Please share your loads if you have them.
I'd like to have a powder for use that is more readily available.
Thanks!
I'd like to have a powder for use that is more readily available.
Thanks!
+1 RL15 is temp sensitive but shoots well, and the 4451 is the IMR equivalent to Hodgdon's EXTREME powders; temp insensitive and burn speed close to H4350RL15 is good for 130`s and IMR4451 is good for 140`s,,IMR4350 does well in both weights in mine also,,but I have to say my favorite load is the 130 VLD and 41.5 H4350,,
One of the BEST powders for accuracy, speed and great e.s.'s is VV N550. There are 2 problems with it though: 1.) It is "fairly" temp sensitive; and 2.) It will eat your throat up like candy. But it is EXCELLENT, especially as far as accuracy and speed go.
Yes! On my second 6.5 x 47 barrel I was using 130 gr Berger VLD's. I was using 40.1grs of VVN550. I got 1400 rounds before the accuracy, almost immediately fell off. I took my rifle to my 'smith who promptly looked down the bore with his Hawkeye. He said "it looks like an excavation pit" to be quoting him! But that rifle shot those VLD's at 2970 with excellent accuracy>>>for 1400 rounds! LOL!!Have you confirmed the "eat your throat up like candy" observation via bore scope and/or throat OAL measurements?
Jack
I've never had temp issues with RL15, where did your problem develop?+1 RL15 is temp sensitive but shoots well, and the 4451 is the IMR equivalent to Hodgdon's EXTREME powders; temp insensitive and burn speed close to H4350
Yes! On my second 6.5 x 47 barrel I was using 130 gr Berger VLD's. I was using 40.1grs of VVN550. I got 1400 rounds before the accuracy, almost immediately fell off. I took my rifle to my 'smith who promptly looked down the bore with his Hawkeye. He said "it looks like an excavation pit" to be quoting him! But that rifle shot those VLD's at 2970 with excellent accuracy>>>for 1400 rounds! LOL!!
I am also of the opinion that one barrel may not wear at the same rate as another. I had a 6mmBR that went for about 3000 or so rounds before it gave up the ghost. I was running several powders over a couple years in that rifle, including VV N540 which is very hot, yet I did not experience rapid throat wear. Remember, I am in Texas and it gets MIGHTY hot here in the summer. Couple that with long shot strings and you have the recipe for erosion..Thanks for the reply.
I have some time with N550 and the 6.5x47, and never experienced it like you stated...and I am saying this by ME regularly seeing (via bore scope), and me regularly physically measuring, the effects on the throat OAL.This was for a whole season and separate barrel.
I have also shot a season with H4350 and another with Varget, with different Kreiger barrels. I agree with you that of the 3 powders (same bullet weight in each, and many other similar components) the N550 did the most erosion, followed by Varget, and the least amount was with H4350. However, I surely wouldn't call it "eating the throat up like candy." The N550 gave me the best accuracy, and more f/s than the other two powders, and I was happy to accept that over the 20% (MY ESTIMATE) faster barrel wear.
Maybe we are not comparing apples-to-apples. I shoot in the East and don't have the temps you have. You may shoot many more rounds (and faster) than I do at matches. Who knows if we use the same barrel, throat L, twist, blah,blah,blah. My intent was not to nit pick your post. I just wanted to mention that N550 is not a guaranteed way to destroy your barrel. It can work very well, and the only complaint I have is the price.
Jack
Ben, what has you experience been with RL15 temp sensitivity?I am also of the opinion that one barrel may not wear at the same rate as another. I had a 6mmBR that went for about 3000 or so rounds before it gave up the ghost. I was running several powders over a couple years in that rifle, including VV N540 which is very hot, yet I did not experience rapid throat wear. Remember, I am in Texas and it gets MIGHTY hot here in the summer. Couple that with long shot strings and you have the recipe for erosion..
It is NOT as temp insensitive as say Varget or 8208XBR but I have not found it to be particularly sensitive either. Whether or not a powder is temp sensitive or temp insensitive, if you run it at the very top of it's node, if temps swing pretty good, you will go out of your node. There is no such thing as COMPLETE temp insensitivity. I like IMR 7828 and IMR 4895 and have not found them to be particularly "sensitive" to temperatures. Just keep as W-I-D-E of a window as possible when in load development and MOST powders won't react poorly. EXAMPLE: My 6.5 x 47 will shoot just as well at 40.0grs as 40.6grs of H4350 with Berger 140 LRBT's.. I choose to use 40.4grs as it gives me a pretty wide window. When I go to Palo Alto this weekend, we shall see if my load development using this "window" will withstand a fairly large expected temp swing there! A front is passing thru and will go from cool to warm..Ben, what has you experience been with RL15 temp sensitivity?
I usually shoot in similar conditions, just parroting what I've heard about RL15 vs H4350. and of course the advertising for the IMR4451I've never had temp issues with RL15, where did your problem develop?
