• This Forum is for adults 18 years of age or over. By continuing to use this Forum you are confirming that you are 18 or older. No content shall be viewed by any person under 18 in California.

Switch barrel hunting battery, brainstrom

I am looking into getting an action with two barrels to cover as wide a range of hunting on the west coast as possible.

Caliber-wise, I'm thinking 6.5-06 for deer, sheep, antelope, and paper. And then a 35 Whelen for elk, black bear, and moose.

For the action, I'm trying to stay on the cheaper side with a long action savage and Shilen barrels from northland shooters supply or a Howa barreled action in 30-06 (cheaper than the savage action) and barrels from McGowan. (I've also thought about a Howa barreled action in 338 win mag and then getting a 6.5 PRC barrel)

Any thoughts or comments are welcome. This could also just come down to the best two calibers that use the same case head diameter for the widest range of hunting possibilities.

(currently have a 03 Springfield and ar-15)
 
Your idea may initially sound good, but if you are going to do it and are not in a hurry, I’d suggest that you use another action other than a Savage.

Have the recoil lug pinned (if a Remington action). Spend the time and money to have the action trued, and you’ll have much better trigger and stock options out of the gate than on the Savage.

In my experience, I think it also better that you go the traditional route of having a shouldered barrel that is chambered by a reputable smith. Setting up the headspace with the barrel nut is not hard, but is certainly not as repeatable as the simplicity of a shouldered barrel. You’ll still need a barrel vise and a proper action wrench to swap barrels.

Buy a really good synthetic stock that fits you well, and you will be happier long term. Don’t just buy off the internet...find someone who owns the stock you think you want, and hold it/shoot it.

Consider that not all combinations will feed the same if you are looking at building a reliable repeater. In my experience, the straight stacking AICS mags made all but a few of my .308 based wildcats a reliable repeater in a short action Remington. IMHO, this was an additional expense that may cost as much as another rifle, but also adds complexity and weight that may not be part of your desire.

I put together 2 switch barrel rifles... one short action (.308 based) and one long acton (30-06 based). I’m a lefty, so when I was young and strong I built the short acton first...on a budget...and made my heavy barrel dream come true over time. Left Hand Remington action trued....308 barrel and .243 Ackley Improved barrel to start. McMillan A3 Stock and a Neil Jones tuned trigger and I was super happy. The feeding issues led me to the Badger AICS solution...but I’d need a custom mag to get it to feed the .22 BR barrel that I later bought (but I’m happy to shoot it as a single shot with a AICS single feeding Bob Sled...). This rifle weights about 13 lbs, which was no issue when I was young, but is now, so switch barrel #2 was begun.

My long action switch barrel was built to be carried forever. It is a long action left hand Remington 700 with a stock (but acceptably adjusted) trigger. Trued and pinned, I opted for a 25-06 barrel as my first because I had some serious neck issues and recoil did not help. With a #3 Hart and a McMillan Edge stock, the rifle weights just over 7 lbs with lightweight Talley rings and a tank of a 3x9 scope. I had planned to do a Whelan, but in all honesty I doubt I ever will...I think the largest I would go with this is .270 or 6.5-06...there is not anything I’d hunt on in North America that I couldn’t kill with that, and I’d still have the light weight that I have come to appreciate in a hunting rifle. A .220 Swift barrel is in the works for varminting, and I already know that I’ll have some feeding issues to work through to make a reliable repeater.

In the end, I really think you don’t save money making a switch barrel. If you are smart, you make one rifle that fits you like a glove that covers your bases. If I had to do it now, I’d buy 3 left hand Tikka T3’s for hunting...and probably save money (and certainly time)...but those were not options until fairly recently...

For the record, I’d built a number of Savage rifles thinking that making them switch barrel rigs would be inexpensive. I still have them, and they are very accurate, but in comparison to my other rifles, they are heavy and crude, and do not have as wide a variety of good stock and trigger options as other actions. I eventually dedicated them to 1 barrel.

Hope this helps.

MQ1
 
Everybody is going to have a little different take on hunting cartridge choices and can be debated till the cows come home but I'd say those are two pretty solid choices. If you're going to be doing much paper shooting with them, maybe consider a little smaller case for better barrel life than a 6.5-06. You could run say a 260 even though it's a long action for better barrel life and not sacrifice too much in the field.
 
HOWA'S ACTION ARE VERY GOOD BUT THE SWITCH BARREL IS A DIFFERENT ANIMAL METRIC THREADS AND LUG MADE ON THE ACTION IT COULD BE DONE BUT I THINK THE REM 700 ACTION IS THE WAY TO GO
 
Look at the West Texas Ordinance "Switchlug" to use on any action with multiple barrels. Requires unique machining of barrels, but barrels are switched in a minute with a single allen wrench, no vise, and repeatable accuracy. Great system, especially for hunting rifles for swithing in the field.
 
