• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

Switching to magnum primers

Well, I’m almost out of large rifle primers. If I want to keep shooting I’ll have to start using my stash of Federal 215 to use with my 180 ELDMs and 56 grains of RL 26 in my 7 Shehane. The usual answer is “reduce by 10%” but that seems like overkill to me. Is it really necessary to reduce this load by 5.6 grains just due to the different primers?
 
For what its worth, I changed from Fed 215s to std large rife Federals in my 30.06 and 300WW, 30.06 there was just about no difference with VV N550 and I think I upped the charged in my 300WM maybe 0.2gr if I remember correctly with N560 to get to my original speed again
 
I can't comment on Federals, but Wolf/Tula primers showed no difference between the standard and the mags in both my Shehane or my 6SLR.
I hope this helps,

Lloyd
 
I would be interested in seeing what the difference in speed was when switching with the same powder charge. Most on here that have a pet load will say when they run out of a powder lot or some component they will adjust the charge till the speed is the same.
 
Not necessary IMO/IME. I would test in .2gr increments starting at .6gr below current charge and test up through your current charge by .2gr. Basically you are looking for the optimum charge for that primer not necessarily dropping for overpressure concerns. I've never had a magnum primer test cause overpressure compared to my standard primer load. For the record, I do not shoot loads on the border of overpressure to begin with so there is plenty of margin for my magnum testing.
 
Well, I’m almost out of large rifle primers. If I want to keep shooting I’ll have to start using my stash of Federal 215 to use with my 180 ELDMs and 56 grains of RL 26 in my 7 Shehane. The usual answer is “reduce by 10%” but that seems like overkill to me. Is it really necessary to reduce this load by 5.6 grains just due to the different primers?
I'd drop 5% and work up. I have done a lot of velocity comparisons regarding small rifle standard versus magnum primers and found that a number of loads actually had lower velocity with the magnum primers - all being equal. I've not run such experimentation on large rifle primers - but I'd think 10% would be "excessively safe" - if there is such a thing.
 
I have experimented with .223 and .260 Rem. Like others I saw little to no velocity increases and in some instances lower
 
Thought I read somewhere the magnum primers just had a thicker cup due to the increased pressure.
 
Thought I read somewhere the magnum primers just had a thicker cup due to the increased pressure.
If true this means you have to be careful if switching from magnums to standard in high pressure cartridges, but probably gonna be fine when switching the other way.
 
I went from WLR to CCI 250 (magnums) in a 338-06. I loaded rounds .3 below to .3 above the charge I was using (IMR 4895 51.6) Can’t say I was smart in doing so but it worked out for me.
 
The CCI No.34 primer below is a magnum primer and it can increase the chamber pressure up to 2,600 psi over a standard primer.
cmnvXVR.jpg
 
I tried some CCI 450 and Russian 5.56 magnum primers in a .223 Rem load with 90 VLDs that had been worked up using Fed 205 primers. Both magnum primers gave an almost identical 30 fps increase in velocity for that particular load as compared to the exact same load with Fed 205s. With that particular load, it was a definite problem because the load with Fed 205s was already pretty stout, and it pretty much killed the primer pockets on the test cases with the magnum primers. I was in no way expecting that much of an increase in velocity/pressure, or I would have dialed back the charge weight by a few tenths grains with the magnum primer load. Fortunately, I only used 10 pieces of brass for the test.

So any difference you might experience going from standard to magnum primers depends on a least a couple critical factors. The first is how much greater (if any) is the brisance of the magnum primers you intend to use as compared to the standard primer you already have been using. This might be a consistent general overall increase in brisance between the two primers, but there is also likely to Lot-to-Lot variance involved as well. In other words, there can be Lot-to-Lot variance in brisance even between different Lots of the same magnum primer. One Lot might be a bit hotter than another, or vice versa.

The second factor would be how hot is the load with the standard primer? If it is a mild load and there is a lot of headroom before approaching MAX, then you can probably afford to back off the load by a smaller amount when switching to the magnum primer. The bottom line is that there is no good way to predict exactly what will happen. So the wisest thing to do is simply back off the load by some safe amount with the magnum primer, then determine average velocity with a few rounds. Comparison of this value to the velocity obtained with the old primer generally makes it pretty straightforward to to dial the load (i.e. charge weight) with the new primer back to approximately the same velocity as with the old primer, especially if you use a reloading program like QuickLoad. Even if you back off the load a bit more than you might have intended, that's always better than not reducing it enough.
 
I tested 210m and 215m side by side with a chrono and there was no real difference in velocity nor accuracy.
This was in a 300winmag shooting 178amax with H-4831 (shorter range load).
 
I only use Mag Primers. Just easier to keep track of. During the last primer shortage that is all I could get. Didn't see much difference. Of course I tend to load middle of the tables. I can say when I loaded 25 gr of Varget with an 80 VLD they got pretty flat but didn't blank. I don't shoot 1,000 any longer so I don't go that high any more.
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
164,962
Messages
2,187,156
Members
78,614
Latest member
dlljr416
Back
Top