McCormick or Timney AR trigger?

[Rookie]

I have a Knights 2 stage 3lb trigger in my SAM-R AR now but after shooting a few 100 rds through it I feel the need for a better "Competition" style trigger in-place of the 2stage "Tactical" trigger I'm using.
I been looking at both the Timney $209 and McCormick $189 drop in triggers.
Any experiences with one or the other?

 

[FroggyOne2]

I believe in my heart that you would be better off with either of these.

http://geissele.com/

Or

http://www.x-tremeshooting.com/index.php?page=X-Treme%20AR-15%20trigger

 

[Rookie]

I believe in my heart that you would be better off with either of these.

http://geissele.com/

Or

http://www.x-tremeshooting.com/index.php?page=X-Treme%20AR-15%20trigger

I've looked at both and shot rifles with both installed. The X-Treme works well and has great feel, Just don't like a 2 stage trigger. The Geissele is really no better than the Knights trigger I have now.

 

[jonbearman]

I like my jewels and have enjoyed one of them for many years. They are 2 stage but thats what I like.

 

[Greg110]

John Holiger at White Oak sells a tuned Rock River trigger that will work just fine for you until you reach high master. And the price is right too.

 

[kentuckytroutbum]

I believe in my heart that you would be better off with either of these.

http://geissele.com/

+1 on the geissele trigger. I've had both it and the jewel, and I definitely prefer the geissele. At first I didn't like two stage triggers but after shooting them for a while in competition, I found that I prefered the two stage. You take up the slack, and hold it, then do the final squeeze, and the rifle fires. The trigger also seems to "reset" faster on a two stage.

Bill

 

[Rookie]

John Holiger at White Oak sells a tuned Rock River trigger that will work just fine for you until you reach high master. And the price is right too.

I've shot John's trigger. Well done Military style trigger. But not what I'm after. I have a AR set up for NM and It's trigger is equal to the White Oak or ERP triggers.
I only plan to use this rifle for varmints. So I'm looking for a sub 2lb super crisp trigger.

 

[7x57]

I've owned and used the Knights, Hollinger's RRA, Jewel, and Geissele in my AR's. I shoot service rifle hipower. I prefer the 2nd stage break of the Geissele the most. I have 2 stage triggers in the gas guns, Anshultz and FWB rifles. I can see why you'd want that 2# single stage trigger for varmint or "bench" shooting, but a light single stage trigger in a gas gun would be prone to doubling or bump firing as the action recoils and reloads. Thats one of the reason why SR rules require 4.5# triggers to minimize that.

 

[kentuckytroutbum]

7x57-

Good point on the "doubling" of gas guns. Glad that you mentioned it in your post.