How is it common? Did you check your prints?
284 Shehane "Clicker" Problem
- Thread starter One Eye Pete
- Start date
One Eye Pete
Gold $$ Contributor
I solved my Shehane clicker problem a while back.
Solution:
Redding small based 284 Win Die. bored out top down to approx 0.2" from bottom of die. (see pictures) If I can do it in my old Grizzly Mill than anyone with even the least amount of machining skill should be able to do it. (I'm a retired mechanical engineer with severely challenged machining skills, college only teaches theory, machining is a skill) Carbide end mill cut it like a hot knife through butter. I realize that it probably would have been better to modify the die in a lathe but unfortunately I do not have one. Heck anyone can do excellent work if they have the right tools!!!!
Resized the "clickers with this modified small based die first.
Then I also purchased a new 284 Shehane die from Blake Barrel and Rifle. This is a fantastic die that matches my chamber really well. After resizing the bottom part of the case with the modified Redding die I used the Blake Barrel die to resize the remainder of the case.
I have both Peterson and Lapua brass for my Shehane. The reason I went through all this trouble was that the Peterson brass gave me better ES/SD numbers and better groups on target than the Lapua brass. If I had to take a guess why it would be that the Peterson brass has a more consistent case volume. However, I do not sort my brass by weight nor do I attempt to measure case volume so I cant say for sure.
OK the real reason I tried this approach is because I'm retired and it gave me something to do. Although an alternate solution would have been to open up the chamber I really didn't want to play around with the barrel and take a chance on screwing it up. The Redding small base die cost me less than $50.0 the barrel including chambering was over $750. I'm not a gambler I try to minimize my losses in case I screw up. Fortunately in this case things worked out pretty well.
Solution:
Redding small based 284 Win Die. bored out top down to approx 0.2" from bottom of die. (see pictures) If I can do it in my old Grizzly Mill than anyone with even the least amount of machining skill should be able to do it. (I'm a retired mechanical engineer with severely challenged machining skills, college only teaches theory, machining is a skill) Carbide end mill cut it like a hot knife through butter. I realize that it probably would have been better to modify the die in a lathe but unfortunately I do not have one. Heck anyone can do excellent work if they have the right tools!!!!
Resized the "clickers with this modified small based die first.
Then I also purchased a new 284 Shehane die from Blake Barrel and Rifle. This is a fantastic die that matches my chamber really well. After resizing the bottom part of the case with the modified Redding die I used the Blake Barrel die to resize the remainder of the case.
I have both Peterson and Lapua brass for my Shehane. The reason I went through all this trouble was that the Peterson brass gave me better ES/SD numbers and better groups on target than the Lapua brass. If I had to take a guess why it would be that the Peterson brass has a more consistent case volume. However, I do not sort my brass by weight nor do I attempt to measure case volume so I cant say for sure.
OK the real reason I tried this approach is because I'm retired and it gave me something to do. Although an alternate solution would have been to open up the chamber I really didn't want to play around with the barrel and take a chance on screwing it up. The Redding small base die cost me less than $50.0 the barrel including chambering was over $750. I'm not a gambler I try to minimize my losses in case I screw up. Fortunately in this case things worked out pretty well.
Attachments
F-CLassInfo
Banned
That’s funny. I don’t have clicker problems and use Peterson in my shehane.
Like has been said. It’s not a brass issue. It’s a mismatch between chamber and brass.
Upgrades & Donations
This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.
Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.
You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.
To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.
Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.
You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.
To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.