• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

Another Dasher fireforming question

I didn't think y'all have seen enough of these questions yet :)

I Just changed over from a 6br to a Dasher and shot it yesterday for the first time. I'm jamming 105 Hybrids in New Lapua Blue box with a .266 bushing and started testing ff loads with 30.5grs of RL-15. I'm very happy with the groups from this load, but I am seeing a ring on the shoulder that corresponds to the original neck shoulder junction. Is this normal for a first firing? The load seems mild and the chronograph showed a 2838, 2835 before it started throwing error messages. I would like to shoot this load in a match on Sunday but I'm hestitant about wasting the round count if the brass should be formed better on a first firing.

I let my wife shoot the first group and she had a hummer going until I stopped her to fiddle with aligning the chronograph after number 4. I think I'm going to be pretty happy with this barrel.
 

Attachments

  • First Dasher group Bartlein compressed.jpg
    First Dasher group Bartlein compressed.jpg
    53.4 KB · Views: 78
Maybe just me but the first once fired stuff shoots really well. Don't think the shiny you mentioned is a problem...just a reforming area brightness it sounds like.....others may have more input.
Sounds like you're having fun tho
 
22BRGUY said:
Maybe just me but the first once fired stuff shoots really well. Don't think the shiny you mentioned is a problem...just a reforming area brightness it sounds like.....others may have more input.
Sounds like you're having fun tho

Thanks for the confirmation. I figured it was not too much of a problem but figured I would check with others who have already been down this road. I can't believe this ff load shoots this well. I'm getting some inconsistent shoulder blows so I probably need to up the charge a bit, but darn it's hard to walk away from something this promising. I just went out at lunch with the wind whipping through a depression in the middle of my range and shot two groups with that same load. The bottom target started with a fresh clean barrel and some kroil still in the bore. I wish I could say it caused that low straggler, but I wasn't paying enough attention. The other 4 are .150"ish. The top group is under .3".
 

Attachments

  • Dasher Shoulders 03052013 compressed.jpg
    Dasher Shoulders 03052013 compressed.jpg
    53.9 KB · Views: 210
  • Dasher 03052013 compressed.jpg
    Dasher 03052013 compressed.jpg
    60.7 KB · Views: 137
They aren't completely formed, the neck is short. The ring on the shoulder will leave but the one on the body may stay. You are way low on the load,what is your free bore? PM me and i'll set you up on a load.......... jim
 
Just an update in case another soul wanders on this post in search of answers.

I have recieved a lot of excellent advise from forum members through a great phone call and several PM's from members with a lot of Dasher experience. What I have learned so far is that even though my first jam and shoot fireforming load produce groups that were acceptable for me to shoot in a local F class match, I was making brass that would be perpetually short and have widely variable volumes for the second firing. (Thanks dmoran and johara1) In short, I would add to my barrel's round count by as many cases as I wanted to form with rounds that would probably not perform as well as the first firing because of the now variable case volumes.

Aside from the inconsistent shoulder definition, my main fireforming problem has been the overall blow length. My first two sessions with Jam method and false shoulder method resulted in an average case length that averaged in the neighborhood of 1.532". Surprisingly both methods have very similar overall lengths despite the marked difference in case definition and the switch from RL-15 to a stiffer charge of Varget. (recommended by both Johara1 and Killshot)

What I think I have learned so far...
1- The Dasher just wants to shoot. Through the first 40 rounds of fire forming this round has agg'd .355". If this was a straight 6BR I would not be all that impressed, but for fireforming loads this kind of wows me.
2- Use a fairly stiff load to ensure that you get uniform results. If not, you will learn nothing from the second firing.
3- By the luck of actually loading the 1st case I used to set up the false shoulder die which had the false sholder set back a few thousandths from all of the others and observing that its formed length is actually .006" longer than any of the others, I feel that setting the shoulder up for an extremely hard bolt close, like I did, actually impedes the neck forming process. My reasoning is that both methods I tried used the same tight bushing and the bullets jammed .020" into the lands. I had a lighter powder charge for the jam and shoot session which could account for the similarities in blow lengths between the two methods, however the only variable that changed in the second session was the set back on the false shoulder on one round , and I got very repeatable results with 19 of the 20 rounds fired. Granted, one round could be an anomaly, but the difference was drastic and like the heading says, this is what I "think" I have learned.

Unconfirmed theories?...
Regardless of actual pressure does a fuller case of powder form better? I have no actual data other than feel and looking at the usual pressure signs, but reading about people filling cases with cream of wheat, the empirical observations of Killshot between rl-15 and varget, and my VERY limited testing, I'm leaning towards a yes answer. Just food for thought.

What is next?...
On the advise of dmoran and johara1 I need to get the blow length right the first time because once they are short, they will always be short.

What I did tonight was remove the firing pin assembly from the bolt, ( I have no ejector, but I would have removed it if it was present) and set the false shoulder up so that I could lightly feel the tension when closing the bolt but not have the 10+ lbs of force required to chamber that I had on the second session. I am hopefull that this new setup will allow me to start seeing some control over blow length based on the powder charge.

