• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

ATHLON review thanks to Doug at Cameraland

I’ll be honest I wasn't looking forward to reviewing Athlon optics. I’m an optics snob and all my rifles sport Vortex Razors, AMG, Nightforce NSX, Swarovski and Zeiss. I just believe you get what you pay for. Doug asked me to review two Athlon scopes for him. (Argos 6-24x50, Talos 4-14x44) Last weekend I mounted both of these up to my 6MMBR. This is my most proven rifle. Over the summer I shot a 5 shot group at 600 yards that was 1.5 inches. Yeah I don’t believe it myself. Gotta love Bartlein barrels!!! For testing I purchased several Boxtobenchprecision targets. This allow for tracking tests on scopes as well as load development. You have the ability to run a scope up 7.5 mils.

First off, I’m a huge fan of first focal plane optics. I was in a rush and never bore sighted either of these scopes. Each scope took only 3 shots to get zeroed. (Nightforce rings help, use good rings!!) Nothing like having the turrets match the reticle. I started off at 100 yards to test the tracking first. I ran both scopes up to match the spots of the targets. First was 1.5 mils and the last was 7.5 mils. For a total of 5 points of impact. Once I reached 7.5 mils and cranked them back down to my initial zero. To my surprise it worked. Next I conducted a box test with the same results. Clarity means nothing if a scope won't track. With my tracking concerns out of the way I moved on to the features. The turrets are very positive and have a nice audible sound. The parallax and power rings are very tight but I imagine they will loosen over time. One thing about the parallax that I really like is that they focus down to 10 yards. I shoot a lot of small bore and air rifle. Most scopes can’t focus close and its very limiting. At work we have a 23 yard range. It makes shooting with most scopes tough. My career is as firearms examiner for a major city. At my local range we can shoot out to 200 yards. I was able to decern 6mm bullet holes at 100 and 200 yards with the 24x Argos. With the Talos being 14x it wasn't possible past 100 yards. The Mil reticle is perfect its not overly busy. So many scopes have too much going on and you get lost. Both optics have lit reticles but aren't bright enough for day time use. Not a issue but just like to state that fact. With each scope I shot approx 50 rounds from 100 to 200 yards.

I don't want to get into comparing these scopes to others on the market or get into resolution charts ect. For the price your getting the best bang for your buck. I don't know of any scopes in this price range with all these features. Every company has to start from somewhere. I truly believe we will be seeing a lot more from them in the near future. I remember when Vortex was new to the market just look at them now. Over the next few months Ill get more time behind them to get more input. My next range trip will be my other club that I can shoot out to 700 yards. I plan on really putting them though the paces there. No drop test like the other guys on the forums. They are too subjective and I love my rifles too much to hurt them. I do all my own paint work so it would kill me. As many of you guys know Doug and the guys over at Cameraland are stand up guys. I've known Doug for maybe 18 years now. He keeps bringing excellent pricing and new products for us. I think this is a great addition to his inventory. Having his store so close to my house is good and bad. I walked in a few times to say hi and walked out with new toys. Last purchase was the Lecia Geovid deal he got us. I need to do some more overtime to make up for my Optics addiction.


Testing Procedure

Before I conducted my test I confirmed the scope was mounted level to the rifle and also made sure the rings are perfectly aligned using a 30mm scope lapping bar. Next the target was leveled so I knew that the scopes would tract perfectly level as well. Too many guys overlook small steps like this. Once everything was good I torqued the scope ring capped and crossbolts. I used a Nightforce base and 30mm rings. So to test the scopes I started with a 100 yards zero. Using Box To Bench Precision targets I cranked the scopes up to various MILS. (1.5,3, 4.5, 6, 7.5) and took shots at each spot. The tracking worked perfect. Next I went down 7.5 MILS to my 100 yard zero. Next I conducted a box test on an 18 inch square. The final outcome was shots placed perfectly in the original point of aim. For an impact test I dropped the butt of the rifle on the concrete 6x from a height of 6 inches. Same results no POI shift. Im not beating on my rifle or the optic beyond that like guys did for the Tract optic test. Like I stated earlier for its price Athlon makes some great budget scopes. Today Im getting a Benjamin Maunder to mount it to. Ill do some small game hunting with it and get some further testing done. Patiently awaiting FED EX now!!!!

PROS: Loaded with features
Price
Warranty
They work!

CONS: Honestly my only complaint is the stiff power and parallax rings


PS: keep in mind the winds were brutal the day of testing. 20-25 mph so some shots were slightly off. The small group target was done later when the winds died down.


78BahKc.jpg

06tnq9J.jpg

NUC6CJf.jpg

mUqFi04.jpg

C78xEIt.jpg

QlIkxPR.jpg

kcSC7eW.jpg


Last edited by bhoges; 5 minutes ago.
 
I really like the Athlon Cronus 4.5-29x56 and Midas BTR 4.5-27x50 scopes that I have. The glass is nice, and so far, the tracking has been very good.
I shot out to a mile last weekend with the Cronus and my IOR Valdada Recon 4-28x50 scopes, and the Cronus wasn't too far behind the IOR scope through my eyes.
 
Thanks for the review bhoges. Much appreciated !

Now I'm gonna see what they cost and decide if it's worth my $ or to spend a bit more and get something else.
 
I took a leap of faith on the Helos. I too am a scope snob. My evaluation is the same. It's a lot of scope for the money, but leaves a lot to desire as well.

I would really like to see a review of their Cronus and how it stacks up to the bevy of 56mm, FFP scopes that cost over $1000 more (or double).

