Had a chance to look through them in a Cabela's store back in November. Compared the Whiskey 3 & 5 to a Nikon Prostaff 5 & 7 and a Leupold VX6 and a Zeiss Conquest HD5 all in the 3-15x42-44 or so range.
The Leupold was the sharpest of the bunch with the Whiskey 5 in 'second' closely followed by the Zeiss. The prostaff & then the Whiskey 3 and finally the Prostaff 5.
I ended up finding a great deal on a Whiskey 5 3-15x44 and have it on a stock Tikka T3 308. The 'clicks' are very well defined, you can really tell how many clicks you move the reticle. Glass has been about the same as my Zeiss Conquest HD5 3-15. The 'turrets' allow you to set your scope to zero once it's sighted in on both windage and elevation.
I have taken it outside after dark to see how well it does in low/no light situations and again, it's right up there with the Zeiss and my older Swarovski Habicht.
All in all, I'll be getting some more of them as they come up.
I'd still like to do a tall target test with the scope. I've 'boxed' a target and it came right back to zero as a good scope should.