hello. I'm having a short action standard bolt face rifle built (for long range practice).
6.5x47 - want to use 140 bullets and don't think it has enough powder space
6.5 creedmor - I don't like hornady brass
260 rem- I like it but shoulder angles and short neck (bullet seats in powder space)
260 ackley- don't want to fire form (I don't think I'm ready for that)
6.5slr - I really like that but can it be just as accurate as the others listed above?
Win brass with a light neck turn, would that help? Do you know anyone that
Has one and likes / dislikes it and why?
Your other choices are 6.5 RM, 6.5x284, .264 WM. I am currently rebarreling a .264 WM to a 6.5 RM. I think the Remington Magnum has close to the ideal case volume for a 6.5 at 68 grains. Yes, still hard on barrels, but not nearly so as the .264. And the 6.5 RM case volume seems to make much better use of the powder in producing velocity. But, and it is a big BUT, only Remington made the brass and it is not being made any more. Forming it from other cases is difficult. I'm doing it just because I like the cartridge ballistics, and I have the brass. I also have another gun in .264 as well.
The 6.5x284 has slightly less case than the 6.5 RM, but is very close. Lapua makes brass for it, so no brass issues.
The .264 WM, despite having two of them, I really can't recommend. Just burns too much powder without getting the extra performance, and the barrel pays the price. It is a long action as well.
And to be realistic you will want to shoot long 140 grain bullets for long distance. When you seat them in the neck (not down into the case) in the 6.5 RM or 6.5x284 they are not going to feed in a short action. Yes, you can single feed, but getting an unfired round out is a bit of a pain then.
If you are stuck on a short action, I think the obvious choice is the 260 AI. It is even going to press the limits of a short action, so you should check that out. Your concern about the donuts in forming a 260 AI may have been founded on this older article about
260 Ackley Case Forming. I think the problem then was that Lapua was not making the 260, and the donuts were in a necked up .243 case. Lapua now makes the 260 Remington and I suspect that issue is pretty much gone. I would agree the standard 260 is a little short on case capacity at 53 grains, but I believe the AI version is not much more at 56 grains?
If you really are serious about long range, you may want to consider the 6.5x284. You can buy one
off the shelf from Savage. Just my thoughts.