• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

How Does Your Compensated .22 Firearm Perform?

SGW Gunsmith

"Accipere non casus-Virga Bis"
I've seen quite an array of compensators attached to .22 rimfire barrels over the years. Some are made with huge gaping ports at the top of the "muzzle brake", and some have slots or ports all around the periphery of the compensator. Some are called comps and some are called brakes, take your pick, but the outcome desired is pretty much the same. To reduce muzzle flip and get to "sequential target acquisition" much quicker. Then, there are those folks who will declare that there isn't enough 'force' behind a .22 Long Rifle bullet to provide any benefit in reducing muzzle flip. I don't agree:
sHeoakS.jpg

The above is my "bowling pin shooter", it has a compensator that I made which is actually screwed on, though you will never be able to find the 'line where it meets with the muzzle'. The ports have been found to work very well when the diameter chosen is used, along with the position and number of ports done.
My analogy to show how these ports work is to compare the pressure being created sorta like a garden hose. Without any nozzle on the end of the hose, water just dribbles out, same as a huge gaping slot on a .22 muzzle with expanding bullet gasses, When the hose has a nozzle affixed to the front end to regulate pressure by constricting the water to create more pressure, then, even the hose will have some slight recoil, for lack of a better term. That's what the diameter and position of the ports I chose to use come into play, like so:
2ocZTOM.jpg

I placed one wrap of painters tape to cover the above ports and then fired one CCI Mini-Mag round. The expanding and escaping gasses blew the tape off the ports.
LmlEWnu.jpg

Next, I wrapped four layers of painters tape around the brake to cover the ports and fired another CCI Mini-Mag round:
8JY03b1.jpg

The gasses easily blew away all four wraps of tape, so, next I wrapped four pieces of painters tape along with a playing card, which is a bit thicker, over the ports and fired another CCI Mini-Mag round:
ZglMksl.jpg

i1Sy4AL.jpg
he escaping gasses had no problem removing the thicker material. This proves to me, that the expanding gasses are effective in reducing, and counter-acting muzzle flip, too some degree. This will help a shooter get back on target much quicker than a shooter not using a brake with the proper design. That could be why there are differing 'classes' between uncomped and comped barrels in some shooting disciplines.
 
Last edited:
sorry, but I am among those that view compensators on 22 rimfires as looking tacticool, but of no practical value .. used to shoot two S&W k-66 (6" k-frame) 357 mag revolvers quite a bit, as well as matching 6" rimfire k-frames (two k-17 22 lr and one k-48 22 wmr) practice companions, all with identical target fat-butt grips, so muzzle flip was never something that bothered me, it's just something you learn to accommodate when rapid fire shooting DA revolvers .. and those k-17s would shoot in SA mode head to head with any target pistols I have yet seen in 50 years .. as good or better than my Ruger MKII 10" bull barrel or Ruger MKIII 6 7/8" fluted barrel .. they still do, but I don't ("got no eyes no more" for open iron targetg sights, have to run scopes or red dots on those Rugers these days, cataract Lasik pending) .. only compensator I have on a rimfire rifle is what came on my S&W TC/R 22 .. I don't take it off, because I consider it cute but irrelevant .. but it ain't no F-class benchrest rifle nohow ...to each their own, though, no offense intended, but you asked .. nice to know that somebody/somewhere still shoots "bowling pin" matches .. that used to be a 38 special thing back-in-the-day .. I know red dots are very popular for your style shooting, but you might ought think about just going with fiber optic sights front and rear .. or fiber optic front with white outline/dot rear ..give it whirl sometime, if you haven't yet done so, tough to beat in sunlight for rapid target aquisition .. either that or a more open style reflex sight, instead of tubular .. best wishes and good luck
 
sorry, but I am among those that view compensators on 22 rimfires as looking tacticool, but of no practical value .. used to shoot two S&W k-66 (6" k-frame) 357 mag revolvers quite a bit, as well as matching 6" rimfire k-frames (two k-17 22 lr and one k-48 22 wmr) practice companions, all with identical target fat-butt grips, so muzzle flip was never something that bothered me, it's just something you learn to accommodate when rapid fire shooting DA revolvers .. and those k-17s would shoot in SA mode head to head with any target pistols I have yet seen in 50 years .. as good or better than my Ruger MKII 10" bull barrel or Ruger MKIII 6 7/8" fluted barrel .. they still do, but I don't ("got no eyes no more" for open iron targetg sights, have to run scopes or red dots on those Rugers these days, cataract Lasik pending) .. only compensator I have on a rimfire rifle is what came on my S&W TC/R 22 .. I don't take it off, because I consider it cute but irrelevant .. but it ain't no F-class benchrest rifle nohow ...to each their own, though, no offense intended, but you asked .. nice to know that somebody/somewhere still shoots "bowling pin" matches .. that used to be a 38 special thing back-in-the-day .. I know red dots are very popular for your style shooting, but you might ought think about just going with fiber optic sights front and rear .. or fiber optic front with white outline/dot rear ..give it whirl sometime, if you haven't yet done so, tough to beat in sunlight for rapid target aquisition .. either that or a more open style reflex sight, instead of tubular .. best wishes and good luck
Obviously, you've NEVER handled or actually fired a "properly ported" muzzle brake on a "properly" set-up pistol, with a "red-dot" sight clearly pictured (First picture) on my #1 Post. The red-dot provides much more quicker sequential target acquisition than what fiber optic pipes do, one aiming dot does it every time, and it will even work very well at a dimly lit indoor target range. Not like fiber optic pipes can, as the need ambient light to work properly.
If those ports are not doing the intended job with venting gas properly, please explain what you think it was that blew the tape off the compensator?

Maybe you haven't noticed, but the VC compensator has holes all around its periphery, so, with that type of device the holes counteract one another and gas vents out all around the compensator. How in the world could that work to vent any escaping gasses to counteract muzzle flip?

It always happens when I post concerning proper gas compensation on a Ruger semi-automatic pistol, there always seems to be those who've never owned or shot a properly set-up pistol who claim they don't think the ones like above work. Well, the North Wind didn't blow that tape and playing card off the muzzle, .22 rimfire expanding gasses did that for SURE!
 
Obviously, you've NEVER handled or actually fired a "properly ported" muzzle brake on a "properly" set-up pistol, with a "red-dot" sight clearly pictured (First picture) on my #1 Post. The red-dot provides much more quicker sequential target acquisition than what fiber optic pipes do, one aiming dot does it every time, and it will even work very well at a dimly lit indoor target range. Not like fiber optic pipes can, as the need ambient light to work properly.
If those ports are not doing the intended job with venting gas properly, please explain what you think it was that blew the tape off the compensator?

Maybe you haven't noticed, but the VC compensator has holes all around its periphery, so, with that type of device the holes counteract one another and gas vents out all around the compensator. How in the world could that work to vent any escaping gasses to counteract muzzle flip?

It always happens when I post concerning proper gas compensation on a Ruger semi-automatic pistol, there always seems to be those who've never owned or shot a properly set-up pistol who claim they don't think the ones like above work. Well, the North Wind didn't blow that tape and playing card off the muzzle, .22 rimfire expanding gasses did that for SURE!
blowing tape off that barrel extension doesn't mean squat; you asked for opinions, you got one ... but have a nice day, and good luck with your sales efforts
 
The proof is in the targets...Of which I see none.. If you post about mods without before and after pics it's kinda moot isn't it. The work does look nice though..
Oh, all right! Here are the targets, just freshly painted:

PDWRJxv.jpg
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
164,688
Messages
2,182,823
Members
78,476
Latest member
375hhfan
Back
Top