That one I did not have the cajones to take a leap of faith on, and perhaps paid a lot more to be certain I was getting what I wanted.





5
1 Review
 
I bought the Talos to go on my Weatherby TRR, 6.5 CM. I haven't got to shoot the rifle/scope combo yet but very impressed with the quality of the glass looking across the field in front of my house. Seems like a good value for $300 and tax.
 
My favorite scopes are Leupold & Weaver. I have 3 Weaver 6-20X40 Grand Slam scopes and I can see .22 bullet holes at 300 (yes 300) yards with both. I have a Leupold 6.5-20X50 VXIII and a Leu 6.5-20X40 VX3, both can spot .22 bullet holes at 300 but the Leupolds do it better in bad light. My 2 Leupold 4.5-14X40 VXIII scopes can spot .22 holes easily at 200 and barely at 300 only with good light. My Weaver 4.5-14X40 GS is slightly inferior to the Leupolds. My SWFA 12X42 MOA Quad can spot .30 holes at 200 but not much more. The best hole spotter of the bunch is my Weaver T24, 24X40. As far as adjustment go the T24 & SWFA 12X42 are the best and I get almost what I want per click. All scopes have or have available sun shades, these are often needed when shooting rodents in the late afternoon. The best buy was the SWFA. I would regard these to be mid value range scopes and I have seen better at almost 2X times the price.

I have never used an Athlon scope but would welcome the chance to objectively check one out. Something must be wrong if 6mm holes are unable to be seen beyond 100 yards with a 14X. My scopes show much use, the oldest one a 17 YO Weaver 6-20X40 GS that gives great service. The only problem I had was with a newer W 6-20X40 GS with 1/8 adjustments because I was unable to center the reticle on a Ruger 77 using Ruger rings - it shot 6 inches low at 100 when cranked up to max elevation. The solution was to mount that scope on a FN Mauser using Burris Signature Zee rings and now it is good for 500 yards minimum.

Resolution is important, especially when shooting tiny brown-gray rodents at extended ranges. I like to check out resolution by viewing (no rifle attached) news print. I am on old guy and when possible I get somebody younger with much better eyes to tell me what a great scope it is. Old eyes can appreciate good glass. A trip to the optics store with its $1700 - $2000 scopes is an eye opener.
 
Just to be fair here, that Talos he couldn't see 6mm holes past 100 yards with has map pricing of $299. For that you get an FFP scope with an Illuminated Reticle. The same model scope in SFP, without the illuminated reticle has map pricing of $150, same glass. Just saying that model is built around features, not glass quality.

I have no use for the lower models with high magnification, doesn't make sense to me, but I wouldnt expect much at 14x from $150 glass.
 
I recently found my self short a couple of optics and took steps to correct the issue. Fedex delivered a new Vortex Razor GII 4.5-27 for a needy bolt gun and a Vortex Strike Eagle 1-8 for the latest 6.5 Grendel find. Still, after losing its optic to a CZ455, the 223AI bolt gun was still in need. The Athlon Argos 6-24 mil/mil with illuminated reticle was in stock at Cabela's and the price fit in my Cabela Bucks budget (after the expense of two new Vortex) so it was time to give it a go. The Argos arrived Monday. My first impression, before I opened the box, was that there was something heavy in there. I think this scope is a bit heavier than others of similar features but not really an issue. All the turrets work smoothly and clicks are tactile and audible. The illuminated reticle was clear and well laid out (it's the "Christmas-tree" version) and the power ring was smooth as well. I installed the scope yesterday but had no chance to go outside and really check out the glass. Maybe tomorrow I'll get to the range. There is much more to consider in a riflescope than clarity (although clarity is the one thing most of have an opinion on). Internal materials and construction are, especially for a tactical turret scope, ultimately more important. Just how many times can you "work those knobs" so to speak and the adjustments stay precise? Only time will tell and I plan on finding out.
EDIT:
I did find some plastic discs with a center hole packed with the scope. Nothing in the literature explained them but it appeared they were for some type zero-stop arrangement. I called Athlon and they quickly answered. The guy was nice and told me they were indeed for zero stop set and were so new that the manual had no info on them yet. I am a big fan of zero-stop so looking forward to seeing how these work.
 
I would cheerfully give up the illuminated reticle, side focus, FFP and even variable power for resolution but not reliability and durability. I like to see bullet holes and small indistinct long range targets.
 
I have the Athlon Cronus BTR and it is amazing! Clarity on par with my other high end optics and fit and finish are really really good. The adjustment knobs are a little mushy for my taste but this is a small hindrance and they allow for easy, by feel adjustments. I was hesitant to try the next models down but they continue to get great reviews.
 
I have the Athlon Cronus BTR and it is amazing! Clarity on par with my other high end optics and fit and finish are really really good. The adjustment knobs are a little mushy for my taste but this is a small hindrance and they allow for easy, by feel adjustments. I was hesitant to try the next models down but they continue to get great reviews.

The grease that Athlon uses on the turret's is what makes the knobs feel mushy. Clean it off,and use a thinner grease on the o-rings.
Then the turret feel will be a lot better,crisp & precise!
 
  • Like
Reactions: MSS
The grease that Athlon uses on the turret's is what makes the knobs feel mushy. Clean it off,and use a thinner grease on the o-rings.
Then the turret feel will be a lot better,crisp & precise!

Will do. Thank you. Any recs on the grease? I have some white lithium but it’s pretty thick.
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
165,565
Messages
2,198,512
Members
78,984
Latest member
Deon
Back
Top