Which would say has the absolute long range accuracy advantage, heavy BMG Imp going over 3k, or 416 heavies? The proportions remind of two cases relative to each other - Rsaum and .338 LM, that actually perform pretty similarly at 1,000 even though the bigger one seems to have to try much harder.
- That's a very good question davidjoe, - And I realize that a lot of folks are of the mindset that the bigger the cartridge is, then the potential for accuracy is diminished to some degree. - I've just recently started working with the 416 Barrett and am impressed and I still have a lot of testing that I want to do with different projectiles.
- Lee Rasmussen (FCSA world record holder who shot a 1.9557" five shot group at 1000 yards) told me, accuracy is just that "accuracy" and what goes into creating the ammunition and the rifle are all every bit as important in the 50 caliber world as it is in the smaller BR caliber world. - Reloading components for all calibers have come a long ways over the last 5-10 years IMO for not just "regular" BR type calibers but the larger calibers as well. - In the earlier days G.I. brass was shot in the 50's and IMI or TMZ was the preferred brass to get ahold of. - Well, along comes RUAG/RWS and Lapua and produces brass for the 50 cal. - There's a big step up in quality & consistency in brass that is available.
- Another "improvement" that I feel that could help the larger calibers is some honest to goodness true match-grade copper jacketed lead core bullets made to the exacting tolerances that the smaller Bench rest projectiles are made to. - How many 6BRA or Dasher shooters do we hear of shooting monolithic solids & winning anything ??? - None, last time I checked. - I believe there are a whole set of "inherent" issues with shooting lathe turned monolithic solids and it has to do with the barrels & chambers we shoot them in. - The bullets are turned to quite precise dimensions but some barrels and throat / lead configurations seem to not tolerate these bullets well sometimes from an accuracy standpoint, regardless if the bullets are bore-riders, seal-tight band, bronze, copper, full-bore diameter or what-have we.
- I believe that greater accuracy could be achieved if "true" BR quality & tolerance bullets of lead core & precision copper jackets could be brought to the table for the big calibers. - One or two smaller companies have tried to mfgr bullets that are lead core & copper jacketed and their tolerances IMO were not as good as the 750 gr. Hornady A-Max. - Their bullets were purchased, tried & didn't cut the mustard from a "BR Accuracy" stand point or everyone who shoots FCSA competition would be using them, plain & simple.
- I started shooting the 50 in 2009 and do not claim to be "the 50 guru" as there are some guys who've been at it since the 80's when Skip Talbot & the founding members started the FCSA & shooting the 50 for accuracy at paper targets. - Another reality is demand & supply, No one builds components if they can't make money doing it, hence there needs to be demand & enough of it to support the front-end product development & testing to get it to the market place and have a product that is successful & still enough demand to where it can survive. - Who's going to turn out bullets at 10 dollars a piece and hope that it will survive a limited market ? - J4 jacket company isn't just going to produce a few hundred very precise jackets so an experimenter who spent a big pile of cash already on a custom set of precision bullet making dies can "tinker" & test the water in 50 cal. - Jackets would need to be drawn to be very concentric & have 0.0003 or less wall thickness variation without fail, as is standard for custom jacketed bullets for the project to even have a chance at being the tolerances that are met in todays custom bullet making process by the men who do it today. (Bart's, BIB's, Berger, JLK, Vapor-Trail, etc., and several others)
- The right barrel chambered & throated correctly for monolithic solid bullets can produce some very good accuracy, I saw it in Raton, NM in 2011 and in matches afterwards. 2-3 inch groups even though only 5 shots at 1000 yards by a big 50 is obtainable, the records show this, consistency is where things have room for improvement. And I don't care how big folks think that bullet is, the wind still has an impact on it.
- Also, there's not as many shooters who pursue large caliber accuracy for obvious reasons, costs being a big one so progress hasn't abounded to the degree that it has in the regular SR & LR BR communities. - I enjoy trying to get what I can out of a big caliber rifle, that's why I do it. - Also, I've learned along the way & most of it has been thanks to the "regular" Bench-rest community and also why I've opted to join their ranks.
- Ron -