Other than figuring out the blow length, I think I have it wired and can't wait to start actually working up loads.

Jeff
 
Jeff,
Nice follow up post, those same to guy's helped me a lot also when I was starting out with the 6brx, great knowledge there for sure.
Wayne.
 
Jeff, very good post. Jim got me setup as well and can't thank him enough with all of his help of forming and loading. I wish i would have tried pulling back a little on the false shoulder, seems like i was loosing to much neck tension with half neck on false shoulder and firing pin was moving my bullet, (I think) and getting short brass on some. I just got though doing 300 outta the box with a light aneal on the shoulder and neck with .030 jam with the varget powder. My last 100 where all in the 1.552-1.555 range, .002 from full headspace on cases. As Jim always said good clean chamber. I was doing ten, let cool and swab chamber with carb cleaner and go ten more. I didn't even now what the word blow length meant a year ago, but i guess ya learn as you go, got a lot of brass in the 1.540 length, previous fire forming. I know if there was a hour meter on this sight it might scare me on how much time i spend on here learning from all the great guys willing to help out. Thanks to everyone. Bill
 
So.....if I'm simply loading and firing to fire form....am I getting less performance from the gun?

My cases come out quite nice, the regular 6br load doesn't shoot very well but even once fired brass will then shoot into the .1s.

It seems like things work well. Should I be doing something different? I suppose measuring case lengths would be a good place to start.
 
boiler_house7 said:
Jeff, very good post. Jim got me setup as well and can't thank him enough with all of his help of forming and loading. I wish i would have tried pulling back a little on the false shoulder, seems like i was loosing to much neck tension with half neck on false shoulder and firing pin was moving my bullet, (I think) and getting short brass on some. I just got though doing 300 outta the box with a light aneal on the shoulder and neck with .030 jam with the varget powder. My last 100 where all in the 1.552-1.555 range, .002 from full headspace on cases. As Jim always said good clean chamber. I was doing ten, let cool and swab chamber with carb cleaner and go ten more. I didn't even now what the word blow length meant a year ago, but i guess ya learn as you go, got a lot of brass in the 1.540 length, previous fire forming. I know if there was a hour meter on this sight it might scare me on how much time i spend on here learning from all the great guys willing to help out. Thanks to everyone. Bill

Bill,
There is a hour meter on here,...you have spent 3 days, 23 hours and 39 minutes. of your valuable time on this site, not nearly as much time I have wasted or spent depending on how you look at it,...78 days, 9 hours and 50 minutes. of course you have been on here since 2007 I have only been a member of this site since 2010 I guess I should go back to watching t.v or shooting at night ;D
Wayne.
 
Well today was the definition of disappointment!

My theory about the super hard bolt close is complete bunk. Neither adjusting the bolt close, increasing the Powder charge, nor cleaning the chamber with the non- chlorinated brake cleaner had any effect on the case length. I'm still blowing in the range of 1.532-1.534. The longest case was 1.538". The second fired cases also measure in the same range.

In addition to this dissapointing news my agg for the day was .426" and this included firing formed Dasher brass for the first time. The two groups with the Dasher brass measured. .380 and .391 which are both larger than the entire .355" aggregate this barrel had while fireforming prior to today. I think the difference is that the seating depth for all rounds today was adjusted to just touching instead of the hard jam I have used up until this point.

To top the morning off I had a group going with 31.6grains of Varget in new Lapua cases going into .040" which would have beat my personal best of .069" by a substantial margin. Other than a bit of wind the weather was perfect and I don't think I have ever had a clearer sight picture. Anyway, 4 rounds into it the wind picks up and the flags are blowing at 90 degrees. Instead of just shooting through it, the big dummy decides to wait it out. Smart move! Shot number 5 makes it own party somewhere else on the paper and blows the group up to .458. :) At least I found a load that I can shoot in the match tomorrow. The ES was the best of all the loads I tried at 16.09 and the velocity averaged 2918fps. Not bad for a fireforming load.

As far as growing the case length... I'm not sure what I will try next. I'll let y'all know if I figure it out.
 

Attachments

  • Picture 10.jpg
    Picture 10.jpg
    59.3 KB · Views: 78
I've been pondering the short case issue and I keep coming back to the clean chamber issue. I seems counter intuitive that a super clean chamber will help the case blow longer. I've seen other posts in the archives where people recommend sizing wax or lube on the cases. I'm sure some you have experimented with both and I was hoping you could share your findings. Is the clean chamber just to prevent stretching the web?

The one other issue I'm thinking about is that I did not polish the shoulder/neck junction at all after I cut the chamber and I'm wondering if a slight radius there might help the brass flow into the neck a bit easier.

On a side note, I ended up shooting a match on Sunday using the short once fired for 2 x 20 rnd matches and unfired for the last 20. Both batches shot fairly well (596-44x), but the once fired was definitely more consistent at range than the unfired even though the unfired grouped slightly better at 100. The carbon ring after 66 rounds is pretty wide so I definitely need to get this short case issue sorted out.
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
166,254
Messages
2,214,815
Members
79,495
Latest member
panam
Back
Top