This.Driving the reamer too slow will dull one in a heartbeat.
Without knowing your level of experience with cutting chambers, nor the method used no one can know whether the reamer was defective/dull from the manuf, or if it happened during your process. Not a dig, just sayin'...
The leade is the most critical part of the reamer that needs to stay razor sharp- and is also the part that receives the most use, cutting from the very start to the end (which is why many pre-bore, as it eliminates much of the cutting that would otherwise be done if the reamer cuts the entire chamber). That said, it's a non-issue with a new reamer provided you're not letting the reamer "drag" when the spindle is turning- there must be pressure applied and the flutes cutting as mentioned above.