• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

Chrome lined vs not

Please give me your opinions on chrome lined AR barrels vs unlined. Which, in your opinion is better and why?

Chrome is an attempt at making a barrel that cleans easier {which the Army feels is a good thing in the field} and maybe might last a little longer if shot "too much too soon", so to speak. I never really saw where the hard chrome lining accomplished either one. I have seen it flake off and the bore looks like a real mess, amazingly though it will still shoot pretty good.
The Army, in their infinite wisdom, figured out that it was not necessarily conducive to accuracy and so none of the barrels they use for match shooting {at the AMU} are chrome lined.
Personally, I never got the "trying to make it last longer" doctrine...the Army has unlimited access to our tax money, why would they care how long a barrel lasts??? Just order another batch.
Bottom line, if I was building an AR for plinking at moderate ranges I wouldn't care if it had chrome lining, but if I was in it to get the smallest groups I could I would pass on chrome lining. Someone above posted the question why so many AR builders use chrome lined barrels??? It's not that they necessarily want/need it either, its that surplus/overrun Army barrels are cheaper so they buy them. I wouldn't throw a chrome lined barrel away, but it wouldn't be my first choice in a rifle I needed to be really accurate either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BMW
Chromed lining along with providing corrosion protection, also aids in the feeding and extraction phases.

If you have an AR with the primary function of defending life by shooting at human chest sized targets, chrome lined is the way to go.

If you have a "go fast" gun, chrome lined is the way to go.

If you are just firing a round every few seconds at an X ring, whiskey bottle, golf ball, or whatever, then unlined is the way to go.

While chrome lined are technically not as accurate, you won't notice it while shooting at plates or offhand.
 
When I posted about having a bumper shop do a chrome job on a barrel, It never occurred to me that this group would not see through the metaphor. I was just making reference to the mechanical effect of a chrome lined barrel and it's less than precision accuracy potential. USGI standard M14 barrels are chrome lined. Actually they don't shoot that bad. I have tested some that are capable if 1-1¼ MOA accuracy. In the halcyon days of yesteryear, I won a couple of LEG matches with a GI M14. My buddy took the same gun to Perry and made the Presidents 100. I did have several magazines chromed at a bumper shop. They stayed a lot cleaner with just a minimum of maintenance and worked quite slick. Just to mess with folks minds, I put a Harley-Davidson parts sticker on them. ;) This board is primarily made up of bench rest and precision shooters, so I mistakenly thought along those lines and made my comment "tongue in cheek"; just knowing that folks would understand. I regret my post and will hold my tapatalking until I understand the level of sophistication of those I am talking to. My mistake.
Favor center
 
Last edited:
If you have an AR with the primary function of defending life by shooting at human chest sized targets, chrome lined is the way to go.

If you have a "go fast" gun, chrome lined is the way to go.

If you are just firing a round every few seconds at an X ring, whiskey bottle, golf ball, or whatever, then unlined is the way to go.

While chrome lined are technically not as accurate, you won't notice it while shooting at plates or offhand.

Pretty good summary right there.

For reliability and a bit more forgiveness in the maintenance (or lack thereof) department, where any "hit" counts, chrome lined isn't bad.

For the more accuracy minded, who are also more likely to treat their weapons a bit better both in and out of the field, skip the chrome.
 
Which, in your opinion is better and why?

You've received some good responses, covering both ends, and giving positives and negatives for both.

Now you need to clarify your question...

In your case and your usage, which is better for WHAT?
 
Man this is some good info! I don't have any chrome shops around me. Do you think this will work just as good as chrome shop chrome? I would really like to chrome line my AR-15 barrel
 

Attachments

  • image.jpeg
    image.jpeg
    42.6 KB · Views: 30
Wait what's a bumper shop. You mean chrome is real? I though that stuff ran out with our liquid Dino reserves back in the '70s... Cars don't even have bumpers anymore.

Kidding aside
3-gun might be a lined barrel. I might even pick one up to complete a rifle and get practice, but plan on exhanging it at a later date. Good reloading practice, and not that long ago 2MOA wasn't horrible accuracy for a plinking rifle.
 
Man this is some good info! I don't have any chrome shops around me. Do you think this will work just as good as chrome shop chrome? I would really like to chrome line my AR-15 barrel


Probably better! Might be easier just to chrome your bullets and cases though.
 
Can you get a chroming kit from Brownell's for less than fifty bucks?

Seems like if you invested, say, thirty bucks, and your rifle lasted longer...
 
Even at 50 bucks it's still worth it! Lol

If you know chrome plating, you ain't doing it at home with a $500 kit. A chrome plating shop is not capable of chroming a rifle bore. Hard Chrome needs a copper plating for the chrome to adhere to. If you do a search on Meloniting you should find the email I posted from a AMU armor of long standing. He did extensive machine tests with chrome lined and Melonited barrels. He goes over the pros and cons of all this on AR barrels.
OP, Mike Ezell has probably forgotten more about rifle related items than most people. I will leave you out of that sentence as I don't know you. Mike is very good at helping folks and would have been a valuable asset to you.
 
If you know chrome plating, you ain't doing it at home with a $500 kit. A chrome plating shop is not capable of chroming a rifle bore. Hard Chrome needs a copper plating for the chrome to adhere to. If you do a search on Meloniting you should find the email I posted from a AMU armor of long standing. He did extensive machine tests with chrome lined and Melonited barrels. He goes over the pros and cons of all this on AR barrels.
OP, Mike Ezell has probably forgotten more about rifle related items than most people. I will leave you out of that sentence as I don't know you. Mike is very good at helping folks and would have been a valuable asset to you.

Butch, thank you! But I don't deserve any praise. I should have just let this thread go and not replied further..it just rubbed me wrong. We'd all been better off and wouldn't have wasted those few minutes of our lives, reading that crap. But thank you, just the same. You know I hold you in high esteem. You've always treated me well and been a stand up person. I appreciate that and all the help you have been to me over the years.--Mike
 
If you know chrome plating, you ain't doing it at home with a $500 kit. A chrome plating shop is not capable of chroming a rifle bore. Hard Chrome needs a copper plating for the chrome to adhere to. If you do a search on Meloniting you should find the email I posted from a AMU armor of long standing. He did extensive machine tests with chrome lined and Melonited barrels. He goes over the pros and cons of all this on AR barrels.
OP, Mike Ezell has probably forgotten more about rifle related items than most people. I will leave you out of that sentence as I don't know you. Mike is very good at helping folks and would have been a valuable asset to you.
I think I'll just stick with the chrome in a can much cheaper!
 
How do you get it out of the can into the bore?
Well 1st you want to separate the upper and lower. 2nd take the bolt out of the upper assembly. 3rd hold the upper with the barrel running down hill. 4th grasp your high quality chrome in a can and raise the can into the lower opening in the upper assembly you know where the bullets usually go. 5th now aim the nozzle into the chamber push the nozzle down and start spraying. This also helps for smoother chambering and start your sweet chrome lining procces. Make sure you rotate the upper while spraying into the chamber as it runs down the barrel. This will help for an even coat down the barrel. Once the wet chrome runs out of the end of the barrel you are complete. Just wait 24 hours and you are ready for rust free and mil spec chrome moly barrel.
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
165,036
Messages
2,188,488
Members
78,645
Latest member
Kenney Elliott
Back
Top