As a lefty, I've got two switch barrel rigs. My motivation was mostly the scarcity of LH "stuff", especially in calibers I wanted (eg 6BR and 260 Rem). It has worked out ok for me, but I don't do nearly as much switching as I thought I would. No matter how carefully you torque the barrel and record scope settings, you'll have to re-zero with each change. Also there's the matter of a single scope not covering your range of applications. If I had the choices available to a righty, I doubt I'd do a switch barrel.
 
I’m in the process of collecting parts for a switch barrel as well. I decided on a 6SST and a 7SST with options of going to any other of the Sherman short mags. You could go with a 6.5SS and a 338SS. This would cover a big range as far as use goes. A 140-150 gr 6.5 and a 250 gr or so 338 al in a short action. What’s not to like.
 
HOWA'S ACTION ARE VERY GOOD BUT THE SWITCH BARREL IS A DIFFERENT ANIMAL METRIC THREADS AND LUG MADE ON THE ACTION IT COULD BE DONE BUT I THINK THE REM 700 ACTION IS THE WAY TO GO
McGowen barrels produces a "Howage" barrel with a barrel nut
 
For the price they are, buy two Howa barreled actions in long actions in calibers you can use, and buy a nice stock that both will bolt into. Just drop the one you want to use in the stock and switch as needed.

Or buy one complete rifle and an additional bbl’d action.
 
I am looking into getting an action with two barrels to cover as wide a range of hunting on the west coast as possible.

Caliber-wise, I'm thinking 6.5-06 for deer, sheep, antelope, and paper. And then a 35 Whelen for elk, black bear, and moose.

For the action, I'm trying to stay on the cheaper side with a long action savage and Shilen barrels from northland shooters supply or a Howa barreled action in 30-06 (cheaper than the savage action) and barrels from McGowan. (I've also thought about a Howa barreled action in 338 win mag and then getting a 6.5 PRC barrel)

Any thoughts or comments are welcome. This could also just come down to the best two calibers that use the same case head diameter for the widest range of hunting possibilities.

(currently have a 03 Springfield and ar-15)
Just buy the 30-06 and go hunting. Nothing on your list will require more killing, provided you hit the right spot, than the -06 with a 180 Partition will deliver.
 
I am looking into getting an action with two barrels to cover as wide a range of hunting on the west coast as possible.

Caliber-wise, I'm thinking 6.5-06 for deer, sheep, antelope, and paper. And then a 35 Whelen for elk, black bear, and moose.

For the action, I'm trying to stay on the cheaper side with a long action savage and Shilen barrels from northland shooters supply or a Howa barreled action in 30-06 (cheaper than the savage action) and barrels from McGowan. (I've also thought about a Howa barreled action in 338 win mag and then getting a 6.5 PRC barrel)

Any thoughts or comments are welcome. This could also just come down to the best two calibers that use the same case head diameter for the widest range of hunting possibilities.

(currently have a 03 Springfield and ar-15)

a 30-06 covers everything. The wildlife Dept. in Alaska says the 30-06 is the most popular caliber and most highly recommended caliber even for grizzlies. a shocker most people don't bbelieve it till they read it.

https://www.adfg.alaska.gov/index.cfm?adfg=hunting.firearms
 
I have built a coule of swith barrel/switch bolt rifles which on the surface or the idea sounds great but the having to readjust scope settings and check zeros after every time I soon grew weary of it.

My advice - spend the money on a nice accurate rifle, good glass, buy a caliber that can cover both ends of your wants. A 270 / 30-06 / or similar, a rifle with less recoil is easier to shoot well and good glass is always a plus.

I am also in agreement with the above posted reference from the Alaska Fish & Game.

drover
 
I have built a couple of switch barrel/switch bolt rifles, which on the surface or the idea sounds great, but the having to readjust scope settings and check zeros after every time I soon grew weary of it.

My advice - spend the money on a good quality accurate rifle, some good glass, buy a caliber that can cover both ends of your wants. A 270 / 30-06 / or similar - a rifle with less recoil is easier to shoot well and good glass is always a plus.

I am also in agreement with the above posted reference from the Alaska Fish & Game.

drover
 

Upgrades & Donations

This Forum's expenses are primarily paid by member contributions. You can upgrade your Forum membership in seconds. Gold and Silver members get unlimited FREE classifieds for one year. Gold members can upload custom avatars.


Click Upgrade Membership Button ABOVE to get Gold or Silver Status.

You can also donate any amount, large or small, with the button below. Include your Forum Name in the PayPal Notes field.


To DONATE by CHECK, or make a recurring donation, CLICK HERE to learn how.

Forum statistics

Threads
165,901
Messages
2,206,073
Members
79,207
Latest member
bbkersch
Back
Top