without a broken leg, and this time with my nephews as witnesses
PPS - And the one basket-rack buck that I shot in my life? I hit it broadside at 40 yards, right in the boiler room, with an M-1 carbine, but instead of going flop, it took off running at full speed, hit a tree and dropped dead. When I walked up to it, I found that half the rack had broken off on impact with the tree!!! No wall-mounter for me! :(:(
 
Last edited:
Hmm...me thinks the sight in of a dropped rifle should be checked before hunting with it again no matter the quality of the scope rings involved. Your quarry deserves your best shot at a clean kill.
^^^ Agree! Yea I don't think there was a story here I would brag( or tell anybody) about! Ummm... Hmmm... I help teach hunters ed. We teach about clean and ethical hunts. Respect for game and hunting priveleges. None of these stories are about that. You guys are not helping the "cause". By that I mean gun rights or hunting in general. If you can't take the time to take a good shot DON'T!!! Giving real sportsmen a bad name IMO! I would really like to see what was behind this buck!??? Do you have any idea where bullet would have gone if you had missed? I admit I dont know all the facts here, but I question the shot, let alone the obvious " Bad" shot you administered. You make it obvious in you post he must have been fairly close to road( legally close????) When you shot were you legal???? Wow. Again I admit I don't know all the fact, but doesnt pass the smell test.
 
ND shooter...LIGHTEN UP! People make mistakes all the time, whether it's hunting or life in general. Things just go sideways at times and there's not much you can do about it, being a human being. Remember the phrase "To err is human..."?
I dare you to say that you have never made a mistake in your life and I'll tell you that your statement wouldn't pass the smell test without hesitation. I also would never do such a thing as it is tactless, especially on a public forum like this.
Look at it this way; we are relating these stories because they are humerous, no-one was hurt, the deer involved were harvested (if memory serves me) and not lost, and other people may learn something from our stories.
I would also like to point out that, in my post, both my brother and I were shooting into the side of a ridge, not at a silhouetted outline at the top of the ridge. There was nothing unsafe or unethical about what happened.
I could say that my using the M-1 carbine was a poor choice for hunting deer because it is marginal at best, but there would probably be a storm of posts that say that other people have used them with no problems.
I'm not posting this to start an arguement. If you really wanted to, you could probably pick apart every post on this forum for one reason or another, but what would be the point?? It's nice that you are an instructor and all, but sometimes you just have to shrug your shoulders and let it go or you'll rile everybody up and give yourself an ulcer.
 
The OP’s story reminded me of light hearted hunting tales that were on the back pages of old hunting magazines. I felt like I was right there with him. I enjoyed it.

Not checking the scope after the incident was a no no, but I’m not going to berate the guy about it. At the end of the day, he learned that lesson too. Bet it never happens again.

It’s sad that the tendency is to chastise others and place yourself on a higher pedestal as if you are infallible. Human nature I suppose.
 
Oh my. Funny and glad it worked out.

There's a large shoulder area and behind it to shoot. Shoot there. Whole lot better than that tight shot to hit the spine in the neck or to make that perfect head shot. One thing you did make was a memory.
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
167,267
Messages
2,229,192
Members
80,300
Latest member
SuaSpontae
Back